The U.S. Department of Labor web site acknowledges that Labor Day originated as
a creation of the labor movement and is dedicated to the social and economic achievements of American workers. It constitutes a yearly national tribute to the contributions workers have made to the strength, prosperity, and well-being of our country.
Now there’s no harm in honoring those who labor – hard-working Americans are the backbone of the greatest free-market economy in the world…and we hope it stays that way, Obama’s socialism fetish notwithstanding.
But on this Labor Day weekend, isn’t it interesting that Gallup has just published the results of a poll showing that for the first time since the mid-1930s, less than 50% of Americans approve of labor unions?

Note that this sharp drop in union approval is occuring shortly after the implosion of the American auto industry. Gallup noted in a poll earlier this year that 43% of Americans placed “a great deal of blame” on auto unions as a cause of the problems with the Big 3. Another intriguing statistic is that union membership was up sharply in 2008 – yet their popularity is tanking.
In the latest Gallup poll, it was noted that more Americans believe that unions hurt the companies where workers are unionized than help.

Ouch!
While there is no discernible correlation between these results and other events beyond the auto industry woes, one must wonder whether there is also some latent concern about the effects of the still-simmering “Employee Free Choice Act” legislation, also known as “Card Check.” While it appears that the EFCA bill is dormant for the remainder of this year, labor leaders such as Jimmy Hoffa are seeing the writing on the wall for big Dem losses in 2010 and are now pushing for action sooner rather than later.
There is a time and a season for everything…but the season for organized labor has come and gone, and Americans have recognized this. So, to the labor unions, on this 127th Labor Day, I say “Happy Labor Day!” And while you eat your burgers and chips, just remember that we Americans are just not all that into you.
Steve Maley
Neil Stevens
Daniel Horowitz
Tipping point
RedBeard Sunday, September 6th at 7:25AM EST (link)Union workers I know on a close personal level (Teamsters, USWA, UAW) are becoming more cynical with every new political step taken by the union top dogs. These people, all old school Democrats, have always been troubled by Big Labor corruption (the Teamster refers to his union card as his “Graft Card”) but their tolerance is fast wearing thin over the ultra-leftist politics of the union bosses who are in league with Obama.
Perhaps, in a bizarre and upside-down way, we have Obama to thank for this sharp new division in labor’s ranks.
Standard-bearer for grouchy curmudgeonry since, oh, 1975 or so.
to a lot of old people the unions were like a cult
kyle8 (Diary) Sunday, September 6th at 8:19AM EST (link)I have had both in my family. Members who were in a cult, and members who were pro-union.
There was a lot of similarity. My old Uncle who was religious and very conservative in his personal life, would vote for the most far out radical lefty because the union told him to. He would vote and campaign for people who were pro abortion, pro welfare, and all the other things he disliked. And he hated Republicans with a passion, no matter how much they actually agreed with his own beliefs.
But whatever you say about the current generations, they are simply not as susceptible to that level of brainwashing, Today, people are much more cynical.
That is part of the reason I never agreed with calling the WW2 generation the “greatest” generation. They did some necessary and heroic things, but they were easily lead by the elites, they were bandwagon jumpers, they elected socialists, and they did a lousy job raising their kids which is why we got the goddamn hippy generation.
“Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty”
Kyle
My life was threatened by union thugs
4life (Diary) Sunday, September 6th at 8:47AM EST (link)when I was little, because my dad was management during a factory stike where all the office workers kept the factory going. When I was little I wasn’t afraid of the monster under the bed, I was afraid of being shot through the gap in the curtains at night. I wasn’t really supposed to know about the threats, but somehow must have heard something. So, no love for unions by me. That factory was eventually shut down and all production moved to another non-union factory.
The other fact here is that so many small manufacturers have been pushed out of business throughout the Midwest particularly, partly by unions and partly by competition from China. Now they have a big target on their back again with Cap and Trade. The big guys are exempt, the little guys will have to pay. Because Democrats are so caring.
Been there, done that, as they say
RedBeard Sunday, September 6th at 9:15AM EST (link)When I was a young foreman in a mid-sized manufacturing plant, the union called a strike that lasted nine weeks. We supervisors, along with the office staff, kept a good deal of production going. One of my jobs was to ride shotgun on company semis. Death threats, intimidation, even attempts by wolf packs of union thugs to run our trucks off the road were common.
End result? The geniuses got a 20 cent per hour rate increase. After nine weeks without pay, that really paid off for them, didn’t it?
And a few years later, the plant closed forever in the face of non-union competition. Yep, that union sure did benefit its members.
Standard-bearer for grouchy curmudgeonry since, oh, 1975 or so.
My only experience was working for a glass company.
NightTwister (Diary) Sunday, September 6th at 12:29PM EST (link)I was a project manager there, where I saw two strikes. One by the fabrication union, which was short-lived because the glaziers didn’t honor it, but later when the glaziers went on strike the fabricators did too. It’s all about which union is more powerful and can exert pressure on the other ones to honor or not.
During the glaziers’ strike, we had our front door shot out (all glass door, of course) while our office receptionist was there. Fortunately she wasn’t injured. She refused (no surprise) to site in the front office until the strike was over.
I’ve been fortunate that for the majority of my careers, unions were not a factor. There are no unions in architecture or information technology.
The best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter. – Winston Churchill
Same here, same industry
Jack_Savage (Diary) Sunday, September 6th at 1:04PM EST (link)Bottom line is that today, unions exist to extort money from their members and from their employers, and protect the bottom of the barrel, non-working, worthless, idiot employess when they are fired.
Look at every industry that has had to be bailed out, or is in bankruptcy, or has had production permanently shifted overseas and you will find heavy unionization. We are not losing manufacturing jobs, unions are COSTING us manufacturing jobs.
It's the untold story.
4life (Diary) Sunday, September 6th at 1:14PM EST (link)I only recently began talking about my dad’s experience. Just last year I was helping my daughter with her social studies homework and read a glowing paragraph about unions. I filled her in on the real facts and then shot off an e-mail to her teacher to let her know my story and that I had told my daughter about it. Since then, I have told my story several times. It just sounds unbelievable, even to me.
'Operation Scrap Obamacare' to commemorate Labor Day
njre Sunday, September 6th at 8:49AM EST (link)Announcing ‘Operation Scrap Obamacare’
Obamacare is nothing but a scam to empower labor unions, ACORN and the likes, in addition to being UNCONSTITUTIONAL!
For a long time now, most labor unions are just criminals that exploit the very people they claim to help. We must not let Obamacare further nourish the criminal elements inherent in most of the labor unions. Obamacare must be stopped!
Let us blast congress, both Dems and Republicans, throw in the media too, with the lists in the 2 files here:-
http://www.scribd.com/doc/19468659/Mass-Email-List-for-Congress-Sept2009
http://www.scribd.com/doc/19468535/Mass-Email-List-for-Media-Sept52009
Operation:
1. copy and paste the email list to the TO box.
2. type in the header box: Scrap Obamacare Now! Americans don’t want it!’
(no need to write anything in the email body.)
3. Click ‘SEND’
That is it.
It only takes a second! Do it daily from each email account. Try it. It will do wonder!
Hint:
1. save the lists to your own files for quick and easy access.
2. can mass email to many recipients at once – e.g. once to Republicans, once to all Dems, once to all media.
3. It will let you know if it is too long, then just split the list in 2.
On your marks, get set, GOOOOOOOOO !
Thank you for participating and enlisting everyone you know or on your mailing list to participate.
njre check this out
h ttp://www.scribd.com/doc/20917727/WHOARETHEBIRTHERS4-0
h ttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mpQlTN9kgfo
Don't threadjack.
Bill S (Diary) Sunday, September 6th at 2:01PM EST (link)This has nothing to do with the diary. I suggest you not do it again.
“It’s such a fine line between stupid, and clever.” – David St. Hubbins
More about union membership
Fla Mom (Diary) Sunday, September 6th at 8:53AM EST (link)Great post, bs.
I was a supervisor of federal government workers for much of the last 20+ years. Some are stellar and would be sought after by any organization. Others, not so much. Government workers are far more unionized than their private industry counterparts, which accounts in no small measure for government’s current cred on effectiveness. Hey, *someone* has to protect them from working hard and efficiently, right? If not unions, then who?
Here’s some good news from the free market perspective that relates to what you said as well as my comments:
From the Bureau of Labor Statistics 1/28/09 (BLS, at http://www.bls.gov/news.release/union2.nr0.htm):
In 2008, union members accounted for 12.4 percent of employed wage and salary workers, up from 12.1 percent a year earlier, the U.S. Department of Labor’s Bureau of Labor Statistics reported today. The number of workers belonging to a union rose by 428,000 to 16.1 million. In 1983, the first year for which comparable union data are available, the union membership rate was 20.1 percent, and there were 17.7 million union workers.”
That is, over a period of 25 years, with a rising American population, union membership *dropped* by over a million and by almost 8 percentage points, even with the little blip upwards being reported here. That’s why they need card check so badly – their only chance of reversing this trend is intimidation.
The BLS further reports:
“Some highlights from the 2008 data are:
“–Government workers were nearly five times more likely to belong to a union than were private sector employees. [Anyone think this is entirely unrelated to the 'public option?' Fla Mom]
“–Workers in education, training, and library occupations had the highest unionization rate at 38.7 percent. [i.e., the NEA--Fla Mom]
“–Black workers were more likely to be union members than were white, Asian, or Hispanic workers.
“–Among states, New York had the highest union membership rate (24.9 percent) and North Carolina had the lowest rate (3.5 percent).
“Membership by Industry and Occupation:
“The union membership rate for public sector workers (36.8 percent) was substantially higher than the rate for private industry workers (7.6 percent).”
From the American Federation of Government Workers (AFGE) on 1/25/08 at http://www.afge.org/Index.cfm?Page=PressReleases&PressReleaseID=819, “Private sector union membership grew by 133,000 and density grew to 7.5 percent in 2007, the first time private sector density grew since 1979.”
So, single-digits for private industry, with essentially no increased membership for the last 30 years, and percent of workers in unions only breaks into double digits because of government workers.
From the same AFGE press release, and related to the ‘public option,’ “The largest increase in union membership was in health services, where unions added 142,000 members, a 0.9 percent increase in density from 2006 to 7.9 percent.” Another reason that the ‘public option’ is so important to some.
Back to the BLS:
“Within the public sector, local government workers had the highest union membership rate, 42.2 percent. This group includes many workers in several heavily unionized occupations, such as teachers, police officers, and fire fighters.”
It’s interesting that the police union supported and represented Sgt Crowley in his run-in with Henry Louis Gates and that it was the firefighters’ union that voted to take New Haven to court to fight the decision against the white and Hispanic firefighters who scored well on the advancement test; why are these unions on the opposite side of these issues than would be expected based on the actions of most other unions? I know a union’s job is to represent its members to management, but there was no hesitation or confusion on the part of the police union because of the races of those involved. And in my experience at the federal level, having a union insist on maintaining *higher* standards? Ha!
Last, from Australia on 4/15/08 (http://www.smh.com.au/news/national/union-memberships-great-leap-backwards/2008/04/14/1208025090872.html), the long-term trend is similar, even though the U.S. just saw a blip upwards:
“Union membership has plunged in the past 12 months despite the central role that organised labour played in defeating the Howard government at last year’s election…. The [Australian Bureau of Statistics] found that membership fell by 5 per cent, or 89,000, in the year to last August, meaning just 19 per cent of the workforce – or 1.7 million workers – were signed up to unions. It accelerates a trend in which membership has halved since 1990. The decline has divided the nation’s labour leadership and some union chiefs – whose organisations have defied the trend and grown in the past year – are advocating a more militant approach to mobilising workers.”
They’re thinking of a new twist on the phrase, ‘If you can’t beat ‘em, join ‘em:’ ‘If they won’t join you, beat ‘em.’
Fla Mom
Time for the Republicans
JohnRichardson (Diary) Sunday, September 6th at 12:58PM EST (link)to start doing some polling about a National Right to Work Act.
I've worked for unions and for employers; both do stupid pretty well.
Achance (Diary) Sunday, September 6th at 1:01PM EST (link)When I was much younger, I worked union and was a union representative and officer. Like that old saw about how if you’re not a radical when you’re twenty, you have no heart, if you’re still one when you’re forty, you have no brain, I grew out of it. I represented the employer for over twenty years sometimes in very adversarial situations. I’ve been threatened all sorts of ways, had a dime dropped to my wife, my boss, a reporter a zillion times. Had a newly elected Democrat administration openly announce that they’d promised AFSCME to fire me in partial exchange for AFSCME’s support. Knew full well that my job was on the auction block at any gubernatorial election.
Over time, I became just as dangerous as they were and nowhere in nature do predators much hunt each other; it is a good way to get hurt. By the time I was in charge of my State’s labor relations program, the game was pretty much the old school yard dynamic of one being scared and the other glad of it. Instead of the all out war that many predicted, I became the first and thus far only since bargaining began in ’72 head of labor relations to keep them all quietly under contract and largely out of politics for an entire gubernatorial term. Since I retired from the State, I’ve worked both sides but mostly for the unions. I have to pause to thank the Palin and now Parnell Administrations for keeping up a steady supply of stupid which makes me a good bit of money.
Basically, unions are only as strong as employers allow them to be. If they’re not afraid of you, they run over you and trying to “be nice,” that Republican disease, causes them to not fear you, so they start to bedevil you. If you’re going to be successful as an employer, you have to learn to think like a Lefty and I, frankly, would not tolerate ANYTHING from them; if they did something to the employer that I didn’t like, I did something to them that they didn’t like. I’ve fired shop stewards and activists, taken every grievance to arbitration because I knew I could afford it and they couldn’t, cut off their dues; the litany is long and some of my union friends would be happy to recite it. Others developed at least a grudging respect for me and I for them and we managed to work together quite well and I enjoy working for them when they’re right. If they come to me with a case or a cause and I agree with them, I take the work. If I think they’re wrong, I tell them so and don’t take the work. That said, I’d never work for AFSCME because they’re not really a union, they’re a socialist political party, and they’d never ask me to work for them, even if they really needed me, because I’m a Republican.
In Vino Veritas
Unions are like the NAACP
jeffreywturner (Diary) Sunday, September 6th at 4:26PM EST (link)There was a time when terrible atrocities and injustices against black folks were the norm in America, and the NAACP fought for decades to change that. They were successful and most of what they had pushed for is now enforced law, so now they are reduced to scraping the bottom of the barrell and trump up rediculous issues in order to justify their own existence.
By the same token, the things labor unions fought for many years ago are now codified in law and enforced vigorously, so now they have to fight for unreasonable things in order to justify their existence.
In short, labor unions, much like the NAACP, have simply outlived their usefulness.
“Life is too short, can’t we all just eat pork and kill some terrorists?”
Not Necessary Anymore
clifwest Sunday, September 6th at 10:24PM EST (link)I totally agree. There was a time when unions worked for the common man, this is no longer the case. Had the union leaders stuck to working for its members and nothing more, the unions would have grown. Instead, the union bosses flush with power wanted more power and more control and moved into the political world to cement their position both locally and nationally. Power leads to corruption which is what has lowered its status in society and, once the public knows how the union game is played, they won’t forget and will never trust the unions again. Socialism is the meal ticket for the unions and they invested heavily in Obama being elected, now they expect Obama to reciprocate at the expense of the American people. All the unions and Obama want is for the American people to shut up, pay their taxes and let the new Socialists run our nation from now on.
Clifton L. West