The school chancellor in Washington, D.C. is a reformist Democrat named Michelle Rhee. She has spent the last 18 months attempting to shake up one of the worst school districts in America, to give the children in the nation’s capital a chance at a quality education. The Wall Street Journal profiled Rhee recently:
In going after tenure, Ms. Rhee is taking on the holiest citadel of the education establishment. This summer she offered a new teacher contract proposal with two options. Teachers could choose a plan under which their pay would rise spectacularly — nearly doubling by 2010 — in exchange for giving up tenure. Or they could opt for a smaller pay bump and still lose some seniority rights.
Ms. Rhee’s proposal has caused a meltdown among leaders of the Washington Teachers’ Union, and negotiations have collapsed. The Chancellor has raised the stakes, announcing the district would seek to dismiss tenured teachers who are ineffective. She has also hinted she’ll go around the union by creating more nonunionized charter schools, or getting the federal government to deem her district in a “state of emergency…”
The beauty of Ms. Rhee’s tenure reform is that it would use financial incentives to help the best teachers. Unions love to say they are underpaid professionals. Ms. Rhee agrees. Under her reform, teachers willing to be judged on their worth could earn up to $130,000 a year. Her price: Disburse money as is in the real world — on merit.
The union leadership claims its members oppose to the plan, but the WTU has refused to allow a vote. The local is getting heat from its parent organization, the American Federation of Teachers, which is petrified that Ms. Rhee’s plan will set a national precedent. These bosses know that smaller pay-for-performance experiments across the country have received strong teacher support.
Now Ms. Rhee has given an interview where she expands on her views, and talks about what Democrats need to do to match Republicans on education policy:
For the last decade or so, the Democrats have not been as strong on education reform as the Republicans have. The Republicans have been much, much better, in my opinion, on ensuring strict accountability for schools and for districts, for ensuring that people are held responsible for closing the achievement gap and significantly increasing student achievement levels for every single child. What worries me about the Democrats is that they tend to be softer on these things, and soft is not what we need right now. Allowing schools to continue to fail year in and year out without significant ramifications either to the district or to the school is doing a disservice to the children…
I don’t think it’s too much for the children of this country to ask for to have somebody who’s leading the education system who is always going to put their interests first and foremost, who is not going to care about the politics, the political flak, how many adults get mad at them, keeping the adults happy. At the end of the day, this is all about whether we’re doing the right things and making the right decisions for kids. And I find it somewhat odd, the amount of what you’d call flak that I get for having that stance, given that my job is to make sure that kids are getting an excellent education…
I think it’s a great place for this to happen because this is largely considered the worst school district in the country. And I believe that when we significantly turn around the learning outcomes of kids in this city, then it takes the excuses away from everyone else who says it’s not possible because of the kids and poverty and that sort of thing. Because if you can do it in D.C., I think you can fairly say that you can do it anywhere.
Rhee is a young, highly-intelligent agent of change, whose goal above all is a quality education for the children she serves. There are few Republicans who seem as committed as she is to reforming the nation’s hidebound public education system. She seems eminently qualified to take on the as-yet-unfilled position of Education Secretary under President Obama. And her nomination would be a sign that Obama truly is committed to changing the way Washington works and creating a more effective federal government.
Would a petition from Republicans help, or hurt?
Steve Maley
Neil Stevens
Daniel Horowitz
She's too green.....
DC71 (Diary) Saturday, December 13th at 11:39AM EST (link)Living in DC I’m pretty familiar with what she’s trying to do here. I like her a lot actually. Most people do. But, it’s too early to put her in charge of the DoE yet. She’s only been at the job or 2 years since coming from the NGO world, and there aren’t any real concrete results showing that anything here has actually improved. I say leave her here to actually see if her plans work to fix up DC schools, and if it does, then try to repeat this nationally. It’ll be easier to enact these policies nation wide if there is a huge success story first and she has more experience running a bureaucracy.
Also, I want to mention, that for all the crap DC government gets, you have to give the Williams and now Fenty administrations a lot of credit for what they have done for DC. I know it’s popular to bust on our local government, but they’ve done a good just at slowly turning this city around from the craphole it was in the 1980′s.
Too green?
Loren Heal (Diary) Saturday, December 13th at 12:23PM EST (link)She’s only been at the job or 2 years since coming from the NGO world,
Hmm, that sounds familiar. Who else has scant experience except for education projects … I’ll have to get back to you.
–
Join the Concord Project, and follow @lheal, if you dare.
I agree with Socrates - experience - that did not matter this year
Elizabeth Christian (Diary) Sunday, December 14th at 2:28AM EST (link)at least to a majority of voters in this country this year.
I saw an interview with her and I would not have known she was a democrat until I read it above. She would be awesome, if Obama would appoint her, get out of her way, let her do what needs to be done, then maybe just maybe some good change would occur. This lady has a great message from what I heard on the interview that I watched. Also, has more plans in the future that sounded good too.
Any society that would give up a little liberty to gain a little security will deserve neither and lose both.
~Benjamin Franklin
Here's her problem, right here:
Loren Heal (Diary) Saturday, December 13th at 12:24PM EST (link)Rhee is a young, highly-intelligent agent of change, whose goal above all is a quality education for the children she serves.
Show stopper.
–
Join the Concord Project, and follow @lheal, if you dare.