Conservatives Ignore Culture at Their Peril


Andrew Breitbart writes that conservatives won’t fix their Internet problem until they fix their culture problems. Writes Breitbart:

The Democratic Party resonates on the Internet because it resonates in pop culture. The Democratic Party resonates in pop culture because it has been committed to dominating it for over a generation…

The spectacular Will.I.Am song and video, “Yes We Can,” could not be duplicated by Republicans if T. Boone Pickens airdropped his fortune on the RNC headquarters.

The Mac versus PC advertising campaign best sums up the stark divide. Only it’s much worse.

What the Republican Party needs to do now is figure out how to make up for 40 years of ignoring the net effect of film, television and music, and the youth culture that goes along with it. When will the people who make the big decisions and write the big checks realize the AM radio band is not enough?

As I’ve written and stated many times, college Republicans and other young conservative activists need to go Hollywood – in mind, spirit and even in location.

I don’t know if it’s quite as bleak as Breitbart says, but it is a challenge for conservatives. Here’s the deal. It seems that most of the people leading on the right are so left-brained towards fields like finance, business, or government that they can’t even grasp the idea of cultural productions as anything more than diversions.

When in reality, culture really turns the wheel of society and in fact is often far out front of government. Culture defines how many people think about issues. Something as simple as who the good guys and who the bad guys are can move people’s views of the world.

Of course, works of culture need not be about specific topics. One example of this if Harrison Ford’s 1993 Hit “The Fugitive.” The plot: A doctor is wrongfully accused and convicted of the murder of his wife. He escape and seeks to clear his name. It was based on a 1960s TV Show.  In the 1960s show, the villain was a one-armed man, a simple thug who did the crime. *spoiler warning ahead*

But we couldn’t have that in 1993. The source of villainy was an evil corporation that wanted to get their heart drug approved by the FDA even though it caused liver problems, because we all know it’s better to make a few hundred million in sales and then get hit by a multi-billion dollar class action lawsuit when someone else figures out the problem.

And how did Deputy U.S. Marshall Samuel Gerard figure out the company was behind it. He quoted it’s Market CAP of several billion dollars and said, ”It’s a monster.”

Yes, any corporation with a larget Market CAP is a criminal enterprise ready to kill you and/or frame you for murder in order to kill other Americans because of their insatiable greed. Thus, to many Americans, if you say, “My name is Bob, I work for a Fortune 500 company…” they’ll think, “Must be a soulless robot.”  

Now, if conservatives are smart, we’ll see more films that feature labor unions as the bad guys. Such an effort would produce a situation where people would think, “So you work for the mafia?” when they introduce themselves as a leader of a union.

While my fellow conservatives may look at me as if I’m from another planet when I mention that I write Science Fiction, my cultural efforts will continue as they matter more long-term than my political ones.



RSS feed

24 Comments Leave a comment

Recommended! nt

Xasteius (Diary) Monday, January 19th at 11:04PM EST (link)

Don’t leave the party, hijack it back!

The only poll that counts is the one at the ballot box.

I don’t want to be Reagan. I want to be a Chance/Soros hybrid.

 

Hollywood is not a viable option...

rbdwiggins (Diary) Tuesday, January 20th at 7:08AM EST (link)

for the promotion of conservative principles and values. It has not been a viable option since Public Law 79-601 was enacted and the House Committee on Un-American Activities was added to the congressional list of standing committees.

Hollywood’s anti-American position is clear and unambiguous. Its position hasn’t even been “questionable” since the aftermath of the 1968 Democratic National Convention.

Our energies would be better spent reforming our government schools and holding them accountable.

“Well, the trouble with our liberal friends is not that they are ignorant, but that they know so much that isn’t so.” – Ronald Reagan

If Hollywood Won't Work...

adamsweb (Diary) Tuesday, January 20th at 9:53AM EST (link)

Make movies outside of Hollywood.

Adam's Blog

You Won't Like The Real Answer To This...

IJB Tuesday, January 20th at 10:29AM EST (link)

…but it’s to drive the American film and TV industry into the ground.

It’s heading that way anyway – American TV is increasingly importing product from Canada, Australia and the U.K. anyway.

But, ironically, the only way to get films and TV that are less hostile to this nation and its culture is to drive its production out of this country and effectively sub-contract it out to other nations.

(Personally, I’d love to see Washington go after Hollywood & NYC punitively until they’re no longer able to stay in business. It would serve Hollywood right considering all the times Hollywood has tried to put other industries in this country out of business. It really would be poetic justice…)

 

In order to change the culture...

rbdwiggins (Diary) Tuesday, January 20th at 10:32AM EST (link)

which is what you’re really advocating IMHO, a counter-culture movement will be required. Because conservative principles are so completely at odds with modern-American pop-culture, too many Americans have no historical perspective from which to base their decision-making process. That only leaves “an emotional response” to any pressing issue they may face.

Because the audience is captive, the only viable, long-term option is to reform our government schools and educate, as opposed to indoctrinate, the future leaders of the Conservative Movement.

“Well, the trouble with our liberal friends is not that they are ignorant, but that they know so much that isn’t so.” – Ronald Reagan

Bingo.

scottbomb (Diary) Thursday, January 22nd at 11:32AM EST (link)

nt

www.HowObamaGotElected.com

“The American people will never knowingly adopt socialism. But, under the name of ‘liberalism’, they will adopt every fragment of the socialist program, until one day America will be a socialist nation, without knowing how it happened.” – Norman Thomas, U.S. Socialist Party presidential candidate 1940, 1944 and 1948

 
 
 
 

unfortunately It will never really change

kyle8 (Diary) Tuesday, January 20th at 7:53AM EST (link)

Because “creative” people, for the most part, are ONLY interested in their art at a young age. They take no time to learn anything about the rest of the world and just absorb the feel good left wing views of their contemporaries.

Later, as they get older they might take more of an interest in the outside world, but since they are ignorant this usually manifests in grabbing some politically correct cause to champion.

As you said, those more interested in actually doing something, business, military, technology, are the ones more likely to become moderate or conservative. But they are simply not interested, or lack the talent, to move into the arts.

It takes a certain type of person to do a certain type of job, it has always been that way and will continue to be.

“Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty”
Kyle

 

amen adamsweb, you echo a call I have been making for a decade

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Tuesday, January 20th at 9:36AM EST (link)

Conservatives must compete in the culture by making TV shows and movies; becoming professors, deans and Chancellors for universities; and owning press outlets and becoming journalists.

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

 

Hollywood is first about making money.

Achance (Diary) Tuesday, January 20th at 10:41AM EST (link)

Yes, the natural bent of actors and writers and such is to be liberal tending degenerate. It seems to have come with the talent since time immemorial. That said, the people who pay the creative types, though they may themselves be liberal, are about making money and as such are acutely attuned to what the consumer is interested in buying.

If you think back to the ’70s, we’d been on a steady diet of anti-heroes and degenerates for a decade or more. Then, along come the Dirty Harry movies, the Rambo movies, even Star Wars was nothing more than a ’40s or ’50s Western set in space. Alll of those movies were in direct opposition to the cultureal elites’ thrust to the left and moral ambiguity and I think it is fair to say that they presaged the coming of morning to America.

In Vino Veritas

I Think Your Model Is Obsolete

IJB Tuesday, January 20th at 11:17AM EST (link)

The problem with that old model is that all “traditional” Media – TV, movies, print – is in decline.

Effectively, this means that the days of increasing profits and earnings are over.

What is left is more players fighting over increasingly smaller and smaller pieces of the pie.

The result of this is that *no one* is truly trying to “broadcast” anymore. No one is trying to capture the entire audience anymore. It’s all about “narrowcasting” and capturing smaller, more homogeneous segments of the audience.

The problem here is that this frees the artistic types from any pretense of trying to put out truly ‘universalist’ entertainment, and instead allows them all to indulge in their absurd proclivities in politics and philosophy.

That’s one reason why you haven’t seen anyone attempt to do a truly popular, “widely appealing” movie about the Iraq War, and instead we’ve seen a string of about a half-dozen narrowly tailored ‘independent’ anti-war screed films – these guys aren’t even trying (much at all) to capture “wide” audiences these days.

Basically, because everyone is trying to “narrowcast”, pretty much everyone is trying to go after the same relatively upscale, money-spending leftie crowd, because that’s really all they know. Outside of that, there are smatterings of basically apolitical “family movies” (e.g. Harry Potter). And there’s not much else.

Hollywood really can’t and won’t target “centrist” (and certainly not “rightist”) mainstream fare anymore because, 1) they don’t have to anymore, and 2) they don’t know how to even if they did want to (which they don’t).

Therefore, if you’re waiting for Hollywood to “come around again”, I fear this time you’ll be waiting in vain.

That’s why I think the best solution is “to drive a stake into the beast”, and use the nasty behemoth that is the federal government to effectively force Hollyweird out of business…

 
 

The Dark Knight says Hi

sayers (Diary) Thursday, January 22nd at 1:53AM EST (link)

I don’t know if Christopher Nolan is a conservative but I thought the parallels to the War on Terror could not have been more obvious in The Dark Knight.

He's leaves it ambiguous....

J. Leg (Diary) Thursday, January 22nd at 4:55AM EST (link)

…the film obviously shows Batman doing things and taking measures that resemble the Bush administration’s actions during the War on Terror, Chris doesn’t reveal his thoughts behind this, but when asked he did offer a devil’s advocate sort of response and says he feels the film asks, “How do you respond to someone who feeds off of violence?”

It’s not neccessarilly a liberal question, conservatives wrestle with this as well, but it could be interpruted differently.

 
 

The Dark Knight says Hi

sayers (Diary) Thursday, January 22nd at 1:53AM EST (link)

I don’t know if Christopher Nolan is a conservative but I thought the parallels to the War on Terror could not have been more obvious in The Dark Knight.

 

John Adams series comes to mind

vital0gy Thursday, January 22nd at 10:32AM EST (link)

I’d like to see more biographical films along the lines of the John Adams mini-series on HBO. My 12 year old son liked the movie so much that he started reading the book. It took him almost 2 months to get through it, and now he wants to read up on TJ.

 

Conservatives Should Support Andy Garcia's "Lost City"

Swamp_Yankee (Diary) Thursday, January 22nd at 11:16AM EST (link)

Cuban-American Garcia spent 16 years making this epic about Cuba. Its a little long and dry at spots, but it was completely blacklisted because of its premise. The 2005 film starred people like Garcia, Dustin Hoffman and Bill Murray, but Garcia refused to listen to the Hollywood editors.

GET THIS. He demanded the thruth be told. about Castro and Cuba. The film makes mortal mistake of actually showing Che murdering people, showing Castro is a less then admirable light and showing pre-Castro Cuba as a flawed, but relatively peaceful and prosperous place.

So this historically accurate epic went nowhere.

Want to support conservative Hollywood, buy “Lost City”

 

You want a culture change? Start with Great Awakenings...

Cheetah772 (Diary) Thursday, January 22nd at 11:32AM EST (link)

Look, I don’t know about you, but I am a born-again Christian, and I believe that cultural values doesn’t appear in vacuum, they have to come from somewhere. And it is within the spiritual realm, where moral and cultural values are formed.

Think about it. Americans in early history dressed modestly and shied away from talking about sex and other taboos, because that was morally and culturally unacceptable. Such customs existed because Americans back then were deeply religious people. Over years, customs were dropped and more vile ones were adapted as norm, partly due to the fact the grip on upholding religious values slipped away.

Going Hollywood won’t help conservative causes at all, because at its most basic level, Hollywood culture is always opposed to the idea of keeping old-fashioned principles in every category imaginable. The best way possible to keep conservatism alive is preaching the Gospel of Jesus Christ, who has died on the Cross for our sins, buried for three days, and resurrected from the dead, calling on His name to save us from spending eternity in Hell. I actually believe that partly because of numerous spiritual revivals in 19th and early 20th centuries, which were done in a biblical way (unlike Billy Graham’s revival meetings today) helped to keep America on the right track and closer to the right of center politically.

Destroy the spiritual values, and there will be an instantaneous change in cultural and moral makeups of American society. That’s how Hollywood become as it is today, because it had no concept of being morally and spiritually upright. Changing culture through any other means will prove in the end to be ineffective.

I’m sorry if I seem to be harsh, but that’s something I strongly believe in. GOP and conservatism alone aren’t going to change America for better, only the Lord and Savior Jesus Christ can do that….

Daniel 2:20 And he [God] changeth the times and seasons: he removeth kings, and setteth up kings: he giveth wisdom unto the wise, and knowledge to them that know understanding.

People generally repent and seek meaning when

wennejunk (Diary) Friday, January 23rd at 4:46PM EST (link)

God brings them to their knees.

Many see today’s financial crises as God’s intervention in our lives.

Perhaps by shaking the very solid reliance (in both secular and evangelical circles) on money, wealth and possessions as the main source of security in people’s lives, He can turn our attention from self absorption to Him.

This is where Christians need to be standing apart in the sense that

1) how we handle/have handled our finances should be biblical and an example for non-believers and also weak-believers

and also

2) in those cases where Christians have been pulled down financially in the mess that surrounds us, we need to be reacting in a way that shows the trappings of life are nothing compared to the faith we have been given.

Failing this in one or both cases, we have failed to witness.

There are only two kinds of people in the end: those who say to God, ‘Thy will be done,’ and those to whom God says, in the end, ‘Thy will be done.’ -C. S. Lewis

 
 

There is a market

drohan00 (Diary) Thursday, January 22nd at 11:50AM EST (link)

for traditionally based films. But that market is almost exclusively from the religious right. I mean the Passion of the Christ was a phenomenon.

Films depicting the evils of collectivism are rare these days. I think a re-make of 1984, and some focus on what goes on in China and North Korea would be apropos. What we need is some over-arching understanding of what the drift to collectivism is. Then we’ll be in better shape.

What kills us is our inability to teach conservative moral values to our kids anymore. I think there is a generation coming up that notices the dark side of secular progressivism, but we need to offer the alternative, which for many is traditional religion. While that is not a “growth” sector, we should focus on religious films, and then branch out. Capitalism is something that is difficult to have an emotional attachment to.

It's an image problem!!!

From ME to You (Diary) Thursday, January 22nd at 12:37PM EST (link)

“Conservatives” are viewed as “stick in the mud” types who can’t really enjoy themselves! You know, the “country club” types where a party means sitting around the club room sipping cocktails and looking down their noses at “the little people”, you know…Leona Helmsley types.

That perception hurts us.We have failed to adapt our message to the media! NOTE..I did not say change the message!!

We can’t be afraid of “newness”! We should not be “tech” phobic but learn to embrace the new communications technologies. I, personally have no need to ‘Twitter” but if conservatives can use that to get the message out, have at it!

Our job should be to broadcast, narrowcast and every other type of ‘cast’ our message using every means at our disposal and maybe create new means not yet thought of!

Photobucket
 
 

This is why Sarah Palin resonates

azaeroprof (Diary) Thursday, January 22nd at 2:45PM EST (link)

so well with conservatives. She is “real” and “glamorous” in a way that very few conservative politicians or intellectuals do. (I mean, it took a Hollywood actor to finally elect a conservative Prez!).

Idea for Hollywood that might just actually sell: a biopic on Barry Goldwater. A true American “maverick” with solid conservative credentials and quite a personal story. Conservatives would see it in droves, others would go if it were well-made and well-cast. Who would play Barry???

Fred! n/t

wennejunk (Diary) Friday, January 23rd at 4:33PM EST (link)

Who else?

There are only two kinds of people in the end: those who say to God, ‘Thy will be done,’ and those to whom God says, in the end, ‘Thy will be done.’ -C. S. Lewis

 
 

The future is not traditional

moderich (Diary) Thursday, January 22nd at 9:55PM EST (link)

NASCAR, Country Music, South Park, Tom Clancy books & movies, etc… conservative entertainment mediums already exist, and some are massively popular (and lucrative). That’s the best you’re going to get, IMHO.

The internet is a game changer that renders so-con efforts pointless. The web is implicity libertarian, egalitarian and future oriented — and the kids growing up within this new cultural framework are increasingly more individualistic and yet socially conscious. From here on out, I expect culture to steer more strongly to a soft-libertarianism (that is, neither conservative or liberal).

The Barna group has already documented this trend among 30 and under born-agains and evangelicals. If you can’t win in your own backyard, well…

Austere, intolerant, well-armed, and blood-thirsty, in their own regions the Wahhabis are a distinct factor which must be taken into account” – Winston Churchill, 1921

 

Truth is not trendy, apparently...

DONTREADONME (Diary) Sunday, January 25th at 12:42AM EST (link)

That is the conservatives problem with Pop Culture. Conservatism is hard and liberalism is easy, this is the problem. Children and young adults do not want the hard path they choose the easiest because they want to hang out with their friends. Unfortunately, to appeal to this crowd we would have to sacrifice our ethics and principles to lie to them.

God, Abstinence, Patriotism (National Pride) and Career are not trendy either

DONTREADONME (Diary) Sunday, January 25th at 12:43AM EST (link)