This is What ‘Deficit Hawks’ Are For


No Guts, No Glory for the Blue Dogs. Time To Put Up or Shut Up


Get Flash

Congressional Democrats have now agreed to a ‘bipartisan stimulus compromise’ supported by fewer than 1 percent of Congressional Republicans, on a plan to spend about $780 billion or so of your money trying to get the economy moving again. Economists say this bill might provide a few temporary jobs for some workers, but it does nothing to correct the fundamental problems of the economy. Each version of the bill so far has wasted too much on pork-barrel projects and contained little in pro-growth tax cuts. We’ve seen that the bill has contained the seeds of nationalized health care, an end to welfare reform, and the potential to send the economy into a death spiral through a new trade war.

And we don’t know what’s in the bill now, because Democrats closed the doors and negotiated it in the middle of the night. In defiance of their public promises, they will push it to a vote before Members of Congress have had a chance to review it – let alone the public. And rather than this being the last big-ticket spending item this Congress will consider, it’s probably the first of many. The Obama administration says more funds may yet be needed for more bank bailouts. Hundreds of billions will be needed for health care ‘reform.’ There’s still over $400 billion in spending left to approve for the 2009 federal budget. And Congress will take up a transportation bill this Summer.

At best, this bill is a huge mistake.

That’s where the House Blue Dogs come in – whether they like it or not. This is how the Blue Dogs describe themselves:

The Blue Dog Coalition – who celebrated 13 years of leadership in 2008 – has built a reputation as a serious player in the policy arena, promoting positions which bridge the gap between ideological extremes. Many of the group’s policy proposals have been praised as fair, responsible, and positive additions to a Congressional environment too often marked as partisan and antagonistic…

The Coalition has been particularly active on fiscal issues, relentlessly pursuing a balanced budget and then protecting that achievement from politically popular “raids” on the budget. Past Coalition budgets have won the endorsement of the nonpartisan Concord Coalition and multiple newspaper and magazine editorials. As one column pointed out, the Blue Dogs have proven that “common sense, conservative economics and compassion aren’t necessarily mutually exclusive.”

Blue Dog Coalition proposals have served as middle-ground markers which laid the foundation for the bipartisanship necessary to bring about fundamental reforms, and helped set into law policies reflecting the “common sense, conservative compassion” so often attached to the group’s efforts.

I’ve beaten up on the Blue Dogs lately – accusing them of being toothless Democrat partisans who turn tail and run when they confront their liberal masters. Today’s the day to prove me wrong. For many, it may be the last chance to save their political careers.

And as if this weren’t enough, the Blue Dogs have already expressed their concerns with this bill, and threatened to block it if it is wasteful or bloated with unnecessary spending:

We are writing as leaders of the Blue Dog Coalition to urge a redoubled effort to streamline the stimulus and recovery package to achieve the goals of stimulating and strengthening the economy on the fastest feasible timeline and ensuring that taxpayer funds are safeguarded from fraud, waste and abuse…

That is why, as leaders of the Blue Dog Coalition, we worked before the House vote to target and remove spending in the bill that does not have the kind of stimulative, or long-term job creation potential, that is needed. We achieved some modest success, in the removal of hundreds of million of dollars, before the House vote, that we believe was either insufficiently stimulative or unrelated to long-term economic growth. We believe this spending is more properly addressed during the course of the normal appropriations process, which imposes tough budget choices and is critical to Congress’ efforts to keep to a fiscally responsible path…

We look forward to working with you to achieve that goal and ensure that any final stimulus and recovery package is properly focused to achieve the results the American people expect and deserve.

Do the Blue Dogs care about balanced budgets? Do they oppose wasteful spending? Are they the taxpayer’s best friend, the conscience of the Congress, and the moderates who craft bipartisan solutions? Today is the day to prove it. If they help Congressional leaders pass this massive spending bill with no scrutiny, then they don’t really serve any purpose. And they’ll be reminded of it over and over again before the next election.


RSS feed

9 Comments Leave a comment

Joe Lieberman

Dencal26 Thursday, February 12th at 7:44AM EST (link)

I notice Joe Lieberman is back to being a reliable liberal vote.

Lieberman has always been a reliable liberal vote.

Brian Hibbert (Diary) Thursday, February 12th at 8:31AM EST (link)

At least on domestic issues. He’s good on national defense and foreign policy, but he is politically a liberal. He’s a true believer in

Candidate for Trustee of Illinois Central College
Socialism doesn’t work. It looks nice on paper, but it’s been tried and it’s failed miserably every time (usually accompanied by widespread death and suffering).
Proud member of the V.R.W.C.

Take back our party!
Check out Unified Patriots

Hit something to enter the comment by accident.

Brian Hibbert (Diary) Thursday, February 12th at 8:37AM EST (link)

As I was saying, Joe’s a true believer in the government as the savior of the people.

But the thing about Joe is, you know where he stands and you can work with him.. He’s a reasonable liberal.

Candidate for Trustee of Illinois Central College
Socialism doesn’t work. It looks nice on paper, but it’s been tried and it’s failed miserably every time (usually accompanied by widespread death and suffering).
Proud member of the V.R.W.C.

Take back our party!
Check out Unified Patriots

Reasonable?

charlesmartel Thursday, February 12th at 9:05AM EST (link)

Brian, I do understand your point on Lieberman. He’s relatively honorable (as much as any member of government can be) in that he tends to stick to his principles. As far as Democrats go, he’s one of my favorites. But to describe anyone as “reasonable” he would vote to pass this bill is offensive. There is nothing reasonable about this bill.

FWIW, any member of Congress that votes to pass this bill (or has helped it along the way) is dead to me. They will have lost any respect I once may have held for them, and I promise to do whatever I can down the road to work towards their defeat. Support for this bill cancels out any other reasonable actions or good works any of these people may have done, or ever will do.

I guess honorable is a better term than reasonable.

Brian Hibbert (Diary) Thursday, February 12th at 9:45AM EST (link)

What I was trying to convey is that Joe is true to his principals. That he would vote with the liberals should be no surprise to anyone.

Candidate for Trustee of Illinois Central College
Socialism doesn’t work. It looks nice on paper, but it’s been tried and it’s failed miserably every time (usually accompanied by widespread death and suffering).
Proud member of the V.R.W.C.

Take back our party!
Check out Unified Patriots

 
 
 
 

Joe is a liberal, remember that

NickDeringer (Diary) Thursday, February 12th at 1:37PM EST (link)

If the GOP needs to rely on people like Joe Lieberman then we are in trouble.

 
 

Here's the contact info for the Blue Dogs

1SGinTN (Diary) Thursday, February 12th at 9:02AM EST (link)

http://www.house.gov/ross/BlueDogs/Member%20Page.html

It may be slightly out of date since inauguration. Please help me wear them (and their staff) out answering the phones & reading email/faxes as we remind them what their website says regarding fiscal responsibility.

Tu Ne Cede Malis
-Virgil

 

charlesmartel, you're so right

zeebeach Thursday, February 12th at 9:31AM EST (link)

I will fight these people tooth and nail. My children are both at university and I fear for their future. I want my country back!

 

Let's not kid ourselves

TxCon (Diary) Thursday, February 12th at 4:13PM EST (link)

the Blue Dogs virtually vanished after the 1994 elections. If you recall many of them switched parties, (Tauzin, Laughlin, Goode, Parker,etc.) Charlie Stenholm stayed around until 2004, when redistricting finally got him. Can you imagine a Democrat today saying what then-democrat Richard Shelby said when talking about President Clinton, “the taxman cometh.” No way.

Today, I would say there are maybe two true “Blue Dogs” left. They are Gene Taylor and Walter Minnick.

The rest are phonies and can’t be trusted.