In the debate over the ‘stimulus,’ Barack Obama’s biggest problem is that he has not wanted to take the lead on the legislation. For weeks Congressional Democrats complained that his reluctance to set out his recommended legislation was slowing the process. When all was said and done, he never did reveal ‘his’ bill; he simply communicated his priorities to Congress and let them carry the water. Early on in the process the bill clearly deviated from the guideposts he set out — exceeding his recommended spending level and neglecting tax cuts. All along, he has kept his distance while Congress worked out the messy details. Now it seems Congressional leaders may no longer be listening to him.
According to the trade publication Congress Daily, Barack Obama has told Senate Democrats they need to cut the overall spending level in the package to win Republican votes:
Citing urgent economic conditions, President Obama and key advisers Wednesday pressed Senate Democrats to allow spending cuts to the economic stimulus bill to win Republican backing, senators said.
“He talked about taking out some of the stuff that doesn’t really help the economy … taking out some of the fat, putting in a little more muscle,” Sen. Mary Landrieu, D-La., said after Obama’s closed-door meeting with Senate Democrats at the Newseum.
Obama identified some of the measure’s health and education provisions as areas in which the Democrats could meet Republican demands for reductions, Landrieu said. Senate Budget Chairman Kent Conrad said Obama emphasized the urgency of passing a bill soon and told lawmakers that the American people expect “problem-solving.” Obama “is open to changes that strengthen Republican support,” Conrad said.
But is anyone in the Senate listening? If Obama and his aides were ‘pressing’ Democrats to support some spending cuts, there’s no evidence of it so far on the Senate floor. Yesterday David Vitter (R-LA) proposed an amendment to cut $47 billion in wasteful spending. Democratic Senator were united in their opposition. John McCain proposed an amendment to implement some spending cuts after two consecutive quarters of two percent growth. That got four Democratic votes. Even Tom Coburn’s amendment to cut tax breaks for Hollywood got just 14 Democratic votes.
There is an expectation that the negotiations between Senators Nelson and Collins may produce a bipartisan package of cuts that would reduce the overall size of the bill by several hundred billion. But if just a handful of Democrats support a even a tiny cut targeted at Hollywood, how will Obama produce the votes to cut the overall package by one-third?
It’s clear that Obama needs to engage to prevent his presidency from starting with a colossal embarrassment, but it’s no longer clear that his engaging is enough. Those same armies of activists that Obama tapped to win the White House are against him on this — pushing for more spending rather than less. It may already be too late for him to recover.
Note: Jim Geraghty has other evidence of how Obama is seemingly AWOL on this.
Steve Maley
Neil Stevens
Daniel Horowitz
The wrong strategy for the situation
kweiss01 Thursday, February 5th at 4:24PM EST (link)Reagan was able to “take it to the people” to shame congress, addressing the public directly and asking them to press their representatives to get with the program. Obama is trying to do the same, I believe, with his media campaign. The problem is that unlike the Reagan situation in the 1980s (84?), Congress is controlled by Obama’s own party, blunting the effectiveness of this tactic.
I also have to wonder how much Obama really cares. Pork barrel politics is the nature of the Chicago regime. I suspect Obama cares very much about his own image and how it will be tarnished by a failed bill, but is less than enthusiastic about a smack-down over pork.
What a quandry!
Hugo Chavez's way
10ksnooker (Diary) Thursday, February 5th at 4:37PM EST (link)Watch the video on the Frontline site “The Hugo Chavez show” to see how it’s done. And then you will understand why the boot lick Democrats rush down to kiss Hugo’s ring.
The preparation H "solution"
Next93 (Diary) Thursday, February 5th at 4:57PM EST (link)I wish I could find a youtube video of this.
The much-maligned comic genius Gallagher did a bit about the old Preparation H ads, in which the pitchman would hold his hands about a foot apart, and, bringing them about 6 inches apart, would intone “shrinks SWOLLEN membranes”.
Gallagher’s bit was along the lines of: (holding hands about a foot apart), “If THIS is the problem, then THIS” , (moving hands six inches apart) “is NOT the answer”.
Cutting $50 billion off of a $900 billion spending orgy is NOT going to make me feel any better about it,
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again; this is the carbon neutral version of the reichstag fire, in wich the congress takes over broad swathes of the American economy in order to solve a “crisis” that it created; one that will solve itself if they leave it alone.
On the bright side, if Obama gets all this crap passed, maybe he’ll just take the next four years off, since he’ll have done about as much damage to the country in his first month as Carter was able to do in four years.
Obama was The One in 2008.
He’ll be a BIGGER one in 2012.
Looks Like Dems Are Going to Pass This Turkey As Is
Spartan4Life (Diary) Thursday, February 5th at 8:34PM EST (link)That’s the impression I am getting as I follow the story tonight. They might vote on the Collins/Nelson amendment to cut up to a third of the spending but my guess is that it will be voted down. Seems like the new mantra is we need to do “something”. Whether it will create any jobs seems to be immaterial.
I am so sad for our country and our kids.
This is how Obama is now goin to vote present
James_Reynolds (Diary) Thursday, February 5th at 9:50PM EST (link)by onlly giving guidlines and press it is imperitive to get this bill passed. He cansign it and if it fails he will say they did not follow my guidelines, but is was getting late I had to sign it
Either it's good cop/bad cop or the democrats are going back to their racist roots
Leopard1996 (Diary) Thursday, February 5th at 11:52PM EST (link)I mean really, are we looking at an effort to have Barack and congressional leaders treat the American people like a perp in an Law and Order episode, or are the congressional democrats going back to their KKK roots, and not listening to the black man.
“The accumluated filth of all their sex and murder will foam up about their waists and all the whores and politicians will look up and shout, “Save Us!”….and I’ll look down and whisper, “No”…The Watchmen