The biggest earmark in American history has been doled out to a company in Illinois, the President’s home state, in the name of green jobs. The President’s $862 billion Stimulus plan has been an abysmal failure. It provided states and localities with billions in bailout moneys, funded wasteful projects like the Monkey cocaine study at Wake Forest and given false hope to Americans that the President has ideas to turn around the economy. This earmark is an outrage and the signature project of the President’s Stimulus plan. Thankfully, Senator Tom Coburn (R-OK) is sounding the alarm bells and educating the American people to this new Obama outrage.
President Obama is earmarking $1 billion in Stimulus money “to build FutureGen 2.0, a clean coal repowering program and carbon dioxide (CO2) storage network” in his home state of Illinois. According to a Department of Energy press release, this billion is being provided to ”FutureGen Alliance, Ameren Energy Resources, Babcock & Wilcox, and Air Liquide Process & Costruction, Inc. to build FutureGen 2.0, a clean coal repowering program and carbon dioxide (CO2) storage network.” That is right — $1 billion. This is the largest earmark of money in U.S. history and they are taking money right out of your pocket to pay for it.
The Department of Energy projects 1,900 jobs as a result of $1,000,000,000 in new spending. This works out to $526,315.79 of your tax dollars spent per job. A half million dollars per job seems to be a bad deal for the taxpayer. Of more concern to the taxpayer, Senator Tom Coburn believes this project to be more about bringing home pork to Illinois than providing stimulus to average Americans.
According to Secretary of Energy Steven Chu yesterday:
Today’s announcement will help ensure the US remains competitive in a carbon constrained economy, creating jobs while reducing greenhouse gas pollution. This investment in the world’s first, commercial-scale, oxy-combustion power plant will help to open up the over $300 billion market for coal unit repowering and position the country as a leader in an important part of the global clean energy economy
Although the President promised to keep the $862 billion stimulus plan free from earmarks, this project was an earmark in the Stimulus, yet the Washington Post reported on March 6, 2009:
Deep inside the economic stimulus package is a $1 billion prize that, in five short words, shows the benefits of being in power in Washington. The funding, for “fossil energy research and development,” is likely to go to a power plant in a small Illinois town, a project whose longtime backers include a group of powerful lawmakers from the state, among them President Obama.
Now, the Department of Energy has announced the $1 billion in funding for the earmark in President Obama’s home state. This earmark funnels tax dollars from Americans to Illinois. Senator Tom Coburn criticized the first version of this project, FutureGen 1.0, and an argues that this project calls in to question President Obama’s Stimulus plan.
Senator Coburn said of the $1 billion earmark:
This costly and gratuitous earmark further calls into question the integrity of the Recovery Act. This decision appears to have more to do with politics and geography than science. FutureGen 1.0 was called ‘YesterGen’ because it had little scientific value. Now, taxpayers are being forced to finance the largest pork-barrel project in our nation’s history with borrowed money. Adding another $1 billion to our debt for a dubious project will only delay our recovery.
Coburn isn’t the only one concerned. Some greenies on left argue that this project is not efficient and will not do enough to protect the environment. The original FutureGen plan was scaled back and the promises of capturing 90% of carbon emissions became a promise FutureGen could not keep.
The environmental group, the Clean Air Taskforce, was quoted in the Wyoming Business Report:
The reinstatement of FutureGen should be an important milestone and a day for celebration. Unfortunately, it is not. In scaling back the amount of carbon the plant will capture from 90 percent to 60 percent in order to cut costs, the Obama Administration has turned FutureGen to YesterGen.
For months, the Obama Administration and Congress said that the Stimulus language was not an earmark for this company in Illinois. We now know that assertion to be false. The actions yesterday from Secretary of Energy Steven Chu confirm suspicions that this is the biggest earmark in American history. FutureGen in Matoon, Illinois gets $1 billion and average Americans are provided with the bill.
President Obama, Senator Dick Durbin (D-IL) and Secretary Chu need to explain to the American people how this happened. How did this earmark get into the Stimulus? Why is the Obama Administration funnelling $1 billion into Illinois for a project of dubious effectiveness. Unemployment today stands at 9.5% and the Stimulus has proven to have had no effect on unemployment rates.
Ths President’s Stimulus is a failure and many on the Hill are concerned about this project as evidence of special treatment for some companies in the President’s home state. This is exactly the type of waste, fraud and abuse that motivate average Americans to join the Tea Party movement to continue to distrust the federal government.
Aaron Gardner
Steve Maley
KnightsofMalta
From a science perspective,
sacody Friday, August 6th at 10:42AM EST (link)the really sad part about all of this is that the NSF gets many legitimate project and research applications every year that need funding but are turned down due to a lack of money, and on the other hand, we fund this crap without going through any review procedures at all. How disgusting.
As a follow up,
sacody Friday, August 6th at 10:44AM EST (link)we should track how many of these Stimulus Studies ever end up getting approval from the NSF for future funding. I doubt the Monkey/Cocaine study will be at the top of their list of priorities.
Its been reviewed
toneyal Monday, August 9th at 6:26AM EST (link)Obama and his associates looked it over. What more could any sane rational non Racist American want?
I think
rdelbov Friday, August 6th at 11:18AM EST (link)Delaware got a huge energy earmark too for some sort of Car company?
I am bluer then blue over this stuff
Actually, Mattoon lost Futuregen
anacreon (Diary) Friday, August 6th at 11:43AM EST (link)It was originally supposed to be built in Mattoon and after several revisions and cancellation, Futuregen moved to Meredosia, IL – a town of just over 1000. Supposedly Mattoon will still have a training facility, but the Futuregen plant itself will be in Meredosia. Link to Chicago Tribune article below.
http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/chi-ap-us-futuregen,0,7105505.story
www.downstateiladvocate.com
That's right, anacreon.
Loren Heal (Diary) Sunday, August 8th at 8:41AM EST (link)As someone who works in Mattoon and would benefit directly from a giant power plant and federal money pit built there, I can say I’m glad to see it go.
Because like all federal stimulus, the benefits would have been short-lived, but would have brought changes in the local economy from people anticipating a permanent change.
And after the stimulus money dried up, as with Cash For Clunkers there would have been a piper to pay. The FutureGen plant would have been just one more coal power plant — but one more expensive to run than its competitors. It would have taken ongoing state and local subsidies to keep it going.
–
Join the Concord Project, and follow @lheal, if you dare.
Make it PC
toneyal Monday, August 9th at 6:41AM EST (link)You need a program on your computer to filter your comments to make them PC!
True
anacreon (Diary) Monday, August 9th at 9:00AM EST (link)and the private investment for the plant was on shaky ground from what I understand.
If this thing ever gets built, I’ll be surprised.
www.downstateiladvocate.com
Brian, Somebody at RS should make FutureGen updates a personal project.
gamechange11two Friday, August 6th at 11:53AM EST (link)If this revenue ends up in the hands of FG management, the readers here at RS should be treated to quarterly reports on how, or how not, the money is being spent. Just thinking that once the funds have been distrubuted, the lefties at FG will fritter and squander their booty while they decide what it is they are doing. Not that liberals would do that sort of thing with taxpayer money.
Mind Boggling
tragiconda Friday, August 6th at 7:58PM EST (link)A billion here, a billion there, eventually it all adds up!
Just try to wrap your mind around all the untold waste in that 800 billion+ stimulus….
Then try to imagine, if it HAD to be spent, what wonders it MIGHT have done IF actually spent wisely, with oversight, by profit driven entrepreneurs and actual BUSINESS people.
But remember, it was Bush who did things to benefit his energy industry friends
bk (Diary) Monday, August 9th at 6:34AM EST (link)I strongly doubt Bush did 1/100th as much for his “rich oil buddies” we’ve heard about 3,000,000 times in the past 10 years as Obama has done in 18 months for his insider “green” fat cats I’d be surprised. But there’s nary a peep in the press.
Obama redefining "Business as Usual."
saccrewdog Monday, August 9th at 8:44AM EST (link)“Change you can believe in!” What the heck is that supposed to mean, anyway? I believe I’m a lot worse off than before his coronation; I believe that the federal gov’t is way beyond what is necessary to perform its Constitutional duties; I believe that Obama has redefined the powers of the Presidency, and not for the better. I’m fed up. Read, Understand, Be Informed, and then, VOTE! Hoping for Change in November!
apparently no stimulus funds went for proofreaders
partyof1 Monday, August 9th at 8:58AM EST (link)Air Liquide Process & Costruction
Partyof1 - Good Catch
Brian Darling (Diary) Monday, August 9th at 12:08PM EST (link)I didn’t even notice that the Department of Energy press release had spelling errors in it. If you are going to give away $1 billion for one project, you would think you would spell check your press release.
you won't believe this but
partyof1 Monday, August 9th at 2:27PM EST (link)“is expected to create 275 contruction jobs”
Same word, but misspelled differently!
Yes this does make us confident that they will spend the $1 billion with no mistakes.
And speaking of mistakes, I came across the following story today from Dec. 2009 regarding the $ 1.6 billion stimulus allocation for a nuke weapons facility in SC:
Finally, in one of the odder episodes, a stimulus official was barred from the site last month while an outside investigator looked into an accusation that she had threatened one of her superiors by saying she wanted to shoot him.
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/13/science/earth/13savannah.html?_r=1
Kind of puts the whole typo thing into perspective.
MORE "Stimulus" pork
fab4bear Monday, August 9th at 1:02PM EST (link)A company that Al Gore is in partnership with got $528 Million for his car company in Finland.
REMEMBER?
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/news/2345857/posts
I wonder if this has anything to do with CCX
bs61 Tuesday, August 10th at 1:12AM EST (link)The Chicago Climate Exchange sits awaiting some form of Cap N Trade to make trillions in their first year – which profits the usual subjects, Soros, Gore, the Joyce Foundation, Goldman Sachs, etc. Glenn Beck reported on it a while ago.