Howard Dean: Democrats should try to “tackle health reform another time”


Mike Allen of Politico is reporting on the internal Democratic Party secondary explosions from the White Flag hoisted (a la Drudge) on the public plan option.

Where, oh where is MoveOn.org now? Have they spent all their health care money and the plan is still sinking? (Note the nearly straight line down in the graph.) Intrade now shows there is a 14% chance that a public plan option will be law by Dec. 31, 2009.

Dean said on the CBS Early Show that punting to another time and space may be the best option:

“You can’t really have reform without a public option,” Dean said on CBS News’s “The Early Show. “If you don’t want to have the public option, … just do a little insurance reform … and then we’ll tackle health reform another time. But let’s not pretend we’re doing reform without a public option.”

Then there is Jim Carville, always political, also cited by Allen in Politico:

On CNN’s “State of the Union,” Democratic strategist James Carville became the first leading Democrat to suggest publicly that there might be political advantage in letting Republicans “kill” health care.

“Put a bill out there, make them filibuster it, make them be what they are, the party of no,” Carville said. “Let them kill it. Let them kill it with the interest group money, then run against them. That’s what we ought to do.”

Carville was there for the HillaryCare flame out. And, when you are already planning to blame the Republicans for the coming health care failure, you have to be pretty clear about where the politics of continuing down this road will lead — so, it is natural for Carville to blame the Republicans.

In other words, let’s keep health care alive as a political issue that can win elections, even if we let, er, uh, I mean, blame the GOP for killing it dead.

These two leading Democrats, Carville and Dean, are really telegraphing warnings and caution to their elected Democratic friends: let’s wait, let’s not pass anything, we can blame the Republicans.

And one other thing let’s not have any more town hall meetings!


RSS feed

34 Comments Leave a comment

"let them kill it with the interest group money"

Bill S (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 7:24PM EST (link)

Oh, ok Jim, you mean like that interest group money – from the pro-socialism forces – that is outspending the anti-healthcare-socialism groups by 5x? THAT interest group money?

Dipwad.

“It’s such a fine line between stupid, and clever.” – David St. Hubbins

 

yeah, that

Dan Perrin (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 7:26PM EST (link)
 

I definitely don't trust Carville and Dean.

redneck_hippie (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 7:26PM EST (link)

The game could be:

1) Lowered expectations, meaning let’s look like we’re not trying any more, then:

2) Sucker punch, meaning thrash together something compromisy and ram it through resolution-style.

3) Say anything to get the crappy bill out of the news cycle until we can pull off a midnight pusch/cloture.

4) The special interest money is a little slow,

5) Sandbag

6) Rinse and repeat


Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

argh. #2 is reconciliation-style. nt

redneck_hippie (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 8:01PM EST (link)

Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

could be

Dan Perrin (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 8:06PM EST (link)

but it also could be that the liberals are not going to lay down for no public plan, liberals like Dean.

I have talked to some Dem staff on the hill that would rather do nothing than have no public plan.

I am inclined to believe them both.

 
 
 

I wonder

WarEagle01 (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 7:36PM EST (link)

if Howitzer Explosionguy over at CNN pointed out to Carville that A. the Republicans are powerless right now and can’t actually filibuster anything and B. the really important special interests (AKA Big Pharma, AARP, SEIU, AFL-CIO, Moveon.org….the list goes on and on) have lined up solidly behind Barry on this. I’m sure he did. Had to. That’s what a real non-sycophantic journalist would do.

“A wise, doughy leg with rich tingly experiences will always reach better conclusions than will a more tanned, muscular leg that hasn’t felt those thrills.” –Chris Matthews’ Leg

“The alternative to the awful extremity of abortion is the indispensable joy of introducing this flawed world to someone who might make it better.”–John Hayward (AKA Dr. Zero)

I dunno

Dan Perrin (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 8:15PM EST (link)

I didn’t see carville on CNN, just his quote from Politico

 
 

We have the filibuster-proof majority

antisocial (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 7:37PM EST (link)

still Republicans can kill the bill. Our base is intelligent enough to believe us and then we can always enlighten moderates. And we don’t care about right-wing racists. Republicans have magical powers. They can kill the bill with 40% seats. CNN/MSNBC is doing great in the viewer market. Credit geniuses like me.

James Carville

Obama Doctrine – Boot On The Throat
—————————–
What is to be done?
——————————
No. You can’t – Moe Lane
——————————
The Emperor has no clothes!!!

 

If it take 1100 pages of lawyers lingo to reform HEALTHCARE

bobojake (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 7:37PM EST (link)

I know it is foney and I don’t want it. It time ti KILL obamacare and start with a small bill with big stick to TORT REFORM TORT REFORM, ENFORCE IMMIGRATION LAWS.
It would be amazing how much Insurance companies could lower malpractice insurance for Docters and Hospitals there by reducing HEALTHCARE COSTS.

A Doctor HAS to pay the Insurance companies the equivalent of THEIR annual salary to protect the Docter from slip and fall lawyers. There is the villians. The same holds true for Hospitals Insurance. obama was once a lawyer but he doesn’t have a license now. I wonder what happened? Just a simple question.

KILL OBAMACARE BEFORE IT KILLS AMERICA

 

So according to Howard Dean...

kowalski (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 7:42PM EST (link)

So, let’s get this straight:

According to Howard Dean, health care ‘reform’ has never been anything other than a political weapon? That’s the takeaway from this: it was never about doing anything the President said, it’s about politics with other people’s money.

Essentially he just admitted it, and testified to the single most important reason ObamaCare shouldn’t be passed in any form.

Its actually

Dan Perrin (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 8:08PM EST (link)

Carville that admitted it, Dean just wants to drop health reform and do it some other time since there is no public plan option

 
 

Yep ...

10ksnooker (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 7:43PM EST (link)

In other words, let’s keep health care alive as a political issue that can win elections, even if we let, er, uh, I mean, blame the GOP killing it dead.

TORT REFORM NOW — Get rid of the Edward’s ambulance chasers, loser pays. And while we are at it, why not admit that paying for all the illegal aliens in the USA cannot continue.

AMNESTY — Just stealing the jobs US taxpayers used to have.

 

Abandon ship....

NeoKong (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 8:03PM EST (link)

The sails are torn and the mast lay in splinters. Their crew is laying wounded all over the deck.Tea partiers are swinging in with knives in their teeth to capture the survivors. Capt. Palin on the U.S.S. Death Panel is hoisting the pirate flag.

Aaaarrggggg…..

Follow me on Twitter.

That is the way

Dan Perrin (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 8:09PM EST (link)

I see it too.

You may enjoy this, along those same lines:

http://www.redstate.com/dan_perrin/2009/08/16/the-democrats-irrational-political-behavior-on-health-care/

 
 

This Won't Fly With The Base

DavidSage (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 8:16PM EST (link)

I know if Republicans were at this point with a filibuster-proof majority in the Senate, and lopsided margins in the House, and the White House, I’d seriously consider leaving the party if we blew an opportunity like this to make a policy change that we had been fighting for generations.

Liberals have been fighting for this since FDR, and they won’t get another opportunity like this for at least another generation. The Republicans are completely powerless in terms of votes in Congress, if the public option dies, it will be at the hands of Democrats, and the base will know that.
Liberals will have good reason to purge their party, and may even start voting 3rd party.

Should be fun to watch.

agreed

Dan Perrin (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 11:43PM EST (link)

The intra-democratic party fault lines — and that does not even consider the no votes because of abortion, taxes or spending — or health reform details other than the public option

 
 

Tort reform is the key here.

jeffreywturner (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 8:43PM EST (link)

We know that meaningful tort reform is the most important aspect of ANY legitmate healthcare reform.

We also know that Democrats will never allow this to happen as long as they have the votes to stop it.

Let’s insist on it in any compromise bill and let the Democrats be the ones to kill it.

When we get about 65 Reublicans in the Senate and about 300 in the House, to go along with a committed conservative GOP President, then maybe, just maybe we will actually be able to get it passed. In the meantime, let’s just remind the public of who is in the pockets of the Trial Lawyers.

“Life is too short, can’t we all just eat pork and kill some terrorists?”

How many Dems

Dan Perrin (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 11:44PM EST (link)

will vote against the bill because there is no Tort reform?

0

jeffreywturner (Diary) Saturday, September 19th at 10:44PM EST (link)

0

“Life is too short, can’t we all just eat pork and kill some terrorists?”

 
 
 

Let's not pat ourselves on the back for a job well done yet.

Husker (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 8:43PM EST (link)

The pressure needs to be kept up by the folks to defeat this bill. This thing isn’t dead yet by a long shot.

As Dean said, the Senate will pass their version without a public option, and the House will pass their version with the public option included. The Democrats will have to write the bill into the budget without Republicans and pass it with a reconciliation vote.

The Blue Dogs may be pivoting

Dan Perrin (Diary) Tuesday, August 18th at 2:12PM EST (link)

to let’s start over, I am hearing…

 
 

But, but, but...

Leopard1996 (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 9:15PM EST (link)

They control the House, Senate, and White House by extraordinary numbers. In my world that would prove that they have no leadership or governing skills if they could not get what they wanted passed.

But then again, chickens come home to roost when you push “conservative” Dems who are looking to keep their jobs in conservative districts that they will vote conservative when it means their jobs in a year and three months.

“The accumluated filth of all their sex and murder will foam up about their waists and all the whores and politicians will look up and shout, “Save Us!”….and I’ll look down and whisper, “No”…The Watchmen

When the Democrats lost control of Congress

Dan Perrin (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 11:45PM EST (link)

after Hillarycare, no one saw it coming until 6 or 4 weeks before the election, then it started.

And the House did not even vote on the House floor on the proposal.

This means this could happen again to the Democrats, just like last time.

That would be nice to see

Leopard1996 (Diary) Tuesday, August 18th at 4:22PM EST (link)

I think this should be a major issue to ram home, with insurmountable majorities, the Democrats can’t get anything done, let alone anything done right.

“The accumluated filth of all their sex and murder will foam up about their waists and all the whores and politicians will look up and shout, “Save Us!”….and I’ll look down and whisper, “No”…The Watchmen

 
 
 

Progressives never quit

DerKrieger (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 9:28PM EST (link)

Unfortunately there is no rest for the weary. We Conservatives would prefer to just go home to our families, mind our own business, and live our lives in peace in a country whose founding documents guaranteed our autonomy and liberty. But the damn socialists are forever trying to undo the Constitution and tear down our country root and branch and thus we can never “go home”.

We cannot let the GOP reach a compromise with the Liberals because we all know that a little compromise now, a little compromise later and before we know it the Progressives will have gained everything they had originally set their eyes upon.

We have them on the run. Now is the time to force them back over the cliff and deal a mortal blow to Liberalism. The American people seem to be waking up to the fact that they have been like the proverbial frog slowly being boiled. We have been incrementally losing bits and pieces of our liberty for decades and unfortunately for Obama he turned the heat up too quickly and the normally complacent American public has felt it. Had Obama proceeded at a slower pace we might have been fully cooked but he was hungry and so set the burner on high. Well, the frog may have just jumped out of the pot in time to save ourselves.

Obamacare and any incarnation of government run health care is simply unconstitutional and must be defeated. We at least have the Constitution on our side and can force the Democrats to provide Constitutional authority for their schemes. Hold their feet to the public fire.

Strike now, strike hard from all directions.

“In questions of power, let no more be heard of confidence in man, but bind him down from mischief by the chains of the Constitution.” – Thomas Jefferson

“I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which granted a right to Congress of expending, on objects of benevolence, the money of their constituents.” – James Madison

Whenever the legislators endeavor to take away and destroy the property of the people, or to reduce them to slavery under arbitrary power, they put themselves into a state of war with the people, who are thereupon absolved from any further obedience.” — John Locke, 1690

Ah, Barry probably had the right strategy...

bannedtroll Monday, August 17th at 11:12PM EST (link)

Buy off the special interest groups to keep them quiet, and ram healthcare through so quickly, voters would never know what hit them. His problem is that he underestimated the growing impatience and anger among the public with the porkulus, auto bailouts, AIG bonus payouts, etc.

If congress had gotten a bill done before the break, the news cycle probably would have just come up with another lead story to distract angry voters. Ironically, if Obama had crafted his own bill like was done with Hillarycare instead of farming it out to Congress, it might have gotten done because the blue dogs would have used his (albeit diminishing) popularity to cover their votes, instead of having to explain all the provisions they put in the bill. Not a slam dunk, but I think we really dodged a bullet with this miscalculation on Obama’s part.

I’m a banned Democrat who came here to promote the idea that Republicans are racists for disliking Barack Obama.

 

"Progressives?"

Menlo (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 11:34PM EST (link)

I don’t give them the honor of that title. The people who call themselves “progressive” are the most regressive people out there. They want to send us to the days of outhouses, no cars, and no electricity; and they seek to stifle true progress and innovation any chance they get.

“The ultimate touchstone of constitutionality is the Constitution itself and not what we have said about it.” -Felix Frankfurter

5**5

Bill S (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 11:35PM EST (link)

I’ve been saying that for ages now. You are exactly right. For us to use that word is to cede ground to the leftists. And “leftists” is word I prefer. “Liberal” is too easy on them.

“It’s such a fine line between stupid, and clever.” – David St. Hubbins

I like Levin's suggestion

gator_hoo (Diary) Tuesday, August 18th at 9:43AM EST (link)

In his book, he uses the term “statist” and shows how “liberal” isn’t even accurate

 
 
 

Agreed

Dan Perrin (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 11:46PM EST (link)

at least we are making some serious progress.

 
 

The Party of No

6eorge Jetson (Diary) Monday, August 17th at 10:13PM EST (link)

Can seniors keep their current level of access to care???

The Dems are championing NO

 

Carville, you may recall

Adjoran (Diary) Tuesday, August 18th at 5:00AM EST (link)

“made his bones” with the 1990 upset win by Harris Wofford for a Pennsylvania Senate seat, defeating former USAG Richard Thornburgh, which was attributed mainly to Wofford’s central campaign issue of “universal health care.” Before then he had worked for both Republicans and Democrats, mostly in the South, with positive results (but nothing to write home about).

After Wofford, he went nationwide and was tapped by the Clinton campaign, selling them also on the benefits of socialized medicine. The health care debacle not only derailed the whole “Clinton agenda,” it gave the GOP the opening it needed to recapture the Congress (with major help from the House Banking scandal which nailed many prominent Dems).

Nonetheless, Carville has survived and prospered as an analyst and consultant ever since. Being a doctrinaire leftist means never having to say you’re sorry.

 

the fact that Carville is advocating

Dan Perrin (Diary) Tuesday, August 18th at 8:35AM EST (link)

to let this health care bill die at the hands of the Republicans, given his background on the issue, gives his advice on what to do about the Obamacare implosion even more weight

 

Carville: Ugly as he is slippery

Banjo Tuesday, August 18th at 9:16AM EST (link)

Can anyone explain why this weasel keeps showing up on network and cable TV? Is it because he’s married to a famous woman, a sort of minor-key mirror image of Bill and Hillary? My guess is he’s so available he available for everything down to an envelope opening.