Advice to Republicans from a Disheartened, Retiring House Democrat


Rep. Brian Baird, a retiring six-term Democrat from Washington state, relays to John Fund of the WSJ the advice he would give incoming Republicans:

“Governing isn’t as easy as you think. Many of you have taken pledges that are contradictory—to balance the budget and cut taxes, for example. You must be honest about the numbers, since our annual deficit now exceeds all discretionary spending combined. If you set as your goal to roll back the size of government, you have an obligation to answer the tough questions and show real courage, not just appeal to ideology. Treat the voters like adults.”

Surprisingly, I found myself agreeing with much of what he had to say1.

Last night, I was listening to Mark Levin, and a couple of callers brought up their fears that some incoming members might not stay as conservative as advertised once they get to DC. Levin lit into them. Can we guarantee that each and every new Representative will follow what they laid out in their campaigns? Of course not, shot back Levin, but that lament flows only from those not willing to do the work to hold our elected officials feet to the fire once the 2010 elections are over. Eternal vigilence is the price of freedom.

RedState readers are familiar with the entitlement problem the US Government is facing. And who thus far has shown the courage to acknowledge the problem and propose a realistic solution involving some of the inevitable pain? Not Barack Obama, who is seeking the cover of a “bi-partisan commission.”2 As far as I know, only Representative Paul Ryan R-Wisc has proposed a realistic solution/roadmap involving painful allocations of limited resources to get the adult discussion started.

We must continue to engage, and not let the 2010 campaign principles fall by the wayside as the Democrats did following their 2006 victory. Regarding “the most ethical Congress in history”, Baird acknowledges and laments

Before the 2006 election, he says, Mrs. Pelosi had 30 members working on a rules package to make the House more ethical and deliberative. “We abandoned all that work after the election, and leaders told us we should trust them to clean things up. I don’t know a single member of the Democratic caucus who saw the final rules package before they voted on it.”

Among his many examples of Democrats succumbing to the love of power, Baird cites a lack of fiscal transparency3

“We initially had numbers a bit more honest than the Republicans—we at least included war costs in the budget,” he says. “Now we’re authorizing programs for three years instead of five in an attempt to pretend we’re saving money.”

The difficulty for those taking Baird’s view of the world is that the trappings and perks of power go hand-in-hand with the types of programs he would support. All it takes for statists to siphon from Big Government programs is a little subtlety or sleight-of-hand. See Harry Reid’s fortune.

Conservatives, on the other hand, will find the trappings and perks of power in conflict with their principles. Of course, many will stray. But it will be our job to be vigilant, and to call them on it. There is hope for America in the newly engaged citizenry.

This is not the beginning of the end, but rather, only the end of the beginning.


1 The most glaring, obvious exception is his second vote in March for ObamaCare. He originally voted against it in November.

2 What result did we get when we fed our pre-surge situation in Iraq to the CYA dynamics of a bi-partisan commission? THe totally predictable timid groupthink.

3 I concede to his criticisms of the Bush fiscal stewardship, although I retain my view that Obama’s level of irresponsibility is the Bush level on steroids.



RSS feed

5 Comments Leave a comment

Cutting tax RATES has always produced higher revenues

renny (Diary) Saturday, October 30th at 8:33AM EST (link)

Coolidge helped created the boom of the 20s with tax “cuts,” JFK “kick started” the 60s with tax cuts, Reagan generated almost 25 years of ec. success with tax rate cuts (and except for the CRAs, Fannie and Freddie, and the Fed.’s interest rate manipulation that helped promote the credit freeze of 2008, Reagan’s revolution would be rolling on), and George W.’s tax cut in 2003 gave us an improved economy, 4.36 unemployment, and more revenues than the previous rates had produced.
The WSJ wrote in 2006, as the Dems. took Congress, that the deficit had been cut to 2% of GNP, and if the ec. continued, by the end of Bush’ term, the deficit would be 0. Of course, it didn’t happen.
The Dems. have used tax and spend in the entire 1930s, under Johnson, under Carter, and now with little o, and they have NEVER produced long-term successful economies.
The Johnson off-budgeting of Vietnam and then his raid of the Soc. Sec. trust fund in 1968 are the forerunners of entitlement bankrupting and stupendous public debt while setting the stage for the stagflation and doldrums of the 70s and early 80s.

 

great piece

wonkish1 (Diary) Saturday, October 30th at 9:38AM EST (link)

Don’t really appreciate the tax cuts and cutting spending line, but he’s a democrat.

Otherwise, great article.

“First you win the argument, then you win the vote.” Margaret Thatcher

Conservative Innovations I Want To See Succeed
http://rightnetwork.com/ –New conservative TV network
http://actright.com/ –Fundraising hub for all things conservative
http://connect.freedomworks.org/ — Connecting Tea Partiers around the country
http://procinct.net/ –GOTV walk/call lists
http://www.citizensunited.org/ –Their documentary arm

As you say, he's a Democrat

6eorge Jetson (Diary) Saturday, October 30th at 1:31PM EST (link)

and that line isn’t the point.

Dealing with massively overpromised entitlements will involve pushback and will require courage. We can continue with our all-you-can-eat healthcare buffet/arrangements (healthcare consumers pay a marginal 13 cents out of pocket for every healthcare dollar spent) and just wait until the social contract crashes. Got a runny nose? Go see the doctor. Or the country can move toward true healthcare insurance (as opposed to a prepaid ordinary services consumption plan).

In one of Frank Luntz’s focus group, an audience member howled at the notion of a $2,000 deductible. The cost of my family health insurance is $18k / year! We can confront those howls with incentives that maximize consumer’s utilities, or we can let our overpromised entitlements consume our nation.

i can tell we are going to get along well

wonkish1 (Diary) Saturday, October 30th at 6:40PM EST (link)

You and I hit on the exact same things. FYI, paul ryan is my favorite congressman.

And this is the rights think tank on healthcare:

http://www.healthtransformation.net/

I also love the book, “saving lives, saving money” I recommend it to you.

“First you win the argument, then you win the vote.” Margaret Thatcher

Conservative Innovations I Want To See Succeed
http://rightnetwork.com/ –New conservative TV network
http://actright.com/ –Fundraising hub for all things conservative
http://connect.freedomworks.org/ — Connecting Tea Partiers around the country
http://procinct.net/ –GOTV walk/call lists
http://www.citizensunited.org/ –Their documentary arm

Welcome to RedState, Wonk

6eorge Jetson (Diary) Saturday, October 30th at 7:24PM EST (link)

Glad you’re here