The latest Quinnipiac poll of Connecticut voters is out, and while it is (standard disclaimer) only one poll, it shows bad news for Chris Dodd, good news for his strongest challenger, Rob Simmons, and bad news for President Obama’s health care plan.
Here’s the topline result on Simmons vs Dodd:
Former Connecticut Congressman Rob Simmons has an early lead in the Republican primary race for the 2010 U.S. Senate contest and runs better than any other challenger against Sen. Christopher Dodd, topping the Democratic incumbent 49 – 38 percent…
Former World Wrestling Entertainment executive Linda McMahon gets 43 percent to Sen. Dodd’s 41 percent…
Even potential Republican contenders with almost no name recognition and almost no Republican primary voter support give Dodd a run for his money.
Simmons leads a Republican primary matchup with 28 percent, followed by McMahon with 17 percent. No other contender tops 9 percent and 36 percent are undecided.
Connecticut voters disapprove 54 – 40 percent of the job Dodd is doing, compared to a 49 – 43 percent disapproval September 17, and say 53 – 39 percent that he does not deserve reelection.
The poll shows Dodd with a favorable/unfavorable rating of -15 (38-53) among men and -25 (34-59) among Independents, and a re-elect number of -24 (34-58) among men and -32 (30-62) among Independents, the latter mirroring the showing of Jon Corzine and Creigh Deeds among Independents.
It’s still somewhat early to judge whether any of the other Republicans in the race would be electable against Dodd; clearly, Simmons, as a moderate former Congressman, has a very real shot of winning this race, as he’s polling basically where Chris Christie was polling at this stage against Corzine. And bear in mind, this was a poll of registered, not likely voters; the likely-voter screens almost always help the GOP candidate, especially since 2010 will be an off-year election in which polls are consistently showing that voters on the Right are far more motivated and energized. Here’s the poll’s sample:
From November 3 – 8, Quinnipiac University surveyed 1,236 Connecticut registered voters with a margin of error of +/- 2.8 percentage points. The survey includes 474 Democrats with a margin of error of +/- 4.5 percentage points and 332 Republicans with a margin of error of +/- 5.4 percentage points.
I don’t have offhand the overall registration breakdowns for CT. The sample here is 38.3% Democrats, 34.8% Independents and 26.9% Republicans, as compared to 2008 exit polls showing an electorate 43% Democrats, 31% Independents and 27% Republicans. So, Republicans aren’t oversampled here; whether the poll oversampled Independents at the expense of Democrats depends on whether you think 2008 turnout is representative of what the electorate will be going forward.
Anyway, time will tell as to whether the other GOP candidates can credibly challenge Simmons. McMahon is clearly well-funded, and her pro wrestling background suggests some familiarity with the kind of populist appeal that made Jesse Ventura a governor, but Ironman at Next Right, a close observer of the CT political scene, thinks she is a poor stump speaker and too close with Rahm and Ari Emanuel and Lowell Weicker to be trusted, including a $10,000 donation to the DCCC in the fall of 2006 while it was pouring money into CT to help defeat Simmons and Nancy Johnson (McMahon herself didn’t vote in that election). $3 million in state tax credits for WWE and a heavy WWE lobbying presence in the state capitol are also not the kind of resume lines that are likely to help a populist campaign against the goodies-collecting Dodd. All of which adds up to more reason why McMahon will have a long way to go to convince GOP voters that she’s a better option against Dodd than Simmons.
As for Connecticut’s other Senate seat, up again in 2012 and presently held by an incumbent from the Connecticut for Lieberman party, Jay Cost has argued that the 2006 race shows that Lieberman needs to win over Republicans and conservative-leaning independents to keep his job, and that this helps explain his opposition to Obamacare:
18% of all voters [in 2006] were self-identified Republicans who voted for Lieberman. 14% of all voters were self-identified conservatives who voted for Lieberman. Simply put, Lieberman won that 2006 race in large part because conservative Republicans voted for him, not Schlesinger.
This means that Lieberman now has to win over voters well to the right of his old electoral coalition from when he was a typical Democrat. Losing the support of the left means he must go looking for conservatives, whom he managed to find in sufficient numbers three years ago. So, suppose Lieberman antagonizes conservatives in his home state so much that they get behind a more viable candidate in 2012. That Republican wins 20% of the vote rather than 9%. If the Democratic nominee can replicate Lamont’s 39%, Lieberman would lose.
The Q poll strongly supports Cost’s thesis – Lieberman’s poll profile is essentially that of a liberal Republican at this point, and Connecticut voters are far more skeptical of the Democratic health care plan than they are of Obama in general:
By a 51 – 25 percent margin, Connecticut voters say Sen. Joseph Lieberman’s views on issues are closer to the Republican Party than to the Democratic Party. There is agreement on this among voters in all parties.
Voters approve 49 – 44 percent of the job Lieberman is doing. He gets 74 – 20 percent approval from Republicans and 52 – 40 percent approval from independent voters, but Democrats disapprove 62 – 31 percent.
Voters say 64 – 29 percent that Democrats should not strip Lieberman of his committee chairmanship if he joins Republicans in a filibuster against the Democrats’ health care reform.
Connecticut voters approve 58 – 35 percent of the job President Barack Obama is doing, but they disapprove 48 – 45 percent of the way he is handling health care.
Note also that the poll shows that voters trust a Republican over Dodd on the health care issue, 43-37. And this is a liberal northeastern state; today’s Q poll in Ohio, which shows some encouraging news for Rob Portman, has voters disapproving of Obama’s health care plan by 55-36 and Obama’s approval rating running lower than the Democratic Senate candidates.
As a final footnote, recanvassing shows that Bill Owens – who ran against the House health care bill, although he then voted for it as soon as he was sworn in – has lost a significant part of his margin of victory over Doug Hoffman (who also ran against the House bill) in NY-23. Even assuming that the net result of the recanvassing doesn’t lead to any efforts to challenge the legitimacy of Owens’ election, the dwindling margin of victory undermines efforts to make much hay of Hoffman’s loss, and offers yet another data point – from the Northeast, no less – to suggest that support for Democrats and their health care plan is faltering almost everywhere.
If Connecticut is turning into dangerous turf for liberal Democrats and their big government schemes, that should be a sign to encourage opponents of big government everywhere to get in the game.
Steve Maley
KnightsofMalta
Liberman in the GOP?
DerKrieger (Diary) Thursday, November 12th at 1:26PM EST (link)No thanks. As much as I respect him on defense he’s still a Liberal.
Interestingly I called my own senator (Lincoln, D-AR) and recommended that she switch to the GOP. It only makes sense for her since Arkansas went for McCain last year with 59% of the vote.
If Lincoln, or any Red State Dem at high risk of losing their seat, votes for Obamacare I want to see an investigation launched into their finances or their post-Congressional career choice. There would be no other reason to vote for Obamacare except in anticipation of a payoff, financial or career. It wouldn’t surprise me at all to find George Soros behind the curtains.
“In questions of power, let no more be heard of confidence in man, but bind him down from mischief by the chains of the Constitution.” – Thomas Jefferson
“I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which granted a right to Congress of expending, on objects of benevolence, the money of their constituents.” – James Madison
Whenever the legislators endeavor to take away and destroy the property of the people, or to reduce them to slavery under arbitrary power, they put themselves into a state of war with the people, who are thereupon absolved from any further obedience.” — John Locke, 1690
The GOP is better off with Lieberman where he is
Dan McLaughlin (Diary) Thursday, November 12th at 1:41PM EST (link)but that doesn’t mean Lieberman is, or that that’s what CT voters want.
It’s premature to figure on whether the GOP has a shot at beating Lieberman in 2012. If we think we can’t, that’s when it’s time to start thinking about whether it would be worth adopting him if he wanted in.
“No compromise with the main purpose, no peace till victory, no pact with unrepentant wrong.” – Winston Churchill
Liberman will caucus with the majority no matter what
jasonmvass (Diary) Thursday, November 12th at 2:20PM EST (link)its the only way for him to go now. So when we win the Majority back, he’ll be with us, but that would have to be next year, and nobody is predicting ten pick-ups.
If Obama runs as strong in the Northeast in 12 that he did in 08 Liberman won’t win re-election anyway.
Simmons
Daniel Horowitz (Diary) Thursday, November 12th at 1:55PM EST (link)Dodd is so weak that all of the contenders are polling at least competitively against him. While Simmons is probably the strongest contender because he was already elected Congressman and appeals to many soft Democrats, I’m not so sure that we should throw in the towel and elect a RINO. To contrast CT, lets take Delaware. It is quite clear that Castle is the only RINO that can win state wide so I don’t advocate trying to run a conservative challenger. In CT, it appears that even Culiguiri and Schiff could potentially win. I still think that it is worth a careful assessment of the other candidates before we support Simmons.
Yes!! Simmons is a RINO
Ann_W (Diary) Thursday, November 12th at 4:35PM EST (link)He was pro-card check and “cap and trade”. We need to get a conservative. We could actually get a conservative!!!!!
Schiff actually understands economics. What would that be like? Amazing, I think.
“One of the great mistakes is to judge policies and programs by their intentions rather than their results.”
— Milton Friedman
The War on Poverty– forty-six years and counting!
RINO Simmons is in Favor of Cap & Tax!
jonsager Friday, November 13th at 12:02PM EST (link)I attended the July 4th Tea Party in Norwich, CT. Simmons when asked about the pending Cap & Trade declared “Not Now” when it should be “Not Ever!”. He lost my support right there and I recognize him as a RINO. Linda McMahon is cut from the same cloth.
The Republicans need a articulate candidate that promises real backbone against this liberal hogwash
Tom Foley
rocks Thursday, November 12th at 2:02PM EST (link)Hello? I have seen this poll posted all over the place and everyone fails to note Tom Foley would beat Dodd 47-41, almost as good as Simmons and far better than anyone else including McMahon and Schiff.
Simmons lead is based on name recognition alone. A name well associated with the politics of big spending by the Bush WH.
In a year which will heavily favor non-incumbents who is likely to do better? A former incumbent with close ties to DC like Simmons?
Or an outsider like Foley?
Foley is so generic on his website.
Ann_W (Diary) Thursday, November 12th at 4:40PM EST (link)It makes me wonder what he stands for. Also, is he too closely assoc. w/ GW Bush? You know that’s all Dodd has to fall back on for the campaign– they are going to run against GW Bush.
“One of the great mistakes is to judge policies and programs by their intentions rather than their results.”
— Milton Friedman
The War on Poverty– forty-six years and counting!
Running against GWB FAILED
redtillimdead (Diary) Thursday, November 12th at 7:33PM EST (link)People have moved on. If running against GWB worked, Corzine would have been re-elected in a landslide.
Nancy Pelosi can kiss my asstroturf.
Ask the D idiot Vanderhye in Great Falls, VA how running against President Bush...
JadedByPolitics (Diary) Thursday, November 12th at 7:58PM EST (link)worked…it didn’t and her commercials had Bush and Cheney and OMG Tom Delay and Comstock was shown saying she was part of the Right to Life movement for decades…….booooooo!
The voters REJECTED that insanity and the lib went home after one 2 year term! The elections were and will be a referendum on LEFTISM and the REJECTION thereof!
Unified Patriots – How-To:
Activists Taking Action
CT is different than other parts of the country.
Ann_W (Diary) Friday, November 13th at 8:00AM EST (link)Conservatives here are fiscal conservatives mostly and many are very bitter against GWB. Then add that to the Dems (which are a majority here) who hate him deep in their bones, and it’s better to start w/ a blank slate and convince them about the economic realities which people are starting to wake up to.
“One of the great mistakes is to judge policies and programs by their intentions rather than their results.”
— Milton Friedman
The War on Poverty– forty-six years and counting!
No mention of Schiff in Conn.?
GregInFla (Diary) Thursday, November 12th at 2:04PM EST (link)or do the folks here have something against him? When I last looked, I thought his views were right on target with conservatism
– A true evolutionist would let endangered species die off. Think about it.
– The sign outside the courthouse said no signs allowed. So I took it down.
– Atlas Shrugged is now on the non-fiction aisle at Amazon.
5555 nt
Ann_W (Diary) Thursday, November 12th at 4:35PM EST (link)“One of the great mistakes is to judge policies and programs by their intentions rather than their results.”
— Milton Friedman
The War on Poverty– forty-six years and counting!
Schiff
cdbymatt Thursday, November 12th at 3:03PM EST (link)I think Peter Schiff will come on strong in the next few months. He should be very attractive to Indepedents because of the outside the beltway sentiment that will be strong once the campaigning heats up. Conservatives will turn to him once they hear his views, add that with electability factor with Independents and we very well could have our Conservative revolution under way.
I hope soooooo!!! nt
Ann_W (Diary) Thursday, November 12th at 4:38PM EST (link)“One of the great mistakes is to judge policies and programs by their intentions rather than their results.”
— Milton Friedman
The War on Poverty– forty-six years and counting!
FORGET ABOUT GOOD REPS & BAD REPS,
mrbobl7388 Friday, November 13th at 7:08AM EST (link)if the Conservative will not divorce himself from the republican party he does not deserve to be elected.. The people WILL support and elect Conservatives. If the candidate is republican and uses republican money, he/she is OWNED by the republican party. Just when we need their vote as a conservative, the party can alter their vote in the name of bipartisanship. We don’t need these RINOS. We need Conservatives wearing Conservative hats, all the time…
This doesn't make sense at all
Ann_W (Diary) Friday, November 13th at 7:56AM EST (link)There are still conservatives in the Republican party. What does “owned by the Republican party” even mean? I agree that we don’t need RINO’s. But there’s nothing wrong with appealing to the remaining conservatives there and then making clear that you are a candidate of principal.
“One of the great mistakes is to judge policies and programs by their intentions rather than their results.”
— Milton Friedman
The War on Poverty– forty-six years and counting!
This is the election cycle to run
Change Jar Conservative (Diary) Friday, November 13th at 7:43AM EST (link)For those of you with political connections or who have ever considered running for one of the “smaller” jobs like a state representative or anything like it, this is the cycle to get in there.
You elected officials in Arkansas, North Dakota, South Dakota, and West Virginia — Get into a bigger race … run for Senate, Governor, Secretary of State. We need a quality candidate in every race to catch the tide.
Are you in a D+5 congressional arena and you are a local politician or even a member of a large church or large local company? This is the chance to steal a congressional seat.
Look at where and who some of the jokers the Dems got in during 2006 … that’s because the tide was theirs. Now it’s ours.
********
Formerly know as “Oz” in these parts
kepp your eye on the big picture
olddog Friday, November 13th at 10:18AM EST (link)They are now bringing the terrorists to N Y for a civilian trial. past history, shows we should be looking at what else, they are doing.
call your Senators, protesting this move by Holdren and crew. they are masters of sleight of hand , so much for transparency. so much for all the promises made. They destroy our credit,, currency ,and freedoms, and tell us they are doing a good job. In what dimension??
One Old Dog