Gleichschaltung, a German word we should understand.


(I originally wrote this as a comment, but I’d like to try to stimulate a little discussion.)

It means something like coming together or bringing together, but people who write about the Nazi Era usually translate it as coordination. Coordination is used to describe the process by which the NSDAP insinuated itself into and gained control of the civil and economic institutions of Germany. We’re watching it now but from the other side.

Some of you know that recent political events have caused me to start looking into the poltics of Weimar Republic in more detail than the “Cabaret” level. Up until about 1928, Germany could have gone either way: remained a liberal constitutional republic, adopted Soviet-style communism, or turned to the NSDAP (Nazis), with the odds somewhat favoring the communists. The Worldwide economic downturn added staggering unemployment to already staggering inflation in Germany. Inflation is tolerable to people if they can make themselves worth more to more or less keep up with it. Germany’s system of unionization and compulsory arbitration (See, e.g., EFCA) had allowed labor to inflate wages with the inflating currency. But, with the deepening depression, many were thrown onto the welfare rolls where falling government revenues precluded the benefits from keeping up with the inflation well enough to provide for the most basic needs. Enter the Nazis.

Business and industry were straitened by the depression and infuriated with the unions, the communists, and the government’s labor policies. While one might not expect business and industry to make common cause with the National Socialist German Workers Party, the English translation of the NSDAP or Nazi Party’s name, the Nazis brought them into the fold with promises of money, growth, and power through bailouts and a massive public works stimulus program. The business assets and processes remained nominally private but they remained so on sufferance of the Nazis. That sufferance depended on their coordination of the activities of the business to the activities of the Nazi Party. Starting to look familiar.

Then the Nazis struck out against their political enemies. For them those were the communists, the unions, and the social democrats (liberals). First, they vilified and intimidated them by means that would make Saul Alinsky proud. As they gained power in the states, they used that power to actively suppress the opposition. Perhaps the most successful early coordination was between the Nazis and the judicial system. While in America the Nazis are usually portrayed as working class thugs, the Nazis had a strong following in the universities, in the professions, and, especially, in the legal community. Thus, they quickly got a strong grasp on the German judicial system and used that system to suppress opposition. Before long in a nation that had prided itself in its positivist legal system was issueing judicial opinions based on “the healthy opinion of the volk.” You find that phrase over and over in the court decisions that countenanced the complete takeover of German society by the Nazi Party.

On thing I admire about thoughtful communists is the fact that they work very hard at understanding their defeats. The greatest defeat communism ever suffered was losing Germany and unleashing the Nazis on the Soviet Union, an event which brought the end of communism to within a dozen miles of Moscow. There are lots of thoughtful communists in America and they’ve been waiting for this moment for a very long time. They are definitively not clueless. They are embarked on a program of coordination with the civic and political institutions that are not unalterable opposed to them and are busily setting up the mechanisms by which they will eliminate those, mostly on the right, who will not “come together” with them. Those who don’t know the past are doom to repeat it. Those who do know the past are doomed to be surrounded by people who don’t.

We are facing a perfect political and economic storm.  Either the government will print so much money that the dollar becomes debased or our trading partners and lenders will lose faith in the American government and economy.  Either way, we are facing massive inflation of the sort that destroys retirement plans and savings.   People on SS or other retirement or wage schemes indexed to CPI will feel real pain shortly.  The CPI will remain static or even drop since deflating housing is so heavily weighted by BLS, but all other goods and services will be inflating dramatically.  Heat or eat will be life’s great choice for many retirees.  Need I remind you that there are over 75 million Baby Boomers at or nearing retirement.  EFCA will bring about massive unionization in vital industries, especially healthcare, retail, and the remaining high-tech manufacturing as well as the Southern auto and other manufacturing.  The arbitration provisions in EFCA will result in spiraling wages followed by dramatic layoffs.  The fracturing economy will severely curtail government revenue and it will not be able to keep up the bread and circuses and transfer payments or inflate them enough to keep the mob sullen but not mutinous.  Then the only question is who hits the barricades first and what the government does about it.  Do we turn left or right?


Category: , , ,

RSS feed

46 Comments Leave a comment

Scary and prophetic at the same time.

Finrod (Diary) Friday, February 20th at 1:44PM EST (link)

This is one of those articles that I wish I could find fault with, because its conclusions scare the bejabbers out of me, but I can’t. Good job, and recommended.

Let’s get down to brass tacks here. How much for the ape?

 

Art, what would it mean for the U.S. to turn right?

civil truth (Diary) Friday, February 20th at 4:46PM EST (link)

In Weimar Germany you described a three-directional fork.

I don’t see a right-dictatorship force in the U.S. right now that has any credible following.

And the Bush era could not be viewed as “right” – it was far more centrist by historical U.S. standards.

But I don’t see how the American people would embrace an alternative that would be labeled as a return to the Bush era.

So what are the centrist and right alternatives – or does the Weimar parallel break down here, and there is only one alternative to the left. And if so, what is the “right” alternative.

The greatest evil…is conceived and ordered (moved, seconded, carried, and minuted) in clean, carpeted, warmed, and well-lighted offices, by quiet men with white collars and cut fingernails and smooth-shaven cheeks who do not need to raise their voice. Hence, naturally enough, my symbol for Hell is something like the bureaucracy of a police state or the offices of a thoroughly nasty business concern. -C.S. Lewis

http://www.gmsplace.com/

Agree that moderates get trampled when left and right fight

civil truth (Diary) Friday, February 20th at 5:38PM EST (link)

The Russian and French revolutions are prime examples of that truism.

However, my question still remains: who constitutes the “right” that would stand against our left totalitarians. Who could form an effective counterforce if the SEIU and Ayers and other communist planners get their juggernaut moving?

I’m not sure I see a coherent right opposition that could take it to the streets. Besides, such a battle would likely destroy our country both because of internal damage from a civil war plus the opportunity that outside enemies could exploit because our defenses against outsiders would be neglected.

And frankly, once you strip away the romantic fantasy, a rag tag group of suvivalists who are as likely to shoot each other than the common enemy are not a match for a modern army with it’s remarkable surveillance and firepower.

(I’m reminded of the old Monty Python survival skit.)

While they might be tolerated at the fringes, they couldn’t prevail in any direct confrontation. Rather, they’d have to wait for collapse, and that would represent the end of the U.S. as a remotely recognizable entity.

Which means that the “moderates” (not RINOs, etc. of today’s common parlance) – that is, those who believe in a constitutional republic form of government rooted in free enterprise and minimal governmental function – are going to have to abort the left early on and recapture governance before the left subverts the constitutional process.

The greatest evil…is conceived and ordered (moved, seconded, carried, and minuted) in clean, carpeted, warmed, and well-lighted offices, by quiet men with white collars and cut fingernails and smooth-shaven cheeks who do not need to raise their voice. Hence, naturally enough, my symbol for Hell is something like the bureaucracy of a police state or the offices of a thoroughly nasty business concern. -C.S. Lewis

http://www.gmsplace.com/

No, not really thinking in terms of the "survivalist right."

Achance (Diary) Friday, February 20th at 6:30PM EST (link)

I think the urban left and the blacks start the civil disruption and neither the Blue city/state governments nor the fed handle it because of political considerations. Then you get a serious armed more or less conservative citizen backlash. The cops drop their allegiance to the city governments and states, so the governments have little control. The military righteously pleades posse comitatus and if federalized mutinies. Yeah, ugly stuff. Red states with blue cities could be particularly ugly since they’re mostly in The South where everybody outside the cities is armed and many are ex-military. Some old scores get settled.

Any way I game this, a lot of people die, so, you’re right, we need to abort this.

In Vino Veritas

To revise and extend my remarks,

Achance (Diary) Saturday, February 21st at 12:32PM EST (link)

much depends on what the uniformed military does if we have real conflict in the Country. A truly leftwing federal administration would probably reach for the UN and cede US sovereignty to UN “peacekeepers” who could be given nominal authority over the US uniformed military and then used to “restore order.”

We can rest assured that everybody promoted to general officer from here on out will be thoroughly vetted to be a squish just as Clinton did. Give BHO enough time, say second term, and the military will be “coordinated” with the Administration. That would set up some potential for real conflict between Red State governors and the federal government should the US attempt to federalize the National Guard to “suppress the rebellion,” to use Lincoln’s fateful words.

This is the stuff of horror, but I truly believe that The One and his string pullers really, really want that Revolution of their drug-induced dreams in the ’60s. They probably think they can pull it off with only enough resistance that the resisters can be dismissed as whackos and easily suppressed, e.g., Waco and Ruby Ridge. And they’re right if the Right strikes the first blows. The US will go after the militias and other miltant conservatives with everything short of nukes and the media and the Country will approve. One thing we conservatives/Republicans really need to do is have some outreach towards the militant right and use every ounce of persuasion to keep them from striking first.

But, as I said earlier, the most likely scenario is that BHO is unable to keep the cities happy. Even in good times you can’t give the Looters and Moochers enough no matter how hard you try. As times get bad, and they will, the cities ignite and begin to attack the suburbs and exurbs. Then it’s Helter-Skelter.

In Vino Veritas

Wait, er, what?

falsehood (Diary) Monday, February 23rd at 11:56PM EST (link)

They want a revolution? Where in the world did you get that idea?

Go away, Troll. nt

Achance (Diary) Tuesday, February 24th at 1:30PM EST (link)

In Vino Veritas

 
 
 
 

not really

kyle8 (Diary) Friday, February 20th at 6:31PM EST (link)

The moderates will never do so because, well they are moderates.

If there is any blowback against our leftward march it will come from three areas.
(1) Conservatives and Libertarians
(2) Apolitical people who finally wake up when their ox finally gets gored
(3) Disillusioned lefties, who could become more conservative than the conservatives (that already happened with an earlier generation of “neoconservatives”.)

“Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty”
Kyle

Both Libertarians Are In.

farstar99 (Diary) Monday, February 23rd at 7:49PM EST (link)

I knocked on their door earlier and they said they’ll join the fight.
The apoliticals are too busy watching the Oscars on TiVo.
The disillusioned Lefties won’t fight, so they’re good to anyone, anyway. The first time Obama offered them cash or power, they’d turn on us.

 

Disagree

falsehood (Diary) Monday, February 23rd at 11:58PM EST (link)

We might not take an active role (and yes, I’m a moderate), but we’ll show up and vote.

The only thing in the middle of the road

Achance (Diary) Tuesday, February 24th at 4:46AM EST (link)

is a yellow line and dead skunks.

In Vino Veritas

 
 

Or Moderates who realize

AKSteveB (Diary) Tuesday, February 24th at 3:02AM EST (link)

the ground has moved beneath them and we are entering a ‘If you aren’t part of the solution, you are part of the problem” time. This is just a strange time.

Just as an example, the folks on here have been ranting about “The Mainstream Media” for years, and I thought they were way over the top. Last year that mainstream media didn’t even bother with the pretense of objectivity. People on here threw around the word “Socialist” relating to Obama quite frequently. That also seemed over the top to me. I generally try to put facts in front of ideology. Well guess what, the “crazies” here were RIGHT. I still don’t know whether they were always right, and it just took till now to see it, or whether it was Obama moving so far left so fast, or what his faces quivering groin that changed it all, but here we are. I’m not arrogant enough to think that just because I’ve noticed this, that everyone else has, but I am willing to bet I’m far from the only one.

Hell is other people – Sartre

 
 
 
 

Now you've gone and made me think!

Achance (Diary) Friday, February 20th at 5:04PM EST (link)

There really is no such thing as a wild-eyed moderate, so I think the center does not hold in any destabilized situation. To borrow the lefty cant, you’re a part of the problem or you’re a part of the solution. A corollary to that is that most are just sitting on the sidelines trying to live their lives only to wake up one morning to find the world has moved under them. So, I think the left dukes it out with the right and the vast middle sits it out but some of them ally with one or the other.

I don’t see the right in America doing anything like what the Germans did, but I see a conflict that could be very brutal. I think the left and their black allies will know no bounds in the things they would do; lots of hate stored up on that side of the ditch. Helter-Skelter and all that.

So, I’m investing in precious metal: lead and brass.

In Vino Veritas

It is all about reference...

DONTREADONME (Diary) Friday, February 20th at 6:57PM EST (link)

who determines what the right, left and moderates are? I would say that by historiy’s standard (My Opinion) we here at red state well some of us would be considered left compared to the Jefferson, Adams, etc… Unfortunately, compared to the Obama administration and the Bush Administration we are far-right and right respectively. When it comes to defining extreme left and right I think about socialism, fascism and communism and monarchy, anarchy and theocracy again respectively. Either direction is a really horrible state of affairs, I am just trying to point out that the reference has been set by someone, for now the country believes (for the time being) they are moderate like Obama… haha… To add, history seems to indicate that the US is destined for continual movement to the left… unless something happens drastically over the next few decades I am afraid we will be considered the old timer extremists. Viva Le Revolucion

The Reference range has changed drastically

AKSteveB (Diary) Saturday, February 21st at 3:12PM EST (link)

in the last month. As I was saying in another thread, The Republicans/”the Right” now ARE the big tent whether they like it or not. There is no more room amongst the Dems for a realistic moderate. Even the Blue Dogs have been deballed. We (meaning self declared moderates) got hit by a 2×4 on this one. We expected Clinton Redux, a pragmatic power monger. I now realize how foolish it was to think that, but given the fact that it seemed like the Repubs were at least as bad as the Dems on fiscal sanity, it seemed reasonable at the time. What we ended up with is an Abbie Hoffman wet dream. Staying in the middle enables it. I’ve never been a political activist, and that will now have to change. I’m willing to bet there are a hell of alot more like me out there. In answer to what Art said, I can’t speak to the military side. I hope he is wrong, I’m certainly not willing to bet on it though. What we have to do now is organize, figure out what works, decide what the outer boundaries are (I’d say in this case, voting for the Stimulus), and then practice Reagan’s 11th Amendment
.

Hell is other people – Sartre

There are no fiscal conservatives...

falsehood (Diary) Monday, February 23rd at 11:59PM EST (link)

…in power, and there haven’t been for a long, long time. Even Reagan couldn’t get around to the governmental shrinking he promised.

Well it goes back to that reference

AKSteveB (Diary) Tuesday, February 24th at 2:50AM EST (link)

range again. Politics is the art of the possible. As an example, I think the horse is out of the barn already in terms of a true free market in health care. We can have a lot of ideological discussions (and I think we should), but we have to work in reality. We’re in a defensive position of trying to protect as much individual choice and minimum government interference in healthcare as possible. I’d guess that might be somewhere along the lines of a Mitt Romney Mass. plan. Is that truly what I want? No. Does it beat Single Payer, damned right it does.

Hell is other people – Sartre

Don't feed the troll, AKSteveB nt

Achance (Diary) Tuesday, February 24th at 1:30PM EST (link)

In Vino Veritas

I'm not a troll

falsehood (Diary) Tuesday, February 24th at 6:39PM EST (link)

It is not my goal to disrupt conversation, or to provoke anyone. I am a moderate without websites for political discussion, so I got to a variety of places. If you have recommendation for another place to do that, I welcome it. I’m not here to cause trouble.

Though I can understand why you’d think so.

You do a very good imitation of a troll. nt

Achance (Diary) Tuesday, February 24th at 6:43PM EST (link)

In Vino Veritas

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Strated Envisioning This Scenario Back In October

rcov092 (Diary) Sunday, February 22nd at 1:11AM EST (link)

started preparing then. I will tell you that given what I see with the patterns of weapons purchases and ammo purchases and food accumulation, there is a rather large contingent of Americans that seem to feel the need to prepare for this type of possibility.

My fear is that I will not have enough time to get fully prepared. Up until recently, I though the time horizon was out a few years. Now I cannot be so sure it is not months.

“Not One Red Dime for the NRSC or NRCC till they stop trying to elect liberals”

 
 

"...I’d like to try to stimulate a little discussion"

redneck_hippie (Diary) Friday, February 20th at 5:06PM EST (link)

Art, could you please use a synonym for stimulate? The word is a little out of favor–how about “spark?” But seriously, I do not disagree with your vision, these things are a matter of degree. What I keep coming back to is that the speed and secrecy of legislation are purposeful and indicate malintention of the socialists.

I’ve been thinking today that in America the path to power is paved with greenbacks instead of brownshirts. That is scaring me more than anything else. The socialists know they can only maintain by mesmerizing the dumb class with their great leader’s media persona.

There are so many dark aspects to the rise of socialism in our country. We downplay their implications at our peril.


Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

At some point the greenback strategy fails.

Achance (Diary) Friday, February 20th at 5:17PM EST (link)

I think money manipulation got us here. I know it has been poo-pooed here, but there was some serious currency manipulation and oil price manipulation leading into the election. But, I think my description of how they run out of moves is accurate and when they run out of moves, all Hell breaks loose.

There is a lot of potential violence in America if our fragile social order breaks down.

In Vino Veritas

Manipulation of minds (not money) takes

redneck_hippie (Diary) Friday, February 20th at 5:20PM EST (link)

a lot of greenbacks as evidenced by the money poured into the making of The One. What kills me is that he’s still at it. It is a disgrace.


Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

 

You are not alone in that thinking -nt

DONTREADONME (Diary) Friday, February 20th at 6:15PM EST (link)

The Soros Crowd...

rcov092 (Diary) Sunday, February 22nd at 1:14AM EST (link)

is deeply embedded in the mechanisms causing so much political contention. I see no reason to believe he is not involved in the financial turmoil. He has made his largest fortune off this sort of turmoil and has been convicted in France of financial manipulations contrary to law.

“Not One Red Dime for the NRSC or NRCC till they stop trying to elect liberals”

 
 
 

left and right are meaningless terms for what you describe, Achance

pilgrim (Diary) Saturday, February 21st at 12:27PM EST (link)

You are talking about folks with tremendous delusions of grandeur. They see their ideas and the power that they must control as something that cannot be questioned. Anything or anybody that gets in their way needs to be eliminated instead of engaged. No compromise and only unconditional surrender by their opponents. Islamists and communists are examples of folks like this.

Market capitalists make compromises in the marketplace every day, and I am still optimistic about capitalism. The rumors of its death are premature.


Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

I use them only for convenient reference, Pilgrim.

Achance (Diary) Saturday, February 21st at 12:36PM EST (link)

I know that for BHO and his string-pullers it is maily about their sense of superiority over EVERYONE of any political orientation. They are communists at heart and some are communists in the mind as well, others are your usual squishy limousine liberal, and most are simply opportunists. And I pretty much use Right for anyone who isn’t one of them but who is engaged in politics.

In Vino Veritas

Admit you were speaking in John Wayne's

AKSteveB (Diary) Saturday, February 21st at 3:04PM EST (link)

voice when you said “I use them only for convenient reference, Pilgrim!” Seriously, I can’t argue with you on the futurescape, I desperately hope you are wrong, but I have no faith that you are.

Hell is other people – Sartre

 

great column Ac-nt

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Saturday, February 21st at 10:53PM EST (link)

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

 
 
 

It would be good if more Americans knew civics and history

David123 (Diary) Saturday, February 21st at 11:20PM EST (link)

nt

David123

hey, that is my line!

Doc Holliday (Diary) Saturday, February 21st at 11:24PM EST (link)

ok it is possible others think the same way, actually I wish more did :)

Molon Labe!

 

Better if everyone knew about civics and history.

Rod_Patrick (Diary) Saturday, February 21st at 11:43PM EST (link)

EDUCATION
EDUCATION
EDUCATION
EDUCATION
….

But:

Who will teach us?

Almost all liberal professors in the Universities and Colleges are Marxists and Socialists…. and they use REVISED HISTORY texts authored by European nihilists.

Instead, we should advocate and shout:

UN-LEARN
UN-LEARN
UN-LEARN
UN-LEARN
….

Many Americans especially the newly graduates need to unlearn the wrong education and accounts of history and economic principles that they got from fliberal/marxist universities here in America.

I think the first work of RNC is to re-launch and finance:

CONSERVATIVE MOVEMENT IN SCHOOLS AND UNIVERSITIES.

Conservative students have been maligned and discriminated in school especially in the last 8 years.

We have never truly encouraged and helped them.

Knowing some history and civics makes me understand why conservatives are often correct

David123 (Diary) Sunday, February 22nd at 12:11AM EST (link)

A lot of what I see at Redstate seems like basics civics and common sense.

If more Americans knew basic civics and history, Obama would have done worse than McGovern did.

:-)

David123

 
 
 

Great post

antisocial (Diary) Sunday, February 22nd at 11:34PM EST (link)

The indicators are not good. Surprisingly lot of people seem to think this will pass and America will emerge stronger. The problem is situations are changing so fast and for the worse. America is headed towards socialism at a very disturbing pace. Looks like this administration is in a hurry to push through the socialist agenda. Social engineering and economic crisis make for a perfect combination.

Another problem is people who talk about socialism don’t quite understand it. There are striking parallels to what’s happening here and what happened in Germany or what happened in Italy.

Obama Doctrine – Boot On The Throat
—————————–
What is to be done?
——————————
No. You can’t – Moe Lane
——————————
The Emperor has no clothes!!!

 

total agreement

daveleroy (Diary) Monday, February 23rd at 9:32AM EST (link)

Last year, I helped my neighbor with a college course in economics and political theories, one of the first papers I helped him with involved a oligarchic fascist state and the rise of fascism. Although normally associated with right wing politics as in Spain, germany and Italy in the 1930s, I was also on my soapbox at the time railing against Obama. I believed then as I believe now even more that he is essentially a socialist disguised as a “democrat.” And the similarities between the rise of Hitler and Mussolini and Obama are striking. Both used financial disasters to gain power and once there, used the apparatus of a capitalist system to consolidate power. If this country survives as capitalist democracy, we will be studying how Barack Obama led America into its first truly fascist government (although FDR came damn close). Using the economy as an excuse to pass a large part of his liberal/socialist agenda, look for “workers of the world to unite” with his pro-union legislation and de facto take over of the media. They already had academia and they seized the economy. Just look at the Orwellian names of the laws being passed- Economy Recovery and Stabilization Act (very sterile unil you read it), the “Fairness Doctrine” (anything but), and Employee Free Choice Act (free choice? democratic principles?). And socialized medicine is still on the horizon to finish it all off, but expect a nice neutral, sterile name for it.

My professor for Nazi Germany history this semester...

jarrod21 (Diary) Tuesday, February 24th at 1:52AM EST (link)

…has really done a lot to open my eyes.

The NSDAP had “socialist” right in their name. He explained how you can have socialism on the right as well as the left. He also explained how fascism can occur on both the right and on the left.

It’s just weird having a history professor who isn’t just a slobbering leftist. He’s actually, horror of horrors, criticized the current regime for misrepresenting the financial “crisis” and set a student straight when she said that the New Deal ended the Great Depression…came the next class with charts and everything. Yeah, it’s bad out there, but it’s nowhere near what it was, and it’s not going to get there.

The parallels are creepy. We’ve got our own little Fuhrer cult in this country now and Hitler himself said something to the effect of noise being an acceptable debate tool in the face of opposition. I don’t have my notes handy to get the exact quote. But seriously, just being loud and obnoxious is step one of the democrat playbook these days.

I still say we’re closer to a replay of the French Revolution in this country, however. I mean, sure, they say they’re against capital punishment for criminals, but they wish we were all dead, and a lefty loves his hypocrisy like a fat man loves cake.

 
 

Nothing I can add to this

kowalski (Diary) Monday, February 23rd at 5:04PM EST (link)

There’s really nothing I can add to this except to say that I hope it doesn’t happen. I hope that the people on Obama’s team will begin to realize that Keynesian economics is not The Way out of the current financial situation that the United States finds itself in. I hope some of them begin to understand that a real message of Hope and Change begins with economic reality, not relying on Government workers to suddenly snap out of it and rise to the cause, as the Washington Post is hoping they will do.

OK I’ll add something to in anyway. ;) Great job, Achance. And…

What have those government workers been doing all this time that the percentage of GDP spent on government has risen so high? Reading this article in the Washington Post, you might think they’ve had it *tough* until now, spending taxpayer money.

[Author's note: that article is good for a lot of laughs.]

We know very well what the answers to this crisis without destroying the world and positioning America to lead again will require. We know those answers pluperfectly. Obama is going to have to make a very serious choice: between continuing to do what the people who elected him think is right for fantastic reasons having to do with their fantasies, or what people who actually run businesses in the United States know must really be done.

Precious little business investment is going forward worldwide. The only chance for the United States to recover is if we can capture most of this investment. How can we do that? We would have to convince businesses that this is the best country in the world in which to invest and operate.

What we need to promise

At a minimum, here are the things that we need to promise business managers:

— world’s lowest percentage of GDP (among developed nations) spent on government; only with a low spend will investors have faith that taxes will stay low

– corporate governance that relieves investors from worry that profits will be siphoned off by management

– flexible capital expense depreciation schedule so that a company doesn’t have to pay taxes when it is cashflow-negative

– world’s best school system and best educated workers

– world’s cheapest transportation system and one that is virtually

– free from uncertainty caused by congestion

– predictable product liability system

– less labor market regulation

– immigration that encourages high earners

We need them all. Otherwise the probability of your scenario outlined above, as gloomy as it sounds, becomes much greater.

Is anyone listening?

BTW, people say, "Kowalski are you crazy?"

kowalski (Diary) Monday, February 23rd at 5:26PM EST (link)

They do. They say this to me a lot, and in one of those tones of voice that signifies they think I’m either tilting at windmills and shoveling waste against the tide.

However, it is in Barack Obama’s power to really make changes to the government that will avoid the worst-case scenarios mentioned above and give people real reason for hope. It’s in his power as the President, and I am hoping he is listening, because even though this is a Republican and Conservative blog that Charles Schumer would wave away on the Senate floor, Barack Obama hopefully is not Charles Schumer, and also hopefully he’s not entirely the creature of the people who helped him get elected.

If he wants to help the United States recover economically, in other words, I’m willing to help him, and I’m not going to take the refexively knee-jerk position that has characterized our politics for the past 8 years now. What is done is done. We’re better than that.

President Obama, listen to the words long written down, and find the courage to do what is really right for the United States of America.

Kowalski, he doesn't want the US as we know it to recover.

Achance (Diary) Monday, February 23rd at 5:56PM EST (link)

He wants to essentially take over the means of production in the same way the Nazis “coordinated” business and industry in Germany. Let’s see: you need credit to run your business. You get credit from banks. The banks are owned or in hock to the government. In order to get credit, you do what the government wants you to do. Pretty simple stuff, really.

In Vino Veritas

It's a grim picture

kowalski (Diary) Tuesday, February 24th at 7:20AM EST (link)

It’s a grim picture and I agree that it’s a scenario that has a legitimate possibility of happening in reality. I don’t know what to do to prevent it, aside from recommending articles like this one and continuing to say the things I say.

There are some banks that are not owned or in hock to the government, because they continued to adhere to conservative financial principles even when it wasn’t hip to do so any longer. Of course as you point out, if we get rampant stagflation as a result of these economic policies, having what little money you have left on deposit in those banks won’t be much of a bulwark against the “heat or eat” question.

A few months ago I read an economist from Princeton who wrote very directly about the problems that injecting all this federal money into the American bloodstream could cause. It seems to me that what Obama’s advisors are trying to do is cause a pulse of inflation to “counteract” the deflationary slide that has gripped the American economy. I don’t know whether anyone is smart enough, or more importantly could act quickly enough and in a targeted enough way to make that strategy work.

I suppose that one of the signs that it’s not working will be if “serious thinkers at important conferences” start talking about altering the way the CPI is calculated. My eyes will be wide open.

 
 
 
 

Gosh Achance...

Darvin_Dowdy (Diary) Tuesday, February 24th at 8:57AM EST (link)

…so many parallels. Thanks for bringing this perspective. We have a chance to learn from history here. One thing you said that really struck a cord with me:

“One thing I admire about thoughtful communists is the fact that they work very hard at understanding their defeats.”

Would that only the Movement Conservatives be so introspect. One of the reasons I’ve been so brutally hard on them in some of my posts? Because they have been so short on self analysis. The grim picture you’ve painted can all be avoided if Repub’s can take back one or both of the legislative bodies come 2010, in my view. And stop some of this crap dead in its tracks, if they have the backbone to do so. But at this point I don’t see the GOP doing near enough to achieve that goal. Darvin Dowdy

 

The Defense is Already Planned

jerry38 (Diary) Tuesday, February 24th at 2:48PM EST (link)

There are two policies already in motion that it could be argued will be used to 1) Disarm the right, and 2) Nullify the need for military cooperation. If one is looking at them in this way, then it shows that the administration is expecting rebellion before there is a chance for the military to be converted.

These two pieces are the proposed gun laws under HR 45, the Blair Holt Firearm Licensing & Record of Sale Act of 2009, and Obama’s DOD Directive, 1404.10 the DOD Civillian Expeditionary Workforce.

http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/z?c111:H.R.45:

http://www.dtic.mil/whs/directives/corres/pdf/140410p.pdf

The short of it is that HR 45 allows the government to know where every gun is located (no matter how long ago you bought it), and criminalizes anyone who fails to tell the government where their guns are. The Civilian Expeditionary Workforce are the modern brownshirts who will come and get your guns.

If HR 45 passes, and if Obama can hold off until these are in place. Then at the first sign of the militant right acting up, a state of emergency will be declared and gun ownership will be outlawed. The Civilian Expeditionary Workforce will be sent around very quickly to collect all the guns and those who have “misplaced” their guns will automatically be in violation of HR 45 and subject to jail. Rebellion ends before it begins and the military will not be pressed into service at all.

“Justice is always naive and self-confident; believing that it will immediately win once recognized. That is the reason why the forces of Justice are so poorly organized. On the other hand, the Evil is cynic, sly and fantastically organized. It never ever has the illusion of the ability to stand on its own feet and to win in a fair competition. That is why it is ready to use any kind of means without hesitation. And of course it does – under the banners of the most noble ideas.”

–Vladimir Bukovsky

Rebellion ends before it begins

izoneguy (Diary) Tuesday, February 24th at 2:53PM EST (link)

Not if you are a good shot

The point cannot be made often enough: Modern liberalism, as embodied in the Obama presidency, is the defender of the status quo. And the status quo is a road to economic ruin. Political forces cannot redistribute the wealth that the economic system does not produce.

 

I hope that they are that hopelessly naive

E Pluribus Unum (Diary) Tuesday, February 24th at 3:03PM EST (link)

That plan is hopelessly flawed on multiple fronts. Just one example:

The CEF will either consist of a bunch of gun enthusiasts (meaning they’re far more likely to turn on an oppressive government than to participate in rounding up guns) or not (in which case a bunch of non-gun thugs are coming to try to take the guns away from a bunch of fun enthusiasts).

Fail!

Kill the Terrorists
Protect the Borders
Punch the Hippies h/t IMAO

I believe your right

jerry38 (Diary) Tuesday, February 24th at 3:23PM EST (link)

…that that sort of plan, if it is a plan at all, would fail, but its a shaky belief and I pray we never find out. But if they get away with HR 45 and they know where all the guns are, it certainly gives them a big advantage. I like to think of all libs as easily defeatible to, but then the whole point of the CEF seems to be for Obama to arm whatever liberal tough guys actually do exist. Like the Govenator for example, or Robert Redford – those libs can handle a weapon.

“Justice is always naive and self-confident; believing that it will immediately win once recognized. That is the reason why the forces of Justice are so poorly organized. On the other hand, the Evil is cynic, sly and fantastically organized. It never ever has the illusion of the ability to stand on its own feet and to win in a fair competition. That is why it is ready to use any kind of means without hesitation. And of course it does – under the banners of the most noble ideas.”

–Vladimir Bukovsky