New York state – under the leadership of Governor David Paterson – is getting ready to dramatically raise taxes on those earning greater than $250K. And faced with the threat that people earning this kind of money might move themselves or their businesses to lower-tax jurisdictions, liberals seem completely unconcerned. Indeed – if you take Rush Limbaugh as symbolic of the rest of these high-earners, they seem positively giddy. Jon Stewart takes the same tack as lots of compassionate liberals; he implies that Limbaugh is a homophobic, drug-addict with a taste for murder, and that New York is better off without him.
Governor Paterson is also eager for Rush Limbaugh to get out of town:
Rush Limbaugh is fed up with taxes in New York and with Gov. David A. Paterson in particular. The radio talk-show host denounced the so-called millionaires’ tax in the new state budget and then announced on the air this week that he would be packing up and leaving town…
“If I knew that would be the result,” he said after a speech Thursday morning in Midtown, “I would’ve thought about the taxes earlier.”
Hee hee! That Paterson is a card!
Let’s see if he laughs as hard when top-earners and small businesses start leaving the state. Because while Limbaugh makes a nice punching bag, this isn’t about one person; it’s about the hundreds of thousands of ‘wealthy’ people who face the same decision Limbaugh has made.
As Paterson himself argued just a few weeks ago – when he opposed higher income taxes – raising taxes will drive out jobs. Paterson himself said that 140,000 people leave the state every year, due to New York’s anti-competitive tax structure – which will get worse under his budget plan. It seems that fans of higher income taxes have to test the theory though; some are even trying to argue that raising taxes creates more wealthy people (as if the economy today is the same as it was in 2003).
According to the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, New York City has more than 86,000 taxpayers earning more than $250,000 annually. The state has more than 200,000 such high earners altogether – and recall that many of these ‘taxpayers’ are likely small businesses. How many will be driven out of the state? How many businesses will close or relocate, and how many jobs will be lost?
Democrats chuckled when they were warned that higher taxes on boat sales threatened the yacht industry; they ended up killing it. And when Rudy Giuliani was elected Mayor of New York City in 1991, taxes were so oppressive that his tax cuts led to tremendous increases in revenue. It looks like Paterson is trying to go back to the future. And it may lead Rudy Giuliani to get elected again – this time as Governor.
Steve Maley
KnightsofMalta
Suggestion for Governor Patterson....
donnac1188 Friday, April 3rd at 3:28PM EST (link)Run, don’t walk, to your nearest library and pick up a copy of Atlas Shrugged in Braille or on tape…
140K leave already??
phxg (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 3:37PM EST (link)And he plans to exacerbate that flight with more taxation and oppressive government policy. Talk about unclear on the concept.
It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it. –Aristotle
To be realistic about it,
Flagstaff (Diary) Sunday, April 5th at 12:12AM EST (link)most people, whether they make $25,000, or $250,000, or $2.5 million per year are hard pressed to pull up stakes and more because their state taxes are raised. It would, for most, entail losing that particular income and having to find something to replace it at the new location. Rush Limbaugh’s situation is not unique but it is far from typical.
For those people who are affected by the new tax who are employees, they have only the choice of staying or quitting or maybe asking for a transfer. If they’re small business owners, how many of them can practically change locations? The only businesses who can actually move are BIG businesses, and the people at the top there prefer to pay the tax and enjoy the luxury of being big worms in the Big Apple.
Heck, it’s taken years for the defection of readers (perhaps mostly conservative) to take its toll on the NY Times, et al. Yet many other conservatives still buy the paper without realizing they’re actually hurting themselves by doing so.
The migrations out of New York can and should take place, but they take years, not months, to have an effect. The quicker cure is for the folks who are living in New York to apply political pressure to party leadership to change the laws, while doing what they can to prepare to migrate.
“The press is so powerful in its image-making role that it can make a criminal look like he’s the victim and make the victim look like he’s the criminal. If you aren’t careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed and loving the people who are doing the oppressing.”– Malcolm X, Audubon Ballroom, December 13, 1964
Mayor Bloomberg himself warned against raising state and local taxes a few weeks ago due to its effect
Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Sunday, April 5th at 12:15AM EST (link)on the 40,000 taxpayers in NYC that pay over half the taxes. He caved recently.
Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson
Agree with you about the $250K or $2.5M income
Achance (Diary) Sunday, April 5th at 10:11AM EST (link)being hard to replace and that keeps you place-bound. However, I think it is very easy for young people and average wage earners, say under $75K to pull up stakes and go where the grass is greener.
The big problem these days is that house we were all so proud to buy not so long ago. As somebody else noted, being upside down in a house is what’s keeping a lot of people in places that are steadily becoming more and more oppressive. Of course the politicians that represent the looters and moochers know that, so they tax the homeowners relentlessly. Back during the mid-eighties crash here, the preferred method of dealing with being upside down in a house was to drop the keys in the bank’s night deposit box on the way to the airport or ferry terminal.
And of course, there’s always inertia and habit. It is very easy to be comfortably uncomfortable – which is why I remain in one of the more expensive places in the Country while on a fixed income other than any consulting I can hustle.
In Vino Veritas
I hear your regarding "inertia and habit"
civil truth (Diary) Sunday, April 5th at 10:22AM EST (link)More later…
The greatest evil…is conceived and ordered (moved, seconded, carried, and minuted) in clean, carpeted, warmed, and well-lighted offices, by quiet men with white collars and cut fingernails and smooth-shaven cheeks who do not need to raise their voice. Hence, naturally enough, my symbol for Hell is something like the bureaucracy of a police state or the offices of a thoroughly nasty business concern. -C.S. Lewis
http://www.gmsplace.com/
You hit the nail on the head Achance.
mbecker908 (Diary) Sunday, April 5th at 10:35AM EST (link)Housing has moved from being “the great American Dream” to being the great American Handcuff. Our homes used to be our nest. In the late ’90′s and the first half of this decade they became a line on our personal balance sheet and now they are just “a house”.
A house can be an anchor, in more ways than one.
Flagstaff (Diary) Sunday, April 12th at 1:23AM EST (link)Your comments are very true, I believe. The unsellable house can be a big factor in keeping anybody in place, regardless of income level. We also need to note that the level of income that would prod one to move because of oppressive income tax rates is probably north of $250,000 in most states. At $50,000 or less the tax burden is pretty much ignorable.
Anyway, my personal experience is that it takes a lot to make any husband and father quit a rewarding and steady job because his income was being nibbled away at the edges. A single person, maybe, but usually not a bread-winner.
“The press is so powerful in its image-making role that it can make a criminal look like he’s the victim and make the victim look like he’s the criminal. If you aren’t careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed and loving the people who are doing the oppressing.”– Malcolm X, Audubon Ballroom, December 13, 1964
Flagstaff, I was more surprised in the # of loss
phxg (Diary) Monday, April 6th at 2:51PM EST (link)It’s not a huge percentage of the state population, and compared to the whole of NY and that Phoenix alone gets 100K/yr coming in, I find it telling.
I personally do not believe it’s the high wage earners leaving as much as the younger, entry to mid-level folks who can pull up stakes. However, how many of those people leaving are doing so to start a business in a more friendly environment? That is a huge loss of revenue never realized by the state.
But yes, he is unclear on the concept because it is those high wage earners (business owners or not) that provide a big chunk of revenue flow within the economy to pay for the $40k/yr people. If that money is confiscated, THOSE people who do pay state sales taxes will leave in greater numbers and impact the system even more. And if they stay, they will demand more public services.
It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it. –Aristotle
I understand, Phxg.
Flagstaff (Diary) Sunday, April 12th at 1:32AM EST (link)I agree. My guess is that most of the outflow are retirees and the unemployed. That number may not even be moving up very fast. I suspect that it was once offset by an inflow of us country bumpkins who had gradjeeated from collidge and were moving to NY to work for a major corporation. Those companies just aren’t hiring much today.
Still, anybody who is able to move away from NY but doesn’t must have a reason that offsets the tax disadvantage, or they just aren’t thinking.
“The press is so powerful in its image-making role that it can make a criminal look like he’s the victim and make the victim look like he’s the criminal. If you aren’t careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed and loving the people who are doing the oppressing.”– Malcolm X, Audubon Ballroom, December 13, 1964
The exodus is already beginning in Orange County
Scipio (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 3:43PM EST (link)There was news in the local paper this week that a major employer in Port Jervis is considering a move to El Paso, TX.
CEO of Kolmar Labs stated that New York was “not friendly to business.”
See: http://www.recordonline.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20090402/NEWS/904020334
It is important to note that Port Jervis is not only in business unfriendly New York, but also in Orange County and the NY-19 Congressional District, both of which are experiencing blue shift.
Minnesota's seen the same
Next93 (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 5:53PM EST (link)Major icons of business in Minnesota have left or moved part of thier operations out of state over the last decade: Honeywell’s not headquartered in New Jersey, Northwest Airlines headquarters moved out after the Delta merger, even though it was going to cost the new airline $250M in penalties, 3M has moved all growth operations to El Paso.
Somehow, the liberals in this state just don’t seem to see the connection.
Obama was The One in 2008.
He’ll be a BIGGER one in 2012.
An interesting interpretation
nvgpete Saturday, April 4th at 8:28AM EST (link)given that Rudy Perpich, the last democratic governor, left office in 1991, and that Tim Pawlenty has allowed essentially no tax increases of any kind over the last 6 years. Further, taxes were lowered substantially during the preceeding Ventura administration. The legislature has had a mixture of democrat and republican control, but not sufficient to override vetos.
Veto override last year, on a tax increase bill
Next93 (Diary) Sunday, April 5th at 5:49PM EST (link)The dems have been in control of the state house for several years now. The republicans who broke on the veto now have virtually no hope of reelection, though. The veto was followed less than a year later with a constitutional ammendment to increase the sales tax for special interest groups (Twin Cities arts groups and outstate environmentalists). Big gas tax increase to be phased in over the next couple of years.
Pawlenty has not been effective in attracting business back to the state; aside from the corporate taxes (which were not decreased under ventura), the workers comp rates and other business permitting costs remain too high. Delta was pretty clear about this in its refusal to even consider headquartering in Minnesora.
Obama was The One in 2008.
He’ll be a BIGGER one in 2012.
Everyone I talk to in California is looking for a way out
JustLeaveMeAlone (Diary) Sunday, April 5th at 9:54AM EST (link)Just last night I was on the phone with a friend from San Diego. He’s giving his litany of problems — people being laid off, businesses going belly up, tenants not paying the rent, taxes on his truck tripling. And I said, well heck, that’s because of where you live.
I KNOW! he yells… then goes into a 15-minute rant about how he has to move out of the state and where he’s looking at moving and what it will cost him and how much he hates California right now.
When I told him that state income taxes were unconstitutional in Texas, he asked me to pick up real estate brochures and send them to him. I think he’s serious.
“To compel a man to subsidize with his taxes the propagation of ideas which he disbelieves and abhors is sinful and tyrannical.” Thomas Jefferson
California trapdoor
izoneguy (Diary) Sunday, April 5th at 10:01AM EST (link)My parents lived in San Jose from 1987 until about 1998
They really wanted me to come out and see how great it was.
I admit – back in the late 80′s it did look inviting. But I just visited ever year and noticed by the late 90′s how much it had changed. Gang fights were a daily occurence just a few miles from there house, and these were decent neighborhoods. My dad finally had enough abd they moved over the border to Minden, NV. The only problem there was that my mom & dad enjoyed the casinos a little too much, so they finally moved back to Texas in 2005. I see parts of Texas slouching towards socialism but for the most part we have drawn the line in the sand. “Remember the Alamo!!”
The point cannot be made often enough: Modern liberalism, as embodied in the Obama presidency, is the defender of the status quo. And the status quo is a road to economic ruin. Political forces cannot redistribute the wealth that the economic system does not produce.
Make sure they fly to Texas.
mbecker908 (Diary) Sunday, April 5th at 10:01AM EST (link)I don’t want them driving there because they’ll have to go through Arizona and, since they are emigrating somewhere from California and they are NOT welcome here.
The exodus is already beginning in Orange County
Scipio (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 3:43PM EST (link)There was news in the local paper this week that a major employer in Port Jervis is considering a move to El Paso, TX.
CEO of Kolmar Labs stated that New York was “not friendly to business.”
See: http://www.recordonline.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20090402/NEWS/904020334
It is important to note that Port Jervis is not only in business unfriendly New York, but also in Orange County and the NY-19 Congressional District, both of which are experiencing blue shift.
Seriously?
Jay_Cee Friday, April 3rd at 5:18PM EST (link)I’m not surprised business taxes in El Paso are cheap – that’s because everyone who is able is fleeing El Paso as fast as they can.
Government business taxes may be cheap, but you gotta factor in “protection” costs from the Mexican Cartels…
You seriously could not pay me enough to move to El Paso.
Seriously, it's true.
Rod_Patrick (Diary) Saturday, April 4th at 9:06AM EST (link)Many businessmen in the Northeast are starting to think of moving to capitalist-friendly states.
No state income tax.
JustLeaveMeAlone (Diary) Sunday, April 5th at 9:56AM EST (link)No snow.
No one comes after you if you use your gun for protection.
Those are just 3 reasons to think about El Paso.
“To compel a man to subsidize with his taxes the propagation of ideas which he disbelieves and abhors is sinful and tyrannical.” Thomas Jefferson
Vote With Your Feet
DavidSage (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 3:55PM EST (link)My only problem with an exodus is people is they tend to take their blue-state voting habits with them. They’re like locusts, they ruin one state, and them move on to the next one.
I live in AZ, which used to be quite conservative and pro-business, but people from places like California and Illinois have moved here in droves and have turned the state “purple.”
I am glad affluent voters are starting to see the consequence of electing Democrats. Wealthier people in affluent suburbs had been moving into the Democrat Party at an alarming rate (mainly because of social issues, imo) I’m glad they’re starting to see that Liberal policies actually DO hurt their well being.
Don't bring your "values" with you...
JChesney (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 10:01PM EST (link)David,
You are absolutely right. The libtards are famous for destroying their own “homes” , and then hauling butt when things (that they brought on themselves) go wrong.
The first thing they do when they set up shop in their new locale is to start cramming their beliefs down the throats of the unsuspecting community that let them in. Thus we now have states like Virginia and North Carolina turning blue.
I live in north Florida, home to two naval bases, and this was a pretty strong conservative area. Unfortunately, the carpetbaggers have been moving to Florida in record numbers and bringing their crap with them.
Do I feel sorry for them? I used to. Do I want them here now? No way. They need to learn that they reap what they sow, and elections DO have consequences.
I have had it with Californication!
Achance (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 10:34PM EST (link)I want to build a twenty foot wall around the place to keep them in.
In Vino Veritas
Hey, I wasn't born here :)
drothgery Saturday, April 4th at 5:20PM EST (link)… and really, as long as I can afford to live here, I don’t want to leave. I mean, no matter how much the donkeys mess up the government, San Diego is still San Diego. But my employer was going to move me to Colorado before they decided to lay off 10% of the IT department (including me), and I still may very well end up there; I’ve got family in Denver, and I don’t know how long I can deal with CA taxes.
And I thought that Colorado
Flagstaff (Diary) Saturday, April 4th at 11:55PM EST (link)was the new California. Maybe it will be soon.
“The press is so powerful in its image-making role that it can make a criminal look like he’s the victim and make the victim look like he’s the criminal. If you aren’t careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed and loving the people who are doing the oppressing.”– Malcolm X, Audubon Ballroom, December 13, 1964
Thank God for upside down mortgages
jackbenimble (Diary) Sunday, April 5th at 8:09AM EST (link)Upside down mortgages are like a ball and chain on Californians. Otherwise the whole country would be getting Californicated.
They ruin whereever they go. I think they should enjoy about the same status as illegal aliens.
“I repudiate the idea of voting for a Democrat
55555! nt
Rod_Patrick (Diary) Saturday, April 4th at 9:08AM EST (link)Beggars cannot be choosy
franklinslocke Friday, April 3rd at 4:16PM EST (link)Guns don’t kill people. Bad, crazy people do. If you want to save lives outlaw cars. They kill more people than guns do. This guy would have killed people with what ever he had if really wanted to kill people. He could have used his car if he did not have a gun.
http://franklinslocke.blogspot.com/
Poor John Stewart
WarEagle01 (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 4:25PM EST (link)That little guy would be lost without his many writers. He is hopelessly unfunny without his cue cards.
“A wise, doughy leg with rich tingly experiences will always reach better conclusions than will a more tanned, muscular leg that hasn’t felt those thrills.” –Chris Matthews’ Leg
“The alternative to the awful extremity of abortion is the indispensable joy of introducing this flawed world to someone who might make it better.”–John Hayward (AKA Dr. Zero)
He's not as funny as he thinks, even WITH his cue cards
Next93 (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 5:55PM EST (link)N/T
Obama was The One in 2008.
He’ll be a BIGGER one in 2012.
Don't blame Jon he has 2 last names
bobojake (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 10:15PM EST (link)and isn’t funny either
No joke for all New York Staters
fisk2521 Friday, April 3rd at 4:31PM EST (link)It’s beginning to occur to people in upstate that the writing is on the wall. It isn’t only people who make over $250,000 that are going to be hit hard with more Democratically inspired taxes from albany, but everyone who pays for electricity, natural gas, gas at the pumps, resigration fees for their cards, sales taxes, property taxes (out of sight in NY – upstate and NYC). Upstate is a different world than NYC – - there’s little in common between the cultures and quite frankly elitist attitudes from NYC that I’ve never quite understood.
The population is actually decreasing for years and has been under the oppression of taxes. Industries have left, and residents are looking at costs to live in homes that are already paid for that will put them into bankruptcy.
Should Paterson and the liberals laugh at Rush leaving – - God no!!!! It’s no joke for any of us and hopefully it will be no joke for Paterson when he gets his rearend handed to him at the next election.
LDavis
I guess Patterson can laugh all he wants, but...
Husker (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 6:21PM EST (link)didn’t Rush just sign a deal for 8 years worth $400 million dollars?
That seems to me like a whole crapload of tax receipts just migrated to Florida.
Rush lives in FL
peg_c (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 8:48PM EST (link)He has explained that he is in NYC maybe 14 days a year due to hurricanes, so they can maintain the show broadcast. He can easily do this elsewhere and Texas is wooing him. He has been audited every single year since leaving NYC for FL and he has to prove a dozen different ways exactly his whereabouts those days he works in NYC. I’m glad he’s leaving and taking his taxes with him – I wish everyone would. This governor is a trainwreck and an idiot. His loss will probably be Texas’ gain.
Government cannot be the solution when government is the problem.
Not only Rush but Athelics that come into NYC
bobojake (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 10:17PM EST (link)to play ball games. I think its would be time to get the heck outta dodge.
Audit the auditors
anotherindyfilmguy (Diary) Sunday, April 5th at 10:51AM EST (link)Shouldn’t the “Justice” department be looking into auditing the auditors who go after Rush like that? To me it seems like a politically motivated abuse of office/witch hunt etc… quite frankly it should have been nipped in the bud the second/third time they did it and showed an abusive pattern… in this case the seed of corruption and abuse has grown so far in NY they need to weed the garden ’cause the buds been long sprouted and grown to fruition…
Santorum? Well, at least he’s not Romney…
http://www.zazzle.com/enemy_of_the_statist_tshirt-235977043035297478
Just check out which states are Red vs. Blue
texas214 (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 4:42PM EST (link)You’ll find the states with the highest growth are the ones with the lowest taxes and right to work (non-union) laws. The problem is that Zero wants to make the rest of the USA look like Michigan, New York, Illinois, Mass. and California.
If Patterson thinks that New York (really meaning NYC) is so special that people will pay what ever preminm asked, he may have another thing coming. With the expansion of technology business is becoming more fungible and can be conducted anywhere. If I ran a hedge fund there would be no reason to be in NYC as trades can be made from anywhere at anytime.
Going National
Skanderbeg (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 6:00PM EST (link)Well, I was going to add what you added – that Mr. Zero, Mr. Reid, and Ms. Pelosi do indeed want to take tax dysfunction national.
Then we can watch flight from *the country.* Hey, what do these people think has been driving “outsourcing” for all these years? If they tighten the thumbscrews even more, more than just “jobs” will go to other jurisdictions….
You will also find they are warm
candoo2 (dkos funluvn1) (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 6:45PM EST (link)and inviting to new business.
Warm is the sirens call. A welcome sight is new business and that is the hope for work that these citizens are following. Like when the textile businesses were in the NE (CT, MA, NY) and them moved south.to North and South Carolina, Georgia, etc. Then those jobs moved overseas.
There must be something happening that causes jobs to move from one place (NE USA) to (SE USA) to overseas.
I have a pretty good idea why that happened.
Overseas is warmer, right?
I make crude sexual jokes about conservatives.
Anecdotal, I know, but I have a family member who's bailing out of NYC
Slightly_Askew (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 5:26PM EST (link)Has his own firm and is looking to move to the midwest/south. His business pretty much demands a heavily populated area, so he is looking at Little Rock or Nashville.
I prefer Amy Lee singing over any
candoo2 (dkos funluvn1) (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 6:47PM EST (link)Nashville star, so in my opinion, Little Rock would be my choice.
Well, that and the fact that my family is from AK.
I make crude sexual jokes about conservatives.
Arkansas is AR, Alaska is AK -
Achance (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 6:51PM EST (link)Wish I had a nickel for every time some package or letter of mine has travelled several times around the World because people can’t seem to get that.
In Vino Veritas
AL
Skanderbeg (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 6:56PM EST (link)Huh? I thought Alaska was “AL”….
No, AL is Alabama.
Achance (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 7:00PM EST (link)Interestingly, we don’t get confused too much with AL, though it makes sense to confuse the two. There’s just something about Arkansas. Last year I ordered my boat name in a vinyl decal from some outfit back East. I got some guy in Arkansas’ registration numbers and he got my boat name. Happens at least a couple of times a year.
In Vino Veritas
Where are these Arkansans and Alaskas? And where is "Carolina"? - nt
Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 6:58PM EST (link)Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson
I was brought up to think that Carolina was to the east
Achance (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 7:02PM EST (link)of Georgia and North Carolina was to the north. There was only one Carolina, the other one had a North in front of it.
In Vino Veritas
amen - 55555 - right answer! - nt
Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 9:39PM EST (link)Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson
It's easy to remember the difference.
Tbone (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 7:04PM EST (link)The rednecks in AK wear coats. The rednecks in AR wear blue smocks.
Envisioning when all that is Left is the Right.
The real rednecks in AK
Achance (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 7:15PM EST (link)don’t wear coats. It’s a badge to walk around in obscenely cold temperatures in a tee shirt and shorts. All kids MUST have a Godawful expensive Columbia or Helly Hanson coat, but they won’t wear it and if you make them, they’ll just “lose” it somewhere. They also insist on wearing shorts at twenty or thirty below.
Actually, you learn after a while to not shiver by just tensing your muscles, so you can play tough guy by standing out in truly frigid temperatures in your shirtsleeves seemingly comfortable while someone who isn’t used to it is shivering uncontrollably. I used consider it good clean fun to go out and have a smoke and if some DC type wanted to talk with me, he had to go with me. I’d just “comfortably” have a smoke – or two – while he shivered miserably.
In Vino Veritas
Taxes aren't the problem
rhbee Friday, April 3rd at 5:47PM EST (link)It is the fear of them that causes the “red flight” described above. It is the fear of the flight/loss of business which allows politicians to override community concerns and infrastructure issues, It also creates a non-thinking response to the what and why of taxes in the first place. Apparently no one here noticed that a majority of the voters in the US voted in favor of changing them.
In one or two comments above the writers conflated (I love that word’s resemblance to flatulence) individuals who make over $250K and small businesses which make over $250k. But under current tax law and definitely under Mr. Obama’s administration they are NOT the same.
Also, while the reason folks might choose to flee (other than Rush’s thinly disguised need for attention) instead of pay a slightly higher share to stay, is an understandable choice. Using that same reason to bludgeon voters into lowering taxes to keep them is actually unethical and borders on the immoral. I know it is and has been a common practice. I live in Northern San Diego County where the housing boom has produced thousands of over-priced homes, extremely crowded roadways, and an ever widening shortage of energy, water, trash facilities, and now jobs. All because we let the politicians operate on the principal attracting of BUSINESS in the name of lower taxes.
On the other side of this arguement may not be the laughter that your headline suggests. It may be relief that finally we may be see an economic reason for using the ideas of LESS IS more. And oh yeah, maybe the idea that someone would leave NYC for El Paso.
The problem is the parasites that flock to urban areas
Achance (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 6:16PM EST (link)and the taxes, crime, and general unpleasantness the looters and moochers bring about causes all the productive people to leave for someplace more pleasant. Since practically every city in America has become a Democrat controlled cesspool, BHO, the leader of the moochers and leaders now has to nationalize the taxes, unionization, etc. to try to get the productive people to continue to support the looters and moochers. I feel a shrug coming on and I think I need to go clean my guns.
In Vino Veritas
[I'm a nasty troll]
rhbee Friday, April 3rd at 6:31PM EST (link)[... And I'm Ok. I sleep all night and get banned all day. I think it's cool, if I tell people to blow their brains out. No, that doesn't really rhyme does it. Guess I'm a troll AND a tool.]
This moment of Zen brought to you by Caleb. Hit the contact form with your complaint. I’m in need of a chuckle. Buh-bye now.
Putting things in their mouth is a trait more associated
Achance (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 6:42PM EST (link)with people on your side of the political ditch.
Democrat politicians run most of the urban cesspools in this Country. Those cesspools have largely chased out all of the people who do anything other than loot or mooch. At best the productive people are allowed to come in and work from eight to five. They all too commonly pay with their lives for exceeding the alloted stay.
I really think you’d be happier someplace else. Perhaps with the psychos on Kos.
In Vino Veritas
Suggesting violence against a commenter isn't the best strategy
Bill S (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 6:43PM EST (link)An apology might be in order.
“It’s such a fine line between stupid, and clever.” – David St. Hubbins
I don't want it, wish he/she/it was a little closer though. nt
Achance (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 6:45PM EST (link)In Vino Veritas
Why?
candoo2 (dkos funluvn1) (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 6:56PM EST (link)Because he/she/it hit the mark on local politics? No doubt that is true.
Let us be civil here and clean our guns after hunting or target shooting. The instance on simple violence with guns clean or dirty in remarks here are pure silliness.
C’mon everyone. We are together here to make a difference in the political world. Let’s find a way to do so that doesn’t include shooting but insists on thinking better than those that oppose the conservative ideals.
We win on ideas.
Anyone and everyone, what are your ideas to get over the hump? We need ideas.
I make crude sexual jokes about conservatives.
Shoot the hump.
Tbone (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 7:01PM EST (link)How’s that for an idea?
Envisioning when all that is Left is the Right.
Limited
candoo2 (dkos funluvn1) (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 7:07PM EST (link)yet still an idea
I make crude sexual jokes about conservatives.
silly on many levels
streiff (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 7:01PM EST (link)The idea that taxes, per se, necessarily do something beyond destroy wealth is simply silly. Having lived in Washington, DC for over a decade and looking at what I got compared to what was available in lower tax Virginia, I speak from some experience. If you think the majority of Americans voted to increase taxes you might want to inform the White House because the guy who won promised not to raise them on anyone making less that $250K.
Simply bogus. How the money is treated depends on how the company is organized. A sole proprietorship, partnership, LLC, or S-Corp would almost certainly, absent heroic efforts at tax avoidance, be hit.
It is sort of strange entering a parallel universe where the notion of keeping more of your own money is immoral. The fact is that if businesses an high earners move away, the tax base erodes. If you want NYC to look like Detroit you are certainly recommending the right strategy.
“What keeps me here is the reek of beer, the ladies and the craic”
Yet NYC will not look like Detroit
candoo2 (dkos funluvn1) (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 7:13PM EST (link)due to the fact that people of means WANT to live there and they don’t want to live in Detroit for the most part.
Those with enough money to not fear the taxman don’t move to Omaha to get away from the taxman. Those with not enough money to just up and move to another state without a promise of a job don’t do that either.
I make crude sexual jokes about conservatives.
Study history much, candoo2?
Achance (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 7:22PM EST (link)This Country was built by people who just “up and move(ed)” … “without a promise of a job.”
In Alaska in the late 70s and early 80s we used to refer to the “black and whites” because the license plates of most of the “Rust Belt” states were white with black lettering. We had an endless stream of pickups that looked like they were out of the Beverley Hillbillies because people had packed up family and possessions and headed “North to Alaska” to seek a better life. And perhaps you’ve seen a movie or even read a book by that Steinbeck guy who wrote about the exodus of people from the rural South and the Midwest Dust Bowl to California in the depths of the Great Depression – that real depression not the media contrivance we’re “enduring” now.
And that’s just the current events version. A real History would tell you a lot more about people leaving everything for the merest hope of opportunity.
In Vino Veritas
In Alaska in the late 70s and early 80s we
Paul_In_Houston Saturday, April 4th at 12:29AM EST (link)used to refer to the “black and whites” because the license plates of most of the “Rust Belt” states were white with black lettering.
During that period, the blue plates with white lettering, from Michigan, seemed to outnumber the local plates here in Houston.
BTW – We respected them, because instead of whining about their lot in life, they were the ones who DID something about it, by moving down here where the jobs were. A documentary about that period noted that about a million people came here looking for jobs, AND FOUND THEM.
-
That's far better than many of the media stories
JoeG Saturday, April 4th at 1:05AM EST (link)I often hear about the woe is me stories in the media about the unemployed.
So far I’ve always had the luxury of being able to find something on my own schedule. But if I ever were sent out the door with nothing in sight soon, I would be looking for jobs without geographical limits.
I have a smallish RV that I could live in until I had the ability to sell my house and relocate my family to my work. People have done the same thing for a very long time.
I just don’t understand those that think otherwise.
Omaha does have more millionaires...
Husker (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 11:15PM EST (link)per capita than almost all other cities in the US. $250K can get you a 3,500 sqft. colonial house on an acre lot with trees.
Warren Buffet can live any where in the world, but he chooses to live here in Omaha.
This of Course is Foolish
ehosterman (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 11:29PM EST (link)Prior to Mayor Rudy Giuliani, NYC was well on it’s way to looking exactly like Detroit. back in 1979, no one wanted to spend any time in Times Square except at New Year. It wsn’t what it is today. Mayor Dinkins had raised taxes to the point where business was looking to leave and let law enforcement drop tot he point where the pimps and gangs were running most of the streets. It could very easily get there againg under the worng mayors.
three strikes plus one for the lefty liar rhbee
Beaglescout (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 8:46PM EST (link)RHBee, let me count the ways all four paragraphs you wrote were wrong. Since you, and lefties like you, have made it plain over the past 8 years that every time someone says something wrong it is because they were lying, I will abide by the same rules you have created.
1. Obama promised in the campaign that 95% of everyone in the US would get a tax cut. That’s why people voted for him instead of the gormless Mack. The Zero didn’t mention that he’d raise taxes on gas, smokes, and electricity to the tune of a couple thou per year per household, and that his original promise was a lie since it depended on his pretense that letting the Bush tax cuts expire wasn’t a defacto tax increase. Like Zero, you are lying. Strike one.
2. Most small businesses are either sole proprietorships or S-corps. In either case the owner pays the tax on the income of the business as part of his personal income. The two are identical from a tax point of view. You are lying. Strike two.
3. The housing bubble was caused by government. CRA and the Fed’s cheap money created it. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, run by loot gathering Democrats temporarily out of government, spread it to the whole banking industry. The traffic and extra houses came from the bubble. Water shortages come from living in a desert. And jobs have been driven out by California’s punitive taxation of businesses and individuals. People don’t extort anything from their government when they say they’ll move out if taxes are high, they are simply speaking freely about reality. If government chooses to ignore reality that is government’s fault, not the fault of people who were merely exercising their right of free speech. And business didn’t move out, which you admit it did, because of low taxes that you fault in the end of your disjointed third paragraph. Business moved out because of high taxes. You are a liar. Strike three.
plus 1. Get used to less, lying lefty. Less free swag from achievers. Less free money to pay for your free gubmint services from overtaxed businesses. Fewer places to work. Fewer stores to shop at. Fewer doctors to save your life. Less food to eat. Less police on the street. More and bolder criminals on the street stealing what you have left. Fewer businesses at which to spend your ever-shrinking supply of money. And if you get out of your downward economic spiral by finally learning to toil and sweat like men and women are meant to work, then the government will call you an exploiter and seize all your earnings. Then you will learn how evil your life of lies really was. Strike four.
Have a nice life.
“A nation which can prefer disgrace to danger is prepared for a master, and deserves one.”
Nice post LJ...
harlan Friday, April 3rd at 11:16PM EST (link)I always appreciate a good smackdown of a left-leaning ne’r-do-well.
regrets, I had a few
Beaglescout (Diary) Saturday, April 4th at 12:43AM EST (link)but then again, too few to mention.
“A nation which can prefer disgrace to danger is prepared for a master, and deserves one.”
hey rhbee, a moderator has medicine for a sick puppy like you. nt
pilgrim (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 6:41PM EST (link).
The first thing I thought of when I heard Patterson...
JadedByPolitics (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 7:18PM EST (link)was how pissed I would be if I were a NYer that this idiot would think to tax me for one minute just to get rid of one citizen! very ignorant.
Unified Patriots – How-To:
Activists Taking Action
All the producers in CA
UpLateAgain (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 7:26PM EST (link)(except perhaps, those in the movie industry) are packing up and getting out. California began experiencing negative population growth in the nineties, and it is accelerating at a rate the Governator can’t even track. It would be even worse were it not for the rise in the illegal population. Unfortunately for CA, they are a much larger drag on the economy than a boon.
The Coastie governments just can’t wrap their heads around the idea that you have to actually produce largess before you can redistribute it.
You never never never actually need a gun, until you need a gun, and then nothing else will do.
See, "The Nine Nations of North America"
Achance (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 7:33PM EST (link)and the description of the “Ecotopian” nation, of which CA is a major part. These people have become phenomenally wealthy in the processing of wealth generated in the other “Nations.” Particularly CA has benefited from the natural wealth of the “Empty Quarter” comprising the InterMountain West, Canada’s Western provinces, and Alaska. It’s some interesting, if very lefty, reading.
In Vino Veritas
NY is a tough state
antisocial (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 7:59PM EST (link)Tough to live in. This state believes in picking pockets of citizens and businesses alike.
Tough to do business in. This is one of the most unfriendly states to do business in. This is one state where state has to give money to a business to setup shop here. There have been talks about AMD setting up a plant here for years now. State has to pay money to do that. Crazy… isn’t it? http://www.bizjournals.com/albany/stories/2009/03/16/daily56.html
I have a few friends who took transfers to New Jersey office of a company instead of working in NYC office. They had an option and they jumped at it.
Flight of business and individual from NY is a real threat.
Obama Doctrine – Boot On The Throat
—————————–
What is to be done?
——————————
No. You can’t – Moe Lane
——————————
The Emperor has no clothes!!!
will have no effect
Janice Cantore Friday, April 3rd at 8:31PM EST (link)While it’s wonderful to dream that enough people will leave to wake those who are left up to effect a good change, it’s not going to happen. As a conservative in California, a very depressed conservative right now, this is what will happen. A few people will leave, yeah, but even if it does effect revenue the effect will be denied. And the rest of the people who will never leave because, after all, IT”S NEW YORK will soldier on. The mindless morons who vote democrat will still be there in the majority and they will keep voting democrat. New York/California California/New York, same thing. Here, the morons keep checking the “d” column in state elections giving up the highest taxes in the country and they keep embarassing us on the national level by sending Maxine Waters and Nancy Pelosi back to Washington.
Right now, I have faith in God, but absolutly no faith in a country that can elect an inexperienced Obama to the highest office in the land and continue to slobber over him as if he were a rock star even though it’s embaarassingly apparent he’s an idiot and a dangerous one at that. We’re lost.
Janice Cantore
I'm similarly pessimistic about this.
asleep06 (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 9:01PM EST (link)Sure, NY’s going to go down the drain. But, just like the People’s Republic of California, the federal government will just bail them out and give the taxpayers the bill.
Excuse me, future generations of taxpayers, I mean.
Small is beautiful.
Janice, we are right with you
peg_c (Diary) Saturday, April 4th at 6:32AM EST (link)We’re conservatives in NY and we agree with every word. I doubt most of the rich in NYC will leave anymore than most of the rich in West L.A. (where I grew up) will, for both cultural and business reasons. These are lefties satisfied with their limo latte lives and smug in their superiority. They do not have the principles or the guts to look at socialist government for what it is and say “no more” and get out of Dodge – especially when it means leaving all their rich, lefty social circles. Conservatives have more individualism in us and a strong aversion to the collectivism that drives lefties.
If there is a way out of this wave of socialism driving the independent spirit out of this country, I don’t know what it is. It would depend on conservatives having influence in industries (academia, media) that we not only don’t have but that we in many ways want no part of. I try to be positive but it sure looks like the inmates are running the asylum to me.
But for family, I’d have left NY already for Texas or a similar red state. I think a lot of Obama’s policies are designed specifically to mitigate the advantages red states have and to bring them down to the same detestable level of the blue states. Socialism’s goal is equal misery for all except the elites.
Government cannot be the solution when government is the problem.
Conservatives are supposed to be bright enough to know when to go!
papalee Saturday, April 4th at 8:27AM EST (link)I know. I did.
When I first started going to Great Britain, the population believed that if there were no jobs where they lived, there were no jobs. Then Thatcher taught them that they had to follow the jobs. That meant that bed and breakfasts had laborers in them from Monday through Thursday nights. But the economy improved.
California is beautiful but deadly. It is time to get out. Now!!
The Flee threat is overhyped
gardenstateeric (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 9:42PM EST (link)It’s hard to leave a place, and it’s unlikely that a mass exodus will ensue just because income taxes go up a few points. I think the argument that a high or increased state tax rate is a bad idea because it will cause an exodus is not a strong one. There will be some incremental out migration to be sure, but it’s unlikely to be swift or pronounced enough to make a point, and there is a large percentage of the population who will simply wish upper middle class strivers good riddance. The better arguments against these policies are (1) they diminish economic growth, in the sense that they simply reduce the size of the private economy relative to the government sector with all that implies, and (2) they make it very unlikely that high income strivers or businesses will relocate (or expand) in your state. Whether or not NJ’s 10.25% income tax causes UHauls to be loaded up is besides the point. Economic activity is not static. At any given time businesses and individuals make decisions about how they will allocate capital. You would have to be nuts to expand a business in NJ or move a business to NJ or settle in NJ after speaking to a tax accountant for 5 minutes, subject to having some specific need to be in the place. Whether a family with 20 year roots in the state can leave is another story entirely, that family is more or less a prisoner to the polity and will likely suck up a lot of bad policies before moving (though retirement locations are pretty much a one way street to 0% income tax Florida).
Of course, the real argument against these taxes, is not really an economic growth argument at all. And it’s probably not a winning one, but we know what it is. The argument is: that government which governs best is that which governs least. Taxes are necessary, but the government should be motivated by a desire to do a few limited things very well (including ensuring that the unfortunate are provided enough), not everything always, and not with an eye to constant expansion. That work is hard. It’s risky, it’s draining, it’s unpleasant, it’s an imposition. Being forced to undertake that toil for 4, 5, 6, 7 months of the year and hand it to the tax man — rather than retain dominion over it to be allocated as you choose — is simply immoral. Our domestic and international situation is parlous. It’s always parlous, but there’s no reason why the government can handle its obligations with say 1/3 of an upper income person’s income, rather than 1/2 or more. That’s the real argument, and it’s a shame that it’s out of intellectual fashion.
May I disagree vehemently
Jack_Savage (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 9:50PM EST (link)I was born and raised in VA, and live in NC right now, and I cannot go to my own bathroom or any of my familiy’s without bumping into an ex-pat yankee.
How I wish you were right, but if there is one thing I know it is that you are wrong.
I agree and disagree
gardenstateeric (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 9:58PM EST (link)In my business over the years I have dealt often with counterparties in NC, Fla., Tex., etc. Guess what, more often than not I hear NY accents on the other end of the phone. So, you’re right, I know full well that NY’s folly has had the result of vaulting the economies and populations of key states. My disagreement is narrow: that NJ/NY has thousands of people who are adversely affected by these tax rates an increases who cannot easily leave and will not leave in response to the latest tax increase nonsense. I’d also make the point that it’s the upper middle class strivers at the lowest end of the affected income range who can least easily leave. The dentist in Plainfield with a 20-year practice will likely suck up yet another couple points on his income tax. He’ll retire to Tampa, he’ll put his wealth into muni bonds to cut his tax bite; he’ll be sorely tempted to lessen the bite by all legal means he can figure out; but he’s unlikely to leave. My larger point is: what kind of stupid tax system sets out to penalize a guy for having a successful dental practice? Rush is a distraction from that argument. It’s not useful.
That's what Team Patterson is counting on
smagar (Diary) Saturday, April 4th at 9:22AM EST (link)As long as people with the means to pay, are willing to stick around and keep paying, then why should Team Patterson do anything BUT raise taxes?
If they damage the state in the long run…well, isn’t that ultimately the fault of the voters? If they reelect Patterson and the legislators that raise the taxes, that is?
This is one reason I have trouble feeling sympathy for Michigan residents. Their state’s economy is sufferning, and Dem Governor Granholm has made things worse.
But, they reelected Granholm, out of widespread frustration with…George W. Bush and congressional Republicans?
One of the problems with a republic: you have the opportunity to screw yourself, through the politicians you put in charge.
“Who will stand/On either hand/And guard this bridge with me?” (Macaulay)
NYT vs. the Union - it's on!
DerKrieger (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 9:48PM EST (link)http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20090404/us_nm/us_media_newyorktimes_globe
“In questions of power, let no more be heard of confidence in man, but bind him down from mischief by the chains of the Constitution.” – Thomas Jefferson
“I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which granted a right to Congress of expending, on objects of benevolence, the money of their constituents.” – James Madison
Whenever the legislators endeavor to take away and destroy the property of the people, or to reduce them to slavery under arbitrary power, they put themselves into a state of war with the people, who are thereupon absolved from any further obedience.” — John Locke, 1690
Competition is a problem for the rest of the country
texas214 (Diary) Friday, April 3rd at 11:00PM EST (link)The main tenent of libralism is the we are all equal. The problem with that is in the USA is we are the “The Unied States” of America, meaning we are a collection of states with disparate laws, and tax policy. It is not always the tax issue that makes certain states and cities more successful for busines, in many cases it is labor laws, tort policy, or other issues that have an impact on business.
Not saying we need to re-fight the Civil War, sans the slavery issue, but in many ways that is where we are headed. The typical northern (and west coast) economy is now at such a disadvantage to the typical southern and middle American economies, due to tax, labor, and legislative laws, they can’t compete; see what is happening with the Big Three and the UAW vs. the foreign auto makers in the south. The foreign makers had a choice to locate any where and we see what they chose.The libral solution appears to be to impose their brand of libralism onto everyone else so they can compete.
The battle in America is going to be north vs. south and if we are all lucky the south will win this time.
PS. These comments do not reflect any sort of racial bias or bigotry related to the Civil War and should not be taken as such.
Not that simple:
Achance (Diary) Saturday, April 4th at 12:45PM EST (link)The South still has a very large dependent class, both black and white, that has not really made the transition away from agriculture and remains under or unemployed. Since the New Deal and especially since the Great Society, the rest of the Country has subsidized the Southern dependent class. As people and production leave the Northern and Left Coast states, they become less able to contribute to that subsidy and in fact themselves require greater subsidies. The South will have to find ways to better employ its dependent class or it will follow the Northeast and West Coast to higher and higher taxes to support the nonproductive members of society.
In Vino Veritas
Exit taxes next?
Common_Cents (Diary) Saturday, April 4th at 12:39PM EST (link)You can check out anytime you like but never leave!
Obama=Golfer in Chief, Leading from,
behind, the Back Nine.Leaders don’t create movements. Movements create leaders. Get involved. Your future depends on it.
Govt “invests” YOUR tax money for POLITICAL return rather than economic return.
Don't give them any ideas. nt
Steph C (Diary) Saturday, April 4th at 12:46PM EST (link)“[I]f the public are bound to yield obedience to laws to which they cannot give their approbation, they are slaves to those who make such laws and enforce them.” –Candidus in the Boston Gazette, 1772
Hillbilly Politics
Just slap a big tax on U-hauls and moving vans. nt
Achance (Diary) Saturday, April 4th at 12:47PM EST (link)In Vino Veritas
Back to the original topic
carlsbadd Sunday, April 5th at 12:29AM EST (link)I was reading the book “regan in his own words” today and he was talking about NY state back in the 70′s
Pretty much the exact thing as today, over taxed with more public workers per capita then people that work there. The more things change ………………
you know the rest….
Just a thought....
toddworsham (Diary) Sunday, April 5th at 6:00PM EST (link)I dont know if anyone has mentioned this in the large number of responses, I apologize, but I think there needs to be a movement and Rush could easily be the leader. People of productivity have already been leaving NYC because of various oppressing taxes and its only going to increase with the new litany of taxes. With a little poking, proding, and some well placed TV ads, NYC could quickly be reduced to the status of a parasite whose host just died.
So start small. If you know someone who lives in NYC, or New York State, you should lobby them to leave. If you have business connections help find people jobs, hell advertise on the NYC craigslist, in the post list the tax differences as well as info about the jobs.
My sister in laws parents just left Long Island for north carolina specifically because of taxes and the cost of living (in addition to the warmer weather and golf in NC). There will be a tipping point and if history tells us anything these increased taxes will lead to less revenue which will lead to increased taxes. The snake is eating its tail already with a little help NYC will be from bad to worse real quick.
Hopefully NYC will do what it did before when things looked back, elect a common sense Republican to clean up a liberals mess. It could happen around an election year maybe? Could serve as a good example of what conservative principles can do to foster real economic growth.
just a thought
**The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants**
–An OG American Patriot–
www.theotherworsham.blogspot.com
Democratic stranglehold
samcoastie (Diary) Monday, April 6th at 10:40AM EST (link)Business leaders will either
1. leave the state for a better tax environment
2..appeal to the government for special upport, ie bailout, tax subsidy.
Workers will either
1.leave the state to find work
2. find a government teat to suckle.
Those who chose the first options would likely vote republican, but will no longer be in NY. Those who chose the second options will not likely vote to cut themselves off, and Democrats will remain in power until the bottom falls off completely. Unfortunately, states like CA and NY will be propped up by the feds so the whole country will have to go down the tubes before enough people wake up. Also, states like NY and CA will continue to welcome Illegal Aliens to bolster their electoral power.
But there is still hope. In the Senate, poplulation doesn’t matter.
The foresight of our founding fathers was incredible. The Senate will be the thread our country hangs on after the Democrats have done their worst. If the Senate fails, and it could if California is split to create another state and DC is given seats in the Senate, then the 2nd amendment may be our only chance to retain the land we love.
We cannot compromise on anything that would increase Democratic power in the senate, or diminish the 2nd emendment.
samcoastie