Jean-Claude Trichet, the outgoing governor of the European Central Bank, just announced that the ECB will engage in purchases of euro-denominated bonds issued by Spain and Italy. This long-resisted move is intended to stem the latest flareup of the sovereign-debt heartburn that is a far greater threat to financial-market stability than the US debt downgrade. If the ECB manage to sustain this, it probably will work, for a while at least.
If you’re an investor in Italian or Spanish (or French) debt, your goals are pretty simple: you just want to enjoy the benefits of higher interest rates, while being assured by someone more credible than Spain or Italy that you’ll get your money back. Can’t blame people for wanting a free lunch, especially if Uncle Trichet is scared enough to offer it to them.
There are two enormous problems with Trichet’s announcement:
1) It represents a complete abandonment of the ECB’s iron pledges not to pull national governments out of the fire; and
2) We’re talking about far more debt than the ECB can possibly buy without creating a lot of inflation. They simply don’t have the resources to sterilize it all. And if they stop short, the move won’t have the market impact they’re looking for.
To the first point, the ECB can now forget about their pretense of being a “pure” central bank, or monetary authority concerned about nothing but preventing inflation. This kicks out one of the props supporting the euro as a credible reserve currency.
The second point puts Germany in a terrible bind. The resources needed to backstop Spain and Italy can only come from Germany, where the taxpayers have been getting restless.
What the Germans had hoped to do with the euro is to create a whole raft of captive export markets across the southern tier of Europe, so they could continue to create high-value jobs in Germany. Germans are nothing if not disciplined: for much of the past decade their economy has underperformed as they slowly built up the eurozone toward that goal.
But now they’ve come to find that the Latin economies simply aren’t productive enough to sustain the higher level of external obligations that comes automatically with higher trade deficits.
The euro was supposed to prevent deficit countries from stiffing the Germans the old-fashioned way, through currency devaluations. Instead, the Germans are finding that they now have to stiff themselves, by guaranteeing their debtors’ IOUs. To this, add the very good possibility that they’ll have to accept repayment in depreciated euros.
Still, you have to admit this is better than Germany’s historical solution, which is war.
Trade predation as a strategy is proved yet again not to be sustainable over time. The Chinese have gotten away with it longer because their prey (the US) is bigger and stronger than southern Europe. The US debt downgrade story is proximately caused by US political dysfunction, but trade imbalances instigated by the Chinese are an essential part of how we got here.
Italy’s long-term government debt is now yielding in the high 6s, more than 300 basis points higher than German debt of comparable maturity. Italian CDS prices are very high, up in the 380s. As Trichet embarks on an Italian-debt purchase program, those spreads should narrow. The next thing to watch out for is inflation.
Germans HATE inflation. If that’s what lies ahead for Europe, maybe Germany’s voters will form their own Tea Party.
Victoria Coates
Daniel Horowitz
Choices, choices
Risky (Diary) Monday, August 8th at 8:29AM EST (link)Well if they were to be honest and let the Greeks default then the Germans would have to spend a bunch bailing out the their banks so it’s there’s a bill to pay either way, but I guess this way shifts the blame abroad a little.
Still doesn’t help in the election when a German asks why they should work till sixty-seven to pay for the pension of a fifty-something Greek ex-civil servant.
Of course the truth is that sixty-seven isn’t realistic either. I think seventy-five is a fair bet in the longer term unless you have someone else to pay for it.
Oh, They'll Get To Work Until They're 75 Now.
Repair_Man_Jack (Diary) Monday, August 8th at 9:43AM EST (link)What sucks, is that so will everyone here in the US of A.
Mr. Obama is pretending that an economic “recovery” is underway when he knows damn well that the banking system is just blowing smoke up the shredded *** of what’s left of that economy – James Howard Kunstler
News?
Risky (Diary) Monday, August 8th at 12:04PM EST (link)but most sensible people who know what an annuity is and basic demographioc trends will have been expecting this. It’s what I expected ten years ago and the current crisis has little impact.
Of course it’s a bit different here in the UK as the basic state pension isn’t worth much and defined benefit schemes are pretty rare in the private sector (I’ve been working nearly 20 years and haven’t ever been eligible for one. The fight is building up about sorting out the public sector, but the mood in the country isn’t behind the unions. Obviously the situation siuatuion differs across Europe with each country having a different combination of problems.
I was talking with one of my German clients about this last week.
jeffreywturner (Diary) Monday, August 8th at 8:35AM EST (link)He explained to me that this is typical for the way things work in Europe. Basically the mentality over there ever since WW2 is that it is OK for a country to get crewed over as long as that country is Germany. Its like an unofficial form of reparations.
“Life is too short, can’t we all just eat pork and kill some terrorists?”
The Germans made a deal with the devil
Death_of_the_Donkey (Diary) Monday, August 8th at 9:49AM EST (link)and now are having to pay on that contract. They loved the idea of the Euro because it eliminated the strength of the DM and gave them great export advantages. Now, they have to essentially decide to either keep those advantages (by bailing out the rest of the EU) or lose those advantages (and kill their economy) but hold the line on bailouts and potential inflation. I really do not feel bad for them (just like I won’t for China when its chickens come home to roost).
As a side note, Francis, China looks eerily similar to what was going on to some of the Asian Tigers during the 1998 Asian crisis (ie fixed currency, reliance on government support, export dominated economy, lots of FDI). Do you think they may crack in the near future?
China isn't where the Asian Tigers were
Francis Cianfrocca (Diary) Monday, August 8th at 10:03AM EST (link)Their capital controls, while imperfect, are still far more aggressive that what Thailand and others had during the 1994-97 “Asian flu” crisis. FDI is high in China, but again highly conditional, and not as large as a proportion of GDP as it was in the Tigers.
China has other problems. I think the US downgrade, in a funny way, accelerates the moment of reckoning for them.
The yuan exchange rate hit a record high of 6.42+ overnight. The Chinese can only pursue their currency-manipulation strategy by continuing to buy US debt. If we’re indeed at the beginning of a long cycle of downgrades and de facto devaluation of US assets, then the game will be up for China sooner rather than later.
And it’s for some of the same reasons that impact the dynamic between Germany and the Latin states!
The question I have on China is how close they are to ...
acat (Diary) Monday, August 8th at 10:17AM EST (link)“bootstrapping” their own middle-class consumer-driven economy. As I’ve understood it, that’s been their goal… the trade was there to build the middle-class wealth needed to take over for the trade at … some future point.
Are they close enough that they could survive – not thrive, but thriving isn’t necessary – with a much less spendthrift U.S. market?
Mew
——

Caveat Suffragator
It's impossible to answer that...
Francis Cianfrocca (Diary) Monday, August 8th at 12:29PM EST (link)…because the best data are from the Chinese, and they have every incentive to lie about them.
The best I can give you is a gut feeling, which is that it’s not going well. They’re still so focused on growth via investment, and they have so much inflation, that real consumer purchasing power is not growing much, if at all.
They also have a major change of government coming up in 2013. The new leaders will have a lot to say about how they pursue the goal of a consumer society.
Keep in mind that many Asian people, and certainly most Chinese, prefer to maintain very high personal savings rates. There are cultural limits to how fast they can transition to a consumer-led society.
Thank you for your gut opinion..
acat (Diary) Monday, August 8th at 12:32PM EST (link)it’s in line with what my gut is saying, but .. mine doesn’t spend its’ days immersed in this kind of thinking.
Mew
——

Caveat Suffragator
#3
Marcus_Traianus (Diary) Monday, August 8th at 9:50AM EST (link)Nobody believes Italy has the political will to invoke necessary austerity and stabilization measures for their debt. Sounds familiar- doesn’t it?
War references aside, once the German people figure out how much of this depends on their financial resources, the game changes. It will become politically untenable to continue supporting this nonsense. Based on that factor, I am still not buying the Euro is in any way stable.
I will also go out on a limb; if countries like Ireland re-inflate their currencies as a means of economic stabilization, something I believe is plausible, then get ready to open both doors at the exits.
“Both of our political parties, at least the honest portion of them, agree conscientiously in the same object—the public good; but they differ essentially in what they deem the means of promoting that good. One side believes it best done by one composition of the governing powers; the other, by a different one. One fears most the ignorance of the people; the other, the selfishness of rulers independent of them. Which is right, time and experience will prove.”.Thomas Jefferson
Responses
Francis Cianfrocca (Diary) Monday, August 8th at 12:34PM EST (link)I actually think Italy can pull together a certain amount of political will to do an austerity. They’ve done it in the past. The whole euro-conversion was one big govt-imposed austerity that Italians still grumble about.
The real problem is recession. As the global economy crumbles, austerity gets really hard to do. Especially in Italy, which has something close to a no-layoff policy across the whole legal economy.
The game in Germany has already changed. Merkel is well aware that her job is in serious jeopardy. The Green party is coming on very strong, in many cases in Red-Green coalitions with the Socialists.
I don’t get your point about Ireland. They use the euro, and can’t unilaterally devalue. They can’t inflate fiscally, either, because no one will buy their debt except at penalty rates.
Ireland screwed up by raising the cost of doing business...
acat (Diary) Monday, August 8th at 12:52PM EST (link)Back in the day, Shannon, Ireland was a boomtown, full of tech and engineering shops – lots of offshoots from the U.S. – who moved there because the taxes were low and the people spoke English, with a quaint accent.
Taxes went up and Shannon collapsed. The firm that gave me a dollop of insider information on the scene there moved their offices to Poland … they also speak English, although the accent is a bit thicker and less quaint… but the taxes are lower.
Mew
——

Caveat Suffragator
Ireland was screwed up..
Risky (Diary) Monday, August 8th at 1:26PM EST (link)..by the bunch of chancers in Fianna Fáil who thought they might have a chance of reelection if they kept the party going. They signed a blank cheque to bail out the bank’s bondholders and backrupted a country that otherwise would have suffered badly from the end of the property bubble, but would still be solvent. They could have guaranteed the deposits and it would have cost a hell of a lot but not ~100% of GBP.
Greece’s probelm were inevitable, Irelands were unnecessary. I trust the Irish electorate will not forget and will never reelect that bunch of crooks in future.
A bad concept from the beginning
johnt Monday, August 8th at 10:27AM EST (link)One currency covering radically different cultures and economies?
More than forty years ago Otto Von Habsburg pointed out the contradictions, he wasn’t alone. It didn’t help that the US underwrote the decline through NATO, contributing to turning a continent into a giant playground for the infantile.
At home a degenerate class here strives to do Europe one better, and then some. Infantilism has crossed the Atlantic.
“a man’s admiration for absolute government is proportinate to the contempt he feels for those around him”. Tocqueville