Yesterday, Congress heard a report that yet another government bureaucracy that failed in its duties to the American people. Now, imagine what would happen if those same people were in charge of your health care.
- u have an issue w/ Santorum's opposition to individual mandates? by abierubin (Diary)
- Not AChance by CincoSolas_del_Bronx (Diary)
- Heh. Toynbee applies, Viet71. by acat (Diary)
- All of it. by NightTwister (Diary)
- Well, part of the problem by aesthete (Diary)
- plain and simple, they dont! by jack0001
- There Are A Lot Of People Thinking That Way by rightland1111
- Polls like that are tricky, brand ... by acat (Diary)
- The Left lambasts the 1% mindlessly. by Viet71 (Diary)
- Never say never. by acat (Diary)
- If actions are taken for political reasons, by Flagstaff (Diary)
- I am ABO but by jack0001
- Their focus is on the wrong thing by lastgopinillinois (Diary)
- Homosexuals are by jamesm (Diary)
- No He Isn't...But That Is Why He Doesn't Look by rightland1111
- Have to agree with bankalyst. by Flagstaff (Diary)
- I provided links just the way Leon H. Wolf requests by abierubin (Diary)
- Cassidy is by citizenkh (Diary)
- What do you get when you cross a feminist with a fetus..... by ashland_avenue (Diary)
- Did you see her speech the other night? by Warrior (Diary)
- Shame! by weyland
- So is adultery by lapert
- Care to change your mind Twist? by Warrior (Diary)
- Yep. Unless something "interesting" happens, Cassidy-Landrieu is coming... by MacAoidh (Diary)
- If We're Going to Talk about the Liberal Media, by SE-779 (Diary)
- I thought the joke was brilliantly played. by altexas
- Drive by campaign by jamesm (Diary)
- paper by Warrior (Diary)
- What? are you in by Warrior (Diary)
- Democracy by Sapient
- Pretty amusing by aesthete (Diary)
- Intrade by miconservative
- The Romney campaign ad by miconservative
- Romney Team doesn't want people to look by jamesm (Diary)
- Repaired by those who are willing to get off their ... couches... by acat (Diary)
- Delingpole has nothing good to say on Santorum either by societyis2blame
- Bill shuffling by duncer
- It's wrong to assume, but OK to observe. by deVere
- Good old maggie was a prototype by jdw4america (Diary)
- Oh, and by the way by rickc
Get Local
COMMENTS
COMMENTS
-
Herman Cain at CPAC 2012: pledges to use his new web site to encourage conservatives to become PCs!
by ColdWarrior (Diary) -
With Heartfelt Gratitude...Thank You, Daniel Hannan
by lineholder (Diary) -
The underestimation of Rick Santorum and how powerful a candidate and problem he could be for Barack Obama
by RealQuiet (Diary) -
Romney's Electability Argument is Fading-Fast
by center77 (Diary) -
A Slip of the Lip from Mitt?
by dkolonia (Diary) -
Whitney Houston Dead at 48; Connie Smith still Alive and Kicking at 71
by conservativecurmudgeon (Diary) -
President Obama Gives the Supreme Court Some Help
by Flagstaff (Diary) -
Collateral Damage
by mlgoodell (Diary) -
Three Reasons Santorum Will Lose Against Obama
by J. Leg (Diary) -
"Let's Move!" I Fully Support Michelle Obama on this one--- So, Accordingly, I've Lined Up a Mayflower Van for Her and Her Husband...
by conservativecurmudgeon (Diary) -
Moe Lane: MoeLane: #rsrh So, you hate your choices in the GOP primary. http://t.co/90xA65jV
-
Neil Stevens: McCain, Hutchison, Chambliss, Murkowski, Grassley, and others to propose their own cybersecurity bill. Good. #rsrh
-
Moe Lane: MoeLane: #rsrh "Peace Sells." http://t.co/mrSNJqV9
-
Moe Lane: MoeLane: #rsrh Sen Scott Brown: Elizabeth Warren hates freedom of conscience. And Ted Kennedy! http://t.co/Zbe33NF9
-
Steve Maley: Last Katrina FEMA trailer leaves New Orleans. #rsrh http://t.co/Tn485jYy
-
Moe Lane: MoeLane: #rsrh QotD, Been There, Done That Edition. http://t.co/Z77ubCQM
-
Dan McLaughlin: So, these Katrina victims spent 3 years in FEMA trailers under Obama. Heckuva job. http://t.co/W3XT8elu @KatMcKinley #rsrh
-
Moe Lane: MoeLane: #rsrh I just have one thing to add to Chimicanga-gate. http://t.co/RvjSJSpE
-
Moe Lane: MoeLane: #rsrh OK, I admit it: I'm probably guilty... http://t.co/RpaX4TrZ
-
Neil Stevens: Why the Democrat-driven rush to bring government control of the Internet? http://t.co/qyYNW5i9 #rsrh
- My hat's off to Rep Steve King (R) Iowa by lastgopinillinois (Diary)
- Why we fight the red herring by Warrior (Diary)
- A Winning Message to Defeat Obama: Part 1 by davenj1 (Diary)
- Sanger, the Ku Klux Klan, and Planned Parenthood by wsullivan (Diary)
- Rick Santorum = a Carbon Copy of Barack Obama! Except ... by abierubin (Diary)
- What Constitutes "Conservative Enough"? by natek58 (Diary)
- Senator Lugar is key to the GOP winning back the Senate by chrysostom15 (Diary)
- Mark Block to Release New "Smoking" Ad Sequel (Video) by Dmitriy Shapiro (Diary)
- What if implementation of Romneycare is doing to Mitt Romney what voting in favor of The War in Iraq did to Hillary Clinton? by atlasshrugs (Diary)
- Who need Congress - part 4 of 8 by conservativekaren (Diary)
- More Bad News for Newt by tooncesthecat (Diary)
- The liberals are choosing our candidate for us, and we are helping them do it. by Caiwyn (Diary)
- The Blunt Amendment: My Letter to Senator Boxer by Bryan Taylor (Diary)
- Rebuttal of Dan McLaughlin's "The Proposition 8 Decision: Not Rational" by scipio62 (Diary)
- Trevor Loudon to headline Tea Party Fort Lauderdale's Third Anniversary Event by mikeymike143 (Diary)
- I Have a Heart by mikefrey (Diary)
- James Delingpole "Why I'm rooting for Barack Obama" by wbf (Diary)
- Obama's Corporate Tax Ploy by Nikitas3 (Diary)
- Afloat in a "sea of lies" by despondentcorrespondent (Diary)
- Liberal News Media – Canned News With a Twist by littletboca (Diary)
- The True Conservative by Bethany (Diary)
- Occupy University by alandlugash (Diary)
- New Legislation Would Prevent Unions From Seizing Employee Contact Info by savejersey (Diary)
- Hostage Situation by Racist (Diary)
- Roger Stone Quits Republican Party by William E. Lewis Jr. (Diary)
- The CPAC Aftermath by Michael Francis (Diary)
- Around the U.S. in 50 Days: Florida, part 2 by davenj1 (Diary)
- New AIM Video - Imam, Priest, Rabbi: Religious Liberty and The Birth Control Mandate by accuracyinmedia (Diary)
- Veterans to March on the White House Monday. by nfloridapatriot (Diary)
- Liberal Media? Not in This Neck of the Indiana Heartland... by APA Guy (Diary)
- YOU CAN DO IT by richsr7 (Diary)
- 'Occupiers' = Greek Terrorists by Nikitas3 (Diary)
- Why aren’t we acting more responsible on foreign policy? by Tim Griffin@griffinelection (Diary)
- Fox Moving Left? by quill67 (Diary)
- What's Tony Bennett Smoking? by Rob Taylor (Diary)
- CPAC Response by kukeeamerican (Diary)
- Collateral Damage by mlgoodell (Diary)
- Around the U.S. in 50 Days: Florida, part 1 by davenj1 (Diary)
- Obama’s Achilles Heel - Americans by littletboca (Diary)
- 0.05% Military Pay Raise is Unacceptable by chrysostom15 (Diary)
RECOMMENDED DIARIES
RECOMMENDED DIARIES
GET REDSTATE BY E-MAIL
GET REDSTATE BY E-MAIL
MEMBER DIARIES
MEMBER DIARIES
SUBSCRIBE TO REDSTATE
SUBSCRIBE TO REDSTATE
RedState on Facebook

What, you dont like rationing? -nt
Alberta (Diary) Thursday, March 26th at 7:14PM EST (link)Sir, my concern is not whether God is on our side; my greatest concern is to be on God’s side, for God is always right.
Abraham Lincoln
Can't be much worse than our current health care system with HMOs and Insurance Companies Running Health Care?
wesley Thursday, March 26th at 9:41PM EST (link)Health care is the number one cause of personal bankruptcy in this country. Over one third of the folks that declare bankruptcy had health insurance.
As someone who works in the health care field, I can tell you that the current system is broken. Any voter who has spent a lot of time on the phone with insurance companies, probably would prefer a bureaucrat to an insurance company that makes extra money based on denial of care.
There are conservative solutions to the health care crises. But if legislators like you don’t start making them and keep defending the status quo, we’re gonna have nationalized healthcare.
Wow. You're capable of bringing down the average
mbecker908 (Diary) Thursday, March 26th at 9:55PM EST (link)IQ of the population of a fair sized state by probably five or six points.
I have multiple family members who work in the health care field
aesthete (Diary) Thursday, March 26th at 9:58PM EST (link)They call BS on “nationalized healthcare”. One of the problems, according to them, is that, if there aren’t enough doctors now, how are there going to be enough when the whole nation has “complete coverage”. The only solution I can see is some form of rationing–probably one that pushes the elderly, handicapped, and people who don’t follow health guidelines (eat fruit every day, don’t smoke, etc) to the back of the line, as they do in western Europe (I lived in Germany for a while).
I prefer giving tax incentives to citizens, and removing the tax incentives for businesses that provide healthcare. That way, businesses won’t just buy mass-produced healthcare that sucks to get money back on taxes, and citizens can pick their own health care provider.
The act of defending any of the cardinal virtues has today all the exhilaration of a vice – G.K. Chesterton
You can stop shooting, folks.
Moe Lane (Diary) Thursday, March 26th at 10:01PM EST (link)He’s gone.
The Kim Kardashian of blogging.
Check out my blog at http://moelane.com/.
http://moelane.com/filthy-lucre-filthy-lucre/
http://twitter.com/moelane
My (combined) wish list.
the problem
JHancock (Diary) Friday, March 27th at 2:20AM EST (link)Is that you are both right. The current system is broken because
1) With employer based health care people are isolated from the cost of their medical care and put at a “moral hazard” (look it up), of consuming health care at unreasonable rates for marginal benefits.
2) With cost shifting, we are pretty much socialized already; we just haven’t instituted rationing yet to contain costs. 14/17 patients in my hospital’s ER aren’t insured…even by Medicare or Medicaid.
Finally 3) Socialism will only make things worse because
a) Not enough physicians
b) Cost of MD education had more than quadrupled since 1980, while incomes are about half 1980 levels inmost specialties
c) Rationing will limit patient autonomy
d) The answer given will be “do the most good for the most people” which will result in cook book rather than individualized medicine, for efficiencies sake, this will screw people with unusual presentations or diseases.
In the end, neither the current employer based system, or the proposed socialist system makes any sense, and neither is a capitalist answer.
The capitalist answer–personal responsibility with individuals negotiating their own plans with the coverage and exclusions they want, then enforce their contract (America has a history of upholding contracts). This will work just like fire, or life, or car insurance. Rates will be locked in for the entire term of the contract, just like life insurance, so as long as people keep up their payments, their insurance won’t get more expensive due to conditions they are diagnosed with after locking in their rate, but just like life insurance, if they switch at 60 it might be rough. End result is longer term customers, and healthier customers in the private sector, a breaking of union bargaining chip control, and making insurance an individual decision and not a burden on industry.
Most of my family shares your view
aesthete (Diary) Friday, March 27th at 10:43PM EST (link)There are a few who buy the socialist agitprop, but with much handwringing over how one would solve those problems that you mention, among others, but considering that my family and I come from a Puerto Rican background, that’s a surprisingly conservative position for them to take.
The act of defending any of the cardinal virtues has today all the exhilaration of a vice – G.K. Chesterton
Can't be much worse?
olsmithie (Diary) Thursday, March 26th at 10:07PM EST (link)Letting you die over budget constraints, in my humble opinion, is much worse than the present system, where everyone gets treated, at the ER if no where else and the taxpayers pick up the bill.
Under Hillarycare, for example, (I have the published plan on my bookshelf right now), if the bureaucrats denied your care, the Dr. can not accept payment out of pocket without becoming a criminal. The current Daschle style plan is similar.
Having a bureaucrat say Aunt Sallie isn’t worth saving (years left/cost of treatment) and has to die is not what I consider improving healthcare…
You may want to investigate what the Obamatrons are proposing. I suspect you are not aware of the horrors of “their” system.
Let’s fix healthcare, but not their way. No way, no how.
Regards
This was in reply to the late Wesley
olsmithie (Diary) Thursday, March 26th at 10:11PM EST (link)Not sure how I keep “unattaching” myself to the reply??
Anyway, I see Moe rectified the problem and raised the average RS IQ back up several points…Thanks Moe!
Regards
Under a socialised health-care system...
david farrar (Diary) Friday, March 27th at 6:31AM EST (link)…can’t we set up a separate patient advocacy program, dedicated to addressing any and all short comings of the general government health-care system?
In terms of addressing the shortage of doctors under a socialised health-care system system, couldn’t we train first responders who aren’t doctors, whose job would be to triage patients initially and assign the correct medical facility to each?
I know this sound heretical, but we can no longer allow the growing number of uninsured Americans to go without health-care and hope to someday rein in medical costs and expenses.
Lastly, I would hope we could set up two separate health-care systems, one private and one public so that both could compete against each other thereby empowering the consumer.
ex animo
davidfarrar
It's just another layer of bureaucrats that would
Brian Hibbert (Diary) Friday, March 27th at 7:02AM EST (link)be staffed by Democrats and suck yet more taxpayer money without actually doing anything to fix a system that won’t work. Patient advocay programs would give people a FALSE hope that someone would listen to their problems and fix them.
If you would like to see a public private system in action that fits exactly your model, look at the UK. I don’t want such a system here.
Candidate for Trustee of Illinois Central College
Socialism doesn’t work. It looks nice on paper, but it’s been tried and it’s failed miserably every time (usually accompanied by widespread death and suffering).
Proud member of the V.R.W.C.
Take back our party!
Check out Unified Patriots
Two layered health
JHancock (Diary) Monday, April 20th at 1:10AM EST (link)does not seem to work well because the government will shift resources to drive out the private sector like it did in England. There is technically a private system in England, but it isn’t visable and is only for the Ferrari crowd, because to have good healthcare without European style rationing for anything close to reasonable prices you need a large number of healthy people paying in for every sick person. Thus private insurance can only be affordable if it sobs up young professionals etc. These people are unlikely to need specialized care, and as producers in society won’t be affected by rationing for many years-they will tend to take the free social system, which is only a mild inconvieniance to them. The people who will want to pay extra to get the care they want without rationing will then get increasingly older as the price gets more expensive, until only the ultra rich are paying private physicians out of pocket–you see capitalism and socalism are natural enimies and don’t play nice togather–socalism usually wins as people will take what they perceive to be free, if of lower quality, instead of paying more. Thus the capitalistic system becomes ultraspecialised and rarified and expensive, and most everyone is forced to socalism.
Britain had two systems
JHancock (Diary) Wednesday, May 27th at 11:05PM EST (link)But the Capitalist one didn’t survive. People would rather get mediocre and rationed care than pay for their own care. If we go two payer systems we’ll be a one payer system within 20 years. After all what relatively healthy person without major health concerns is going to pay for insurance if they don’t have to? Especially once all the big hospitals are feeding from the government trough and many won’t be able to do super specialized individual care as their infrastructure will no longer be setup like this?
I don't think you understand....
david farrar (Diary) Friday, March 27th at 7:50AM EST (link)…the situation we are facing here with the growing numbers of uninsured health-care recipients in this country. It is no longer a question of creating just another bureaucracy. It is a question of how to insure and cover the health-care costs of a growing number of Americans who can no longer afford to pay for their health care, period. We, as Republicans, can continue to stick our heads in the sand over this issue, as is our right, but that will not stop the number of uninsured health-care recipients from growing, nor lower the costs.
ex animo
davidfarrar
ex animo
davidfarrar
The Free Market Solution
dwarfmama (Diary) Friday, March 27th at 9:32AM EST (link)Access to health care is an issue of Supply and Demand, like any other. Medical professionals are leaving their practices at too high a rate, and being replaced at too low a rate. “Free” health care will increase demand without relieving the systemic supply shortage.
The free market solution requires (at least) a two-pronged approach:
1. Tort Reform
Due to the number of outrageous and sometimes completely unjustified medical malpractice awards, physicians are leaving their practices at accelerating rates. Others are ordering unnecessary tests and procedures to protect them from liability. Limits need to be imposed to protect them from frivolous suits and/or excessive awards.
Any Nationalized Health Care Plan will sharply curtail malpractice awards. Canada has the Canadian Medical Protective Association, which aggressively defends against malpractice claims. The cases are heard by a judge, never a jury. According to some sources, it is difficult to find an attorney willing to represent a plaintiff in such a case. Many of the same sources also claim that malpractice is rampant, with no recourse for the victims. I am not in a position to evaluate whether the claim is true.
2. Larger Enrollments in Medical Schools
The American Medical Association controls medical certification in the USA, and strictly limits the number of students who may enroll in medical schools. As a result, many well-qualified applicants are turned away. See 100 Years of Medical Robbery (I hope I did the link right).
Our contest is not only whether we ourselves shall be free, but whether there shall be left to mankind an asylum on earth for civil and religious liberty. (Samuel Adams)
But more enrolements
JHancock (Diary) Monday, April 20th at 1:12AM EST (link)means less qualified people, especially if reimbursement isn’t kept high.