“Avatar” Is a Steaming Pile of Sith


I have no plans to see this movie. But that doesn’t prevent me from commenting on it.

As an English major, the primary thing I am taught is the art of connection: connecting disparate threads, turning ideas over and around to see what they look like in a different light.

When I saw the commercials for James Cameron’s 15-years-in-the-making film opus, Avatar , the first connection I made was “This is Dances With Wolves with Blue People.” The second connection I made was “oh boy, here comes the ‘noble savage’ trope.

The infinitely interesting website “TV Tropes” defines a trope as “a conceptual figure of speech, a storytelling shorthand for a concept that the audience will recognize and understand instantly.” I think that’s a really good definition.

Within Western culture, liberals have fetishized the concept of the Noble Savage™, the idea that Modern Civilization (patent pending) is Evil, that technology has had a corrupting influence on the human soul.

We see strains of this primitivism in the radical liberalism of the Unabomber’s manifesto (“The Industrial Revolution and its consequences have been a disaster for the human race” ), the socially acceptable eco-terrorist movement , or the creation of plans about how Western civilization can be destroyed from the inside .

In the movie, the alien planet Pandora is rich in a resource that us Earthers desperately need to survive, a material unironically called “Unobtainium .” The Earthers’ “Resource Development Administration” declares all-out war against the native Na’vi to get this Unobtainum with the “Avatar program”—a human consciousness remotely controls a Na’vi, as Pandora’s atmosphere is unbreathable by humans.

The main character is recruited into the Avatar program, and infiltrates the tribe of nine-foot-tall Noble Savages, and ends up switching sides to fight the humans’ plan to enact a tacky World Trade Center-like attack on the Na’vi “Home Tree,” complete with human gusto-filled descriptive phrases such as “pre-emptive [attacks] to fight terror with terror.”

In case you don’t get the analogy, we (the humans) are the Bad Guys who are going to attack the “Tower” that the Noble Savages hold dear. In other words, humans are attacking the environment with technology, and it’s analogous to 9/11. Americanism is terrorism, in other words.

This ham-fisted anti-Americanism in the movies is hardly new, though.

If you recall, in the movie Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith, there was much tongue-wagging about whether or not the Big Bad Darth Sidious/Chancellor Palpatine and his actions were meant to be taken to be analogues to President George W. Bush.

When asked by the Ottawa Sun , actor Hayden Christensen (Anakin Skywalker) replied that the movie “absolutely […] takes metaphoric shots at the war-mongering politics of U.S. presidents Richard Nixon and the two George Bushes.”

Christensen, who has all the acting acumen of a 2×4, went on to say that “I think for that reason the French will be really responsive to it. I think they’ll get it. They’ll get the political commentary and the subtext. Anakin says: ‘If you’re not with me, you’re my enemy!’ I think they’ll love it."

In Sith , Palpatine used a manufactured war to gain dictatorial power, and in later movies went on to dissolve the movie universe’s version of Congress, as the Galactic Senate was resisting him on certain measures.

At this point, I think President Obama is closer to "dissolving the Senate"—making the Legislative Branch irrelevant and impotent —than Bush ever was.

No one should be surprised that Hollywood liberals hate America and Western Civilization, nor should anyone be surprised that Hollywood liberals such as James Cameron or George Lucas use their artificial elevation as commanders of movie industry to espouse their anti-Western viewpoints in the form of their “visions.”

That doesn’t mean I can’t bitch about it, though.

[Crossposted at your one-stop shop for Ohio and national politics news, Athens Runaway . ]


Category: , , , ,

RSS feed

11 Comments Leave a comment

It's James Cameron - Whadya Expect?!

IJB Sunday, December 13th at 8:24PM EST (link)

The guy’s *way* past his prime. In fact, he took so long after “Titanic”, he probably just should have retired then.

 

Generally agree, but...

Hermes (Diary) Sunday, December 13th at 10:33PM EST (link)

“Within Western culture, liberals have fetishized the concept of the Noble Savage™, the idea that Modern Civilization (patent pending) is Evil, that technology has had a corrupting influence on the human soul.”

You are painting with far too broad a brush here. I can think of several utterly non-liberal thinkers who are quite anti-modernity and anti-technology: Heidegger, Kierkegaard, Chesterton, Marion, Weaver, Kirk, Fleming. The list is actually pretty long.

I don’t disagree that certain segments of the American left have an instinctual anti-modern tendency, but just as many are happy technocrats: Matthew Yglesias, Glenn Greenwald, Kos, Barack Obama, etc.

Tolkien was another

aesthete (Diary) Sunday, December 13th at 10:59PM EST (link)

classical liberal with qualms concerning technology — I suppose he’d be considered a “crunchy con” nowadays.

The act of defending any of the cardinal virtues has today all the exhilaration of a vice – G.K. Chesterton

If he was, then why'd he deny that interpretation?

Neil Stevens (Diary) Sunday, December 13th at 11:01PM EST (link)

The Lord of the Rings is the story of Jesus, retold in his mythology.

Nothing to do with technology.

RS contributing editor, technical administrator, and “a hardy variety of crabgrass.”
Read the RedState Posting Rules

Unlikely Voter: Poll Analysis, Election Projection.

“I rejoice that America has resisted.” – William Pitt, the Elder

I happen to know a bit about Tolkien

Finrod (Diary) Monday, December 14th at 2:27AM EST (link)

Tolkien despised allegory in all its forms. The seeming ‘anti-technology’ theme comes from the rural land of his youth being gobbled up by the expansion of the nearby large city (unfortunately, I don’t remember which one). The closest he ever came to assigning real people to his characters was that he identified himself as Beren and his wife as Luthien; in fact those names are even on their respective tombstones. I recall Tolkien explicitly stating that if you’re looking for a particular real-world meaning in LotR, you’re mistaken because there is none; I don’t have my Tolkien books unpacked yet, otherwise I’d quote the man himself.

Let’s get down to brass tacks here. How much for the ape?

 

I take that from his letters

aesthete (Diary) Monday, December 14th at 6:27AM EST (link)

He was very Burkean in his politics, such as they were, but he was a lifelong nature lover, and as Finrod said, was somewhat informed by the rural lands of his youth having been urbanized. It’s unlikely that those views were consciously transferred to his writing, though; Tolkien was notorious for disliking allegory.

The act of defending any of the cardinal virtues has today all the exhilaration of a vice – G.K. Chesterton

 
 
 
 

This is pretty much all the same impressions I got

kyle8 (Diary) Sunday, December 13th at 11:34PM EST (link)

from the trailers. (1)Evil military, planet rapers (read Americans), noble savages in tune with nature (read all approved victim groups).

In fact Dances with Wolves was a huge piece of crap for that very reason. Although not as bad as Quigly Down Under (dances with Roo’s)

I’ll pass.

“Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty”
Kyle

 

yes, yes...

DONTREADONME (Diary) Sunday, December 13th at 11:44PM EST (link)

you nailed it on Avatar. Another anti-American film wrapped in the storyline of the American Indians versus the American settlers difference is a pornographic vison of what would have happened if the American settlers would have lost.

News flash to all stupid Hollywood screen writers, producers, and directors, humans will never break the bounds of our planet unless we push technology beyond all bounds of current understanding. One last thing is that those avatar tribes would have destroyed humans if they were the ones with the technology. Greed and power are not symptoms of just man, we call these things in the animal kingdom survival of the fittest, instict, and territorial/domination.

 

e South Park Version Is Better...

rcov092 (Diary) Monday, December 14th at 12:50AM EST (link)

Dances with Smurfs! ROTF!

“Not One Red Dime for the NRSC or NRCC till they stop trying to elect liberals”

 

I Cannot Resist, Ladies and Gentleman, Dances with Smurfs

rcov092 (Diary) Monday, December 14th at 12:55AM EST (link)

Explained:

“Not One Red Dime for the NRSC or NRCC till they stop trying to elect liberals”

Thanks rcov, I'd recommend that comment!! nt

nessa (Diary) Monday, December 14th at 12:59AM EST (link)

“If you love wealth more than liberty, the tranquility of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom, depart from us in peace. We ask not your counsel nor your arms. Crouch down and lick the hand that feeds you. May your chains rest lightly upon you and may posterity forget that you were our countrymen.”—Samuel Adams

Contributor to Unified Patriots

teh twitter